6 ms·
We can't help everyone. It's naïve to think we can, 100% of the time, help all people. Even the most socially progressive system on the planet will have people
by dijit 10y ago
We can't help everyone. It's naïve to think we can, 100% of the time, help all people.
Even the most socially progressive system on the planet will have people slipping through the cracks- we have to be able to deal with that eventuality too.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoTrue but at the moment we have a particularly poor record of helping people with mental illness. This guy didn't slip through the cracks, he was totally ignored along with many others who are struggling.
- DanBC 10y agoThere's absolutely no evidence he had mental illness, and you do harm to people with mental illness when you incorrectly link violent behaviour to mental illness. More important is his time in prison - where most UK terrorists were radicalised - and if you were saying that UK prisons don't rehabilitate I'd agree.
- stagbeetle 10y agoIs brutal violence against others not associated with mental disturbation?
- DanBC 10y agoViolent people are violent. They may also have mental illness, but usually it's coincidental. In this specific case there's no suggestion he had mental illness, and it's ignorant to suggest he did.
- stagbeetle 10y agoViolent people aren't violent because they are violent. There is an underlying cause for someone to use force against another, especially when it is socially unacceptable. Perhaps it doesn't fit under the "common" mental illnesses of depression, anxiety, etc. but it lines up well with thought disorders. A sane and well person would not jeopardize themselves, and their fellow species.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> A sane and well person would not jeopardize themselves, and their fellow species. Sane (by the usual definition, though it's possible you are using an unusual definition of your own) people jeopardize themselves to harm other members of the species all the time. In fact, societies tend to have organized groups of people who are expected to do this when the targets are enemies of the group, and who are honored for it; they also not infrequently honor people who independently do it against people theor society has decided are "the enemy".
- dragonwriter 10y agoThere are some mental illnesses for which are associated with violence, but much violence is not associated with mental illness.
- brokenmachine 10y ago"absolutely no evidence"... except the random crazy violent act against innocent strangers that made international headlines. It's a bit odd to pretend those are the actions of a well-adjusted, sane person.
- DanBC 10y agoMost violent people do not have mental illness. You cause harm to people with mental illness when you ignorantly link violence to mental illness.
- brokenmachine 10y agoWe're not talking about "most violent people" or regular domestic violence. We're talking about someone who ran random pedestrians down on purpose on a footpath and stabbed a police officer for no reason. This is an outlier. Even though it doesn't fit your ridiculous PC SJW agenda, I would be willing to bet he's got some kind of mental health issue. I don't think that's a controversial opinion to hold.
- sctb 10y agoPart of having a civil discussion is leaving things like “your ridiculous PC SJW agenda” right out.
- brokenmachine 10y agoActually, I didn't find it civil to be accused of "causing harm to people with mental illness" by "ignorantly linking violence to mental illness." I don't think it's ignorant to ask the question if someone who did that is right in the head.
- DanBC 10y agoYou didn't ask a question. You saw behaviour that you didn't understand and immediately made an assumption: it must be the result of mental illness. You are saying two things: 1) He is violent because he has a mental illness. 2) People with mental illness are violent because of their illness The reality is very simple: he was a violent man. He had always been a violent man. He had a long history of violent behaviour. He doesn't have a long history of contact with MH services, and he never had (as far as I know) any contact with secure MH units[1]. Some men are remarkably violent, but most of them know exactly what they're doing and they're not controlled by an illness. The prevalence of violence, and mental illness, means that obviously there's some overlap between "people who are ill" and "people who are violent", but you need to be really careful not to say "the violent people in that overlap are violent because of their mental illness". When looking at predictors of violence we see that mental illness doesn't give you much if any predictive power. Substance misuse does; previous episodes of violence does; and any (especially all) of these combined does. The reason it's important to avoid incorrectly linking violent behaviour to mental illness is seen in the stats of people shot and killed by US police: about half the people shot and killed each year are people with mental illness. The vast majority of them pose zero risk of harm to other people, maybe some risk to themselves, but they get killed because people like you keep pushing the "mental illness == violent and dangerous" myth.