5 ms·
Older workers are more likely to utilize health insurance for major procedures. More claims will drive up group health insurance rates. For a business that subs
by brudgers 10y ago
Older workers are more likely to utilize health insurance for major procedures. More claims will drive up group health insurance rates. For a business that subsidizes employee health insurance, this is a bottom line cost. For a business that does not, higher health insurance costs are still a competitive disadvantage.
Because health insurance is so expensive, the costs can be non-trivial and not hiring older workers can be economically rational. The cost of adding people who utilize health care services to the pool establishing group policy rates is why employer provided health insurance policies typically excluded pre-existing conditions until it became illegal.
As fear of going without is a brake upon entrepreneurship, the rate increase from older workers is a brake upon productivity that derives from national health care policy.
- stevenwoo 10y agoI worked at a startup 25 years ago, and we had trouble getting group health insurance for our company of just over a dozen people because the accountant was over 50 years old, and it's not like we were going to fire him to get insurance. I imagine the problem is different today with ACA.
- brudgers 10y agoThe costs are higher today than 25 years ago. A dozen employees at $150/month/employee (10% increase at $1500/month) is nearly $50k/year. That's meaningful money in a lot of contexts. It's also worth considering that most older job candidates aren't in a highly skilled occupation like accounting where experience often adds value. Most employees are more fungible, particularly outside the world of startups. Just for clarity HIPAA changed the landscape for pre-existing conditions in 1997.
- cookiecaper 10y agoWhile this could be a worry for some smaller companies, I think there are more significant costs involved with employees who are closer to retirement than not. This becomes more serious the older one gets. When retirement becomes a short-term prospect (within 5 years), it gets really bad.
- intrasight 10y agoIf the average duration of tech employment is less than five years, how is that relevant?
- cookiecaper 10y agoBecause you don't know which of the five years the employee will select to retire, and because they're getting into the range where it's not unreasonable to suppose that over a period of some years, they may need long leaves of absence to address medical conditions, etc. To be clear, I'm not justifying this attitude. Just explaining how it can be expensive to have older employees, even excluding potential impact on group insurance rates. Of course, on the flip side, you get a lot of benefits from a highly experienced, highly mature workforce.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y ago>> Because health insurance is so expensive, the costs can be non-trivial and not hiring older workers can be economically rational That is not rational- it's selfish and greedy. It's also very short-termist, because everyone grows old eventually (or at least hopes to). If we all don't hire older people, we'll all be without a job further down the line. Failing to establish the conditions that will allow older people to be employed is not being rational. It's being completely incapable of thinking more than a few years into your own future. Honestly- when did "rationality" become synonymous with "tunnel vision"?
- brudgers 10y agoEconomic rationals provide an explanation. They does not imply the behavior is moral or ethical absent some theory that equates economic rationality with moral/ethical propriety.
- BoysenberryPi 10y agoHe said economically rational which it is. It has nothing to do with whether or not the decision helps you sleep well or not. From a pure economic perspective its the right decision to make.
- YeGoblynQueenne 10y agoI'm so not making a moral point. What I'm saying is that, practicallly speaking, thinking only of yourself in the here and now is in the long run detrimental to your own best interest, counterintuitive as that may be. Selfishness is not rational. It's dumb people's rationalisation of their own short-termist stupidity that calls it rational.
- BoysenberryPi 10y agoYou said you are not making a moral point then proceed to talk about selfishness and morality.
- memracom 10y agoThis is not an issue in Canada (Vancouver). Or in the UK (London) or in Germany (Berlin) where everyone is in one national health insurance group. And the three cities that I mentioned all have thriving startup cultures. And American citizens are welcome to immigrate to all these 3 countries as well.