3 ms·
The headline is just wrong. Yes, there was some correlation between "class cues" and resume response rate. But the overwhelming finding (like, 4x the effect!)
by ajross 10y ago
The headline is just wrong. Yes, there was some correlation between "class cues" and resume response rate. But the overwhelming finding (like, 4x the effect!) was gender. Upper class men were wildly more popular than any other group. And in fact upper class women actually underperformed their lower class sisters.
- emodendroket 10y ago"Subtle class cues can backfire" seems like a factual assessment of the finding that being a lower-class man or upper-class woman hurts your chances of being called back.
- ajross 10y agoBut it's not symmetric. Women and lower class men don't get the same response rates, but they're clearly in a cluster of broadly similar numbers. Upper class men are enormously advantaged in this study. And that finding is being buried by the headline.
- emodendroket 10y agoThe finding for women is less pronounced but it's not what a lot of us would expect and it's worthy of examination too.
- ajross 10y agoBut once more: if you had to write a headline for this data, why pick a subtle effect due to class instead of a glaring one based on gender?
- icebraining 10y agoBecause the sample size is bigger, hence the statistical significance is stronger. The other is more likely to be a fluke.
- Mvandenbergh 10y agoSure, but which bit is surprising? 1) Upper class men find it easier to get interviews at elite law firms - Well, sure, we could all have guessed that! 2) Men find it easier than women to get interviews at elite law firms - Not as obvious, but ok, sexism is a real thing so not staggering. 3) Upper class status actually hurts women despite massively helping men - That's actually surprising, isn't it? If privileges were simply additive then you'd expect upper class women to be somewhere between upper class men and lower class women with the exact order depending on whether class or gender prejudice was stronger.