3 ms·
> Blake: I mean, far and away my favorite book is Atlas Shrugged […] Eehh. Atlas Shrugged is surely great in its own way, but I’m not sure it really is a grea
by teddyh 10y ago
> Blake: I mean, far and away my favorite book is Atlas Shrugged […]
Eehh. Atlas Shrugged is surely great in its own way, but I’m not sure it really is a great choice to be a favorite book.
- notahacker 10y agoI've always suspected that half the people that praise Atlas Shrugged have read the plot synopsis rather than the book[1], and Scholl talking about everyone in the book being a pilot makes me wonder if he's one of them[2]. I mean, there is a sequence where one of the protagonists pilots a plane, but there's an awful lot more assumptions the survival of society is dependent on capitalists building enough miles of train track. If I liked the book and was running an aerospace startup I'd probably be more stoked about all the heroes being mechanical engineers... [1]Seriously, the premise of Atlas Shrugged is the great entrepreneurial capitalist novel, but if I passionately believed that the government was so restrictive towards the activities of private enterprises that they actually were on the verge of scaring all the entrepreneurs away, the last thing I'd want people to read to persuade them of this peril would be a tome populated with playboy hereditary billionaire geniuses and philosopher pirates to the point where the whole idea seemed a bit ridiculous [2]Looks like he's in the thread to correct me on this :-)
- johan_larson 10y agoI'm pretty sure it's one of the diagnostic criteria for egomania. "Only we, the very special people, can do the essential work that enables modern society to function. If you don't let us do it our way we'll just walk away and watch the world burn."
- smoyer 10y agoI came here to say exactly this ... perhaps this book should be on a classics list but I have no desire to reread it every few years. Books like that are in a completely different category and even within that category there are only a few I'd call my favorite.