3 ms·
If they can't get their way, the browser vendors can just shrug and make their own rules, that's what happened for Ballot 169 for example. Ballot 169 says to v
by tialaramex 10y ago
If they can't get their way, the browser vendors can just shrug and make their own rules, that's what happened for Ballot 169 for example.
Ballot 169 says to validate DNS names in a certificate you can't just make up any old "validation method" and say you think it's adequate, you must use at least one of these specific enumerated methods.
The Ballot passed, but then a bunch of CAs declared that they had patented some of the methods on the list. So effectively even though it passed Ballot 169 was unwound while they negotiated patent licensing agreements.
But Mozilla meanwhile went "everybody must obey Ballot 169 or get kicked out of Mozilla's trust store", so that raised the bar anyway.
The happy news is that a mix of Mozilla saying "comply or feel free to go out of business, we don't care" and people like me pointing at the crappy patents and laughing at their weak excuse for "innovation" appears to have had the desired effect, and a new Ballot will reinstate the stuff from Ballot 169 later this year.