6 ms·
I'm going to play devils advocate here, I also dislike the erosion of privacy (enough that I even left the UK). But you _can_ make the argument that if only ou
by dijit 10y ago
I'm going to play devils advocate here, I also dislike the erosion of privacy (enough that I even left the UK).
But you _can_ make the argument that if only outlaws use encryption then they're painting a target on their back, which leads to greater scrutiny by security services.
This is reasonably achieved by the current dragnet surveillance systems in place, along with ISP's logging everything.
I don't agree with it, of course I don't, but that's probably an angle people could take- But the angle Amber Rudd took is even more starved of sense.
It's like she didn't ask the appropriate question: "What could we have done to prevent this attack" and the follow up "If we had direct access to his phone and all of his communication information, what could we have caught" and the answer is _nothing_. He used tools commonly available to him, acted alone, probably told nobody.
Anyway, tell the bad guys you're watching the comms and they'll figure out how to talk, they're motivated and smart.
- tonyedgecombe 10y ago"What could we have done to prevent this attack" Actually there is a lot they could have done to help him in his obviously troubled life but that doesn't fit with conservative ideology.
- dijit 10y agoWe can't help everyone. It's naïve to think we can, 100% of the time, help all people. Even the most socially progressive system on the planet will have people slipping through the cracks- we have to be able to deal with that eventuality too.
- tonyedgecombe 10y agoTrue but at the moment we have a particularly poor record of helping people with mental illness. This guy didn't slip through the cracks, he was totally ignored along with many others who are struggling.
- DanBC 10y agoThere's absolutely no evidence he had mental illness, and you do harm to people with mental illness when you incorrectly link violent behaviour to mental illness. More important is his time in prison - where most UK terrorists were radicalised - and if you were saying that UK prisons don't rehabilitate I'd agree.
- stagbeetle 10y agoIs brutal violence against others not associated with mental disturbation?
- DanBC 10y agoViolent people are violent. They may also have mental illness, but usually it's coincidental. In this specific case there's no suggestion he had mental illness, and it's ignorant to suggest he did.
- stagbeetle 10y agoViolent people aren't violent because they are violent. There is an underlying cause for someone to use force against another, especially when it is socially unacceptable. Perhaps it doesn't fit under the "common" mental illnesses of depression, anxiety, etc. but it lines up well with thought disorders. A sane and well person would not jeopardize themselves, and their fellow species.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> A sane and well person would not jeopardize themselves, and their fellow species. Sane (by the usual definition, though it's possible you are using an unusual definition of your own) people jeopardize themselves to harm other members of the species all the time. In fact, societies tend to have organized groups of people who are expected to do this when the targets are enemies of the group, and who are honored for it; they also not infrequently honor people who independently do it against people theor society has decided are "the enemy".