2 ms·
If you notice serious problems with federated messaging, it's an entirely valid choice to abandon federation instead of trying to make federation work. There's
by PeterisP 10y ago
If you notice serious problems with federated messaging, it's an entirely valid choice to abandon federation instead of trying to make federation work. There's no evidence that a system that's (a) federated, (b) open to everyone and (c) non-spammy is possible in the first place; maybe it is, but even more likely you have to choose two out of three at best.
- kethinov 10y agoI don't see anyone repeating this fallacy w/regards to email. The only difference between email and federated IM is email started out (mostly) federated and IM systems started out (mostly) not. Only inertia is what drives this skepticism of federation in IM. Just as there is no technical reason GateKeeper couldn't succeed on iOS just as it does on macOS, there is no technical reason federation couldn't succeed in IM as it does with email. Just perceptions have to change.