5 ms·
> "That is my view - it is completely unacceptable, there should be no place for terrorists to hide." I am sure a ban on encryption would work. Hey, guys, I j
by visarga 10y ago
> "That is my view - it is completely unacceptable, there should be no place for terrorists to hide."
I am sure a ban on encryption would work.
Hey, guys, I just had a great idea. Let's ban bombs, knifes, and driving into people. That would fix the terrorism problem. Once it is illegal, no terrorist would dare do it!!!
I'm wondering why Churchill didn't think to ban the Enigma machine. If only England was led by smart people like the British interior minister...
- pfortuny 10y agoWell, he wants to ban secret hiding places, not bombs. I am sure that might work. Come to think of it... Sorry, he is a she.
- mavdi 10y agoI'll be surprised if you don't get a full HN ban for this.
- Tharkun 10y agoWhile we're at it, can we also ban crime? That'd be great.
- fauigerzigerk 10y agoCouldn't we just ban everything illegal outright? Why take so many detours?
- userbinator 10y agoWhile we're at it, let's just ban living. Everyone born could become a criminal, right? </s>
- erelde 10y agoIt's, in my view, more akin to trying to ban mathematics in a world in which mathematics exist. Tools and weapons don't exist indenpently from us, mathematics do.
- wtbob 10y ago> Hey, guys, I just had a great idea. Let's ban bombs, knifes, and driving into people. That would fix the terrorism problem. They started banning guns almost a century ago. While it did probably reduce the number of gun murders, it certainly didn't make terrorist organisation like the IRA any less effective — and it probably made non-gun crime worse. Possessing encryption tools, lockpicks, knives, guns &c. is a fundamental human right of free men.
- seabee 10y agoShouldn't possessing surveillance tools be a fundamental human right in this hypothetical scenario?
- kakarot 10y agoNo, because we also have the right to privacy.
- drdaeman 10y agoI beg to differ. My (and everyone's else) right to have a copy of tcpdump doesn't violate you right to privacy.
- kakarot 10y agoSure, but how do you feel about a person's right over their personal information being systematically collected by their government, several large corporate entities, and a dozen or so international spy agencies? What about when this information is used to economically bind them into submission?
- drdaeman 10y agoAh, but that's about how the tools are used, not what they are and who has them. I believe, any entity, from a mere individual to a government agency or multinational corporation should be free to possess any software tools they may desire. How they use those is another matter. I do "spy" on my own traffic on my own network running on my own hardware on my own premises. I've had some audits for possible malware/spyware, did reverse engineering protocol analysis, etc - and believe everyone should be able to do that. I shouldn't be able to do this on someone's else traffic without their informed consent - nor technically, neither legally (I believe, both of those aspects are important). As for your question - I don't like this, of course. Don't think there is anyone well-informed and in their sane mind who does.
- adrianN 10y agoThe difference is that it's relatively easy to detect when people use encrypted communication. You can just arrest them. It's not so easy to detect whether someone is planning to drive into people.
- nine_k 10y agoThey forgot to ban steganography, didn't they?
- AnthonyMouse 10y agoCompare like with like. It's plenty easy to detect whether someone is driving. Whether they're planning to drive into people has the same level of difficulty as whether their encrypted communications are about terrorist activity, so shouldn't we ban cars? And buses and planes and anything else with wheels or an engine? If we banned planes that would certainly have prevented 9/11. What better argument could there be?
- mirekrusin 10y ago...we've all been there in US before 1999 where exporting strong crypto had $1mln penalty with long prison terms, basically classified together with chemical/biological weapons. It was recognised that it's impossible to enforce, ie. PGP is there, in general tech is just available to anyone and what about research papers and academia? Treat them as criminals? Even if banned in UK, it's available in the rest of the world. It would be nice if politicians were banned from saying stupid things.