4 ms·
People say Uber needs self-driving cars in order to survive. But how realistic is it that we have self-driving cars without a backup human operator anytime soon
by Kiro 10y ago
People say Uber needs self-driving cars in order to survive. But how realistic is it that we have self-driving cars without a backup human operator anytime soon? If someone needs to be behind the wheel anyway I don't see how it's cutting any costs.
- HenryBemis 10y agoGive it time. Soon they will have a foothold (aka presence) all over the planet. By the time they do this the auto industry will be able to produce a reliable self-driving car and regulations will be catching up. Then someone who owns a self-driving (preferably electric) car will be "renting" his/her car to Uber for the hours when he/she does not need it. The uber will THRIVE using someone else's vehicle, kicking the responsibility for maintenance etc to THEM and Uber will be collecting a nice 5-10-20% cut JUST for the service provision (booking, ACH, etc).
- BillinghamJ 10y agoI actually don't expect they'd be successful using arbitrary people's cars. These marketplace companies don't tend to do very well when the supply side of the market isn't properly prepared for the nature of operating in the marketplace - i.e. most Uber drivers are exclusively Uber drivers - it isn't really car sharing any more. The time and effort would shift away from dealing with drivers who know where they stand, to providing constant support to upset car owners. Quickly, it would switch to the supply primarily being provided by large businesses who own 1k+ cars because the economics stack up well in large quantities. At that point, Uber might as well just buy the cars directly and cut out the middleman.
- bunderbunder 10y agoI don't think they will thrive in that scenario. Uber's got a few advantages, but I think they mostly boil down to being the first ones to have an app, and having a whole bunch of VC cash to pour into a business that hasn't proven to be any more profitable for them in the past few years than it has been for everyone else over the past couple centuries. They've got one big disadvantage, which is that the fleet maintenance costs for their service model are extraordinarily high. There are no in-house mechanics, and there's no fleet standardization. They've been able to get by without that through a combination of that VC money, and being able to shift the fleet maintenance costs onto the ledgers of their drivers, who presumably aren't generally factoring those costs in when forming a business plan. I don't know when self-driving cars will be fully autonomous. But it seems a pretty safe bet that, by the time they do, their advantages in the app and the VC cash department will have eroded away. By that point we're back to the same old commoditized, race-to-the-bottom industry that, minor departures aside, has characterized taxi service since the horse and buggy days. At which point there's no room for individual owners anymore. In that kind of industry environment, the people who have standardized fleets and in-house mechanics will always be able to outcompete the people who need to pay Volvo dealer prices for vehicle maintenance. I also don't know when self-driving cars will be cheap enough that typical individual owners will have either the need or the inclination to massively jump their depreciation rate, or to subject them to wear and tear by random strangers. But it seems a safe bet that's going to be a long way along the technology's maturity arc. I, personally, wouldn't be willing to lay down cash to bet whether the long term looks like a bunch of individuals renting out cars they own anyway, or people mostly not owning cars because it's not worth the trouble to own one anymore. For my part, though, I'm more keenly interested in the latter - right now, for me, the main value proposition behind owning a car is that it's kind of a hassle to haul myself to a car rental shop when I want one for a weekend trip. That hassle disappears when they can just send the car to me instead. tl;dr - Uber's "sharing economy" model, attractive as it sounds, never really made a whole lot of economic sense in the long view. Their more likely futures are to either become one of the traditional taxi companies, or be squashed by them.
- ghaff 10y ago>I also don't know when self-driving cars will be cheap enough that typical individual owners will have either the need or the inclination to massively jump their depreciation rate, or to subject them to wear and tear by random strangers. So many "car sharing" discussions seem to be predicated on the idea that auto costs/depreciation are time-based. In fact, they're probably a lot more mileage-based, especially in areas that don't get snow. So that extra 25K miles that get put on a "shared" car are not remotely free just because you already own the car anyway.
- maxerickson 10y agoIn that scenario the one thing they bring to the equation is a famous brand. That doesn't give much of an edge when it is easy to try a different service.
- darpa_escapee 10y agoThis guy drank the 2014 sharing economy Kool Aid. The end-result of these services is that we'll be renting from Uber/whatever, not the other way around.
- bamboozled 10y agoWouldn't self-driving cars available to all mean they're out of luck and lost the the advantage they were hoping to exclusively obtain? It would be easy for locally owned competitors / taxi companies to be competitive with the added bonus of tayloring the service to suit the clients. Why would you assume Uber would have exclusive rights to use people's vehicles, IMO it will just start price wars to the bottom right ? Why would stop others from building booking software and leasing it ? How do you ensure the third party vehicles are clean and up to standard etc? Sorry, but I don't see it.
