3 ms·
A meritocracy would provide equal access to the top of the profession The Platonic ideal version would anyway. In real life, has anybody ever seen such a merit
by mindcrime 10y ago
A meritocracy would provide equal access to the top of the profession
The Platonic ideal version would anyway. In real life, has anybody ever seen such a meritocracy? Luckily, as it happens, the extent to which something is meritocratic is a continuum, not a binary choice.
But all of that is still orthogonal to my point, which is that hard-work and effort and all of those things still "count" even if they don't get you to the 1% level. If I work really hard and don't wind up making a million dollars a year, I may still wind up making $250K, which will be more than my friend who slept his way through school and is working at McDonalds as the night shift manager.
- brudgers 10y agoMost people who work at McDonalds are not night shift managers and becoming one would be a massive step up in earning potential. But often it goes to someone whose socio-economic inheritance is such that their friends make $250k. Most people work hard and put a lot of effort into finding better jobs and still work close to or at some small multiple of minimum wage (median household income is ~50k in the US). It's not because the slept their way through school. It's because $250k jobs are in the low single digits of jobs and the number of jobs is a fraction of the population and so those positions are highly selective and optimized against false positives which means 'getting to "no"' quickly is preferred over detailed scrutiny and taking a chance on someone.
- mindcrime 10y agoThen if I don't make $250K, maybe I wind up making $130K. Whatever, the exact numbers aren't the point. The point is that individual effort, work ethic, etc. still count even in a world that isn't a pure meritocracy. Again, this is a continuum, not a binary dichotomy. It's not because the slept their way through school. It is for some of them. Probably even for a lot. Unless my high-school was highly atypical, there was a pretty big divide even at that age, between the people who really worked hard and tried to excel, and the ones who were just going through the motions, goofing off, and drifting through life. And my experience suggests that that continues throughout life. Go to any company and you'll find people who are putting in extra effort - going to night school to get an MBA, working extra hours, taking MOOCs, going to industry conferences, whatever it might be, working to advance themselves. You'll also find people who show up, "punch the clock" and do the minimum required to not get fired. And while we aren't in a perfect meritocracy, I'm pretty sure that if you could acquire the necessary data, you'd find a positive correlation between that individual effort, and (salary|position|etc). But some people seem to think that because we live in a world that isn't a perfect meritocracy, that that somehow obviates the value of initiative, work ethic, etc. completely.