5 ms·
>every syllable is a word in its own right, and multisyllable words are compound words[ This is an artifact of the writing system. Mandarin Chinese has multisy
by foldr 10y ago
>every syllable is a word in its own right, and multisyllable words are compound words[
This is an artifact of the writing system. Mandarin Chinese has multisyllabic words in exactly the same way that e.g. English does.
http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3330 http://languagelog.ldc.upenn.edu/nll/?p=3330
- nneonneo 10y agoDespite the article's enthusiasm for polysyllabic characters, these remain exceedingly rare in day-to-day use, whereas polysyllabic words in English are basically unavoidable. There's no equivalence here. The writing system remains very strongly monosyllabic, in that one character corresponds to one syllable >99% of the time.
- foldr 10y agoThe point I was referring to is that the words are not all monosyllabic. The existence or nonexistence of multisyllabic characters is irrelevant. Character != word. https://www.jstor.org/stable/595185?seq=1 https://www.jstor.org/stable/595185?seq=1
- nneonneo 10y agoAh, I see. I was confused because you linked to a LanguageLog article specifically about polysyllabic characters. Yes, indeed, "compound words" as mentioned by the GP post are just plain words that are composed of multiple characters.
- foldr 10y agoYes, I should have explained that I was just referring to the examples of multisyllabic words at the beginning of the post, sorry.
- david-given 10y agoI don't really follow here. One of the examples of a multisyllabic word given is fēijī, 飛機, 'aeroplane'. But this breaks down into 'fly machine', which is a classic example of a compound word. Later on it talks about 'library', túshūguǎn, or 'picture book museum' (according to the dictionary I just found). Again a compound word, and one which raises fascinating questions about whether they had museums before they had libraries. The article says that it can be written as a single character, 圕, or as multiple characters, 图书馆, but surely that's just an artifact of the writing scheme?
- foldr 10y agoThe meaning of the compound words isn't predictable in general -- a library is not in fact a picture book museum. And remember that many multisyllabic words in English are composed of morphemes with a distinct meaning, with varying levels of compositionality. E.g. we would not say that "airport" is two words just because its meaning has something vaguely to do with the meanings of "air" and "port", or that "return" is two words because it can be split into "re" and "turn" (again with each component contributing some element of its usual meaning). But of course, you can imagine a parallel universe where the orthographic conventions of English are such that we write "air-port" and "re-turn", and such combinations are referred to as "compound words". As far as I can see I'm not saying anything controversial here. As the article I liked to earlier points out, there are at most a few thousand distinct syllables in Mandarin Chinese, and it would be absurd to suggest that Chinese is limited to a vocabulary of a few thousand words.
- david-given 10y agoDo you have any examples of multisyllable words in Mandarin which don't break down like this? I have yet to find one. Note that just because a word is a compound word doesn't mean it's not a word. A compound word has a meaning which is distinct from the sum of its parts; otherwise it wouldn't be used. But the meaning of a picture book museum, or fly machine, or language law, though, is still quite clear. But a library has nothing to do with lies or bras, and the last syllable isn't even a valid word. ('Airport's not a good example in English because it actually is a compound word. Contrast with 'sea port'.)
- foldr 10y agoI'm not sure why I'm being downvoted for this. It is a trivially verifiable fact that Mandarin Chinese has multi-syllabic words, and that these are not particularly uncommon. It's also trivially verifiable that the writing system is (to an extent) syllabic, which can give rise to the misperception that each character is a word and that each word is monosyllabic. This is all widely available, easy to verify information.