- bamboozled 10y agoWouldn't self-driving cars available to all mean they're out of luck and lost the the advantage they were hoping to exclusively obtain? It would be easy for locally owned competitors / taxi companies to be competitive with the added bonus of tayloring the service to suit the clients. Why would you assume Uber would have exclusive rights to use people's vehicles, IMO it will just start price wars to the bottom right ? Why would stop others from building booking software and leasing it ?
- lumberjack 10y ago>But how realistic is it that we have self-driving cars without a backup human operator anytime soon? The whole, "in case of emergency, grab the wheel" is just a legal formality. If you are not actively driving you won't be in a state of mind to be able to do that. I think eventually there will be enough data to show that a human behind the wheel does absolutely nothing to prevent a crash.
- hartator 10y agoThe human being the wheel is actually intervening kind of a lot. That's the issue not legalese.
- ceejayoz 10y agoCurrently, yes, but as these get better, there's going to be a really dangerous middle ground, where the car is great in 99.99% of cases but can't handle the rare exceptions. The human driver dozing off or browsing Facebook on their phone simply isn't going to be paying enough attention to realize they're barrelling towards an active train crossing or whatever the unexpected edge case is.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- maxerickson 10y agoThe whole, "in case of emergency, grab the wheel" is just a legal formality. It's looking to be just the opposite, with several of the autonomous projects mumbling about how they don't think it is a workable level of automation, exactly because people don't stay engaged. They are going to try to jump from assistive systems like automatic braking to vehicles intended to handle unexpected driving conditions without immediate human intervention (maybe the system can't proceed, but it will safely stop).
- mtgx 10y agoYes, I'm a pretty big Tesla fan, but this has been my main criticism against Tesla's cars. The most rabid fanbois don't want to believe it, and just buy Tesla's argument that it's the driver's fault when an accident happens while AutoPilot is running, because he "didn't take the wheel in time." I think Ford's study proved that humans can't react quickly like that if they don't already drive the vehicle, and I was able to figure that out myself simply through intuition, way before Ford discovered it. I also think that internally Tesla does believe the same thing, which is why it has pulled its "self-driving" ads from around the world. It's just publicly continuing to say that if there is an accident then it's the drivers' fault "because there are plenty of warnings" (like 200 miliseconds before a crash) or that it asks you to put your hands on the wheel every 5 minutes, as if that does anything. An accident could easily happen in-between those 5 minutes. I guess that feature is there because Tesla also learned that people keep dozing off when a car is self-driven. But I think people who start dozing off because they aren't driving the car themselves will be able to ignore the sounds relatively easily. The bottom line is that such systems put humans in an almost impossible situation that they're not equipped to deal with as humans, and Tesla and others act like they're legally covered and that's all that matters. I think there should only be two types of systems: autonomous features that only activate in emergency situations to save people's lives (like auto-braking when there is an accident about to happen), and complete self-driving that doesn't need a human's attention at all. There shouldn't be anything in between.
- CPLX 10y agoWho knows. But it seems damm sure that the first successful use case isn't going to be a self driving taxi if they do ever exist. It's arguably the most difficult of the common use cases. Uber's strategy seems literally insane.
- IanCal 10y agoReally? They seem like pretty decent things to build first. Owned by a company so the failure of one isn't a huge deal (difference between at worst having to switch cabs compared to losing your own car for a few days). Costs are already high. Costs can be spread out. Costs are very important to the customer. People expect to be sharing the same space as others have used before them. Limited expected range and run time. Customers are already not in control, and taxis are not well known for careful driving in many places (fairly or unfairly). Speed is not a huge issue (can't run trucks limited to 25mph). Can pick locations city by city, so you could run an effective business if you can do London but not rural Wales.
- bunderbunder 10y agoNah. It's long-haul trucking. There's a much easier on-ramp to profitability because you don't have to solve the whole problem at once. You start by just automating the highway driving, which is a much easier problem than city driving. You might still need the human operator to deal with the off-highway driving at the beginning and end of each journey, but in the middle they can just hang out in the cab and work on their PhD dissertation or whatever. At that point your business has become quite a bit more efficient, because you've gotten rid of the need for your trucks to be stationary for 10 out of every 24 hours. So that's already a big win for tackling a relatively small piece of the problem. You can keep chipping away from there, and each increment will net even more returns.
- madeofpalk 10y agoI thought long-haul trucking was a given. I'm still believing that taxi/uber service will be the first consumer facing application.
- Spooky23 10y agoThat's just part of the pump and dump scheme that is Uber. Handing out $20 bills to entice people to accept a ride isn't a sustainable business model... robot or no.