5 ms·
XMPP federation with third-party services providers will no longer be supported starting June 26. Fuck you, Google. Just fuck you...
by mindcrime 10y ago
XMPP federation with third-party services providers will no longer be supported starting June 26.
Fuck you, Google. Just fuck you...
- jkarneges 10y agoParent shouldn't be downvoted. Depression and/or rage are among the valid responses to this part of the news.
- zokier 10y agoThe writing on the wall for this has been up for a long time. Raging for something that has been so predictable is not reasonable, there has been plenty of time to plan for this contingency and act accordingly.
- mindcrime 10y agoCalling this "rage" is probably overstating the situation a bit. Strong annoyance is probably closer to the truth. But you have to understand, I'm something of an ideologue when it comes to open standards, open source, etc. So this really sticks in my craw.
- thrill 10y agoI wish someone at Google would explain their overarching strategy and target. This piecemeal approach just reeks of no coherent plan.
- maverick_iceman 10y agoI doubt they have any coherent strategy in the messaging space.
- zokier 10y agoThrow shit on the wall and see what sticks? Isn't that what pretty much everyone is doing?
- bigkm 10y agoOnce it sticks and everyone is using it, then shut it down
- vocatus_gate 10y agoIt's sad but true. I can hardly trust any Google products any more because you never know when they're randomly going to give it the axe for no apparent reason.
- rhizome 10y agoThey don't appear to have much of a coherent strategy in the product space.
- keymone 10y agoHow about coherent strategy within a company?
- yeukhon 10y agoWell, it is not a big secret on many occasions people tell the outsiders Google would have multiple teams working on the same, if not, similar product, only to find just one will launch publicly, and then 6-24 months later the service will shut down.
- ballenf 10y agoIf you remember whose Google's customers are--advertisers, not users--coherency is a lot easier to understand. So it's really easy to predict Google. Just ask the following questions: - can Google run ads to every user of the product? - can Google extract usage data to build a better user profile, in order to charge more for above ads? The answer with regard to Talk or any interoperable service, is almost always no to both. The incoherency we see is related to the fact that not every engineer or manager at Google is fully plugged into the above or sometimes they create a product that fails to answer the above with the hope they'll figure that out later. Sometimes the nature of the product or the fact that it's an open standard makes it impossible to evolve the product to get the questions right. I loved that I could use my native Mac messaging app to communicate with colleagues in google chat. It was real-time and all messages were logged and available in gmail. I guess that's going away.
- remir 10y agoI agree. Where is Sundar? Larry? Sergueï?
- sah2ed 10y agoA googler already summarized their strategy succinctly up-thread [1] as: Google is a feudally organized collection of fiefdoms and this shows in their product strategy. [1] https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13951918 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13951918
- martin1975 10y agoyep, and neither Larry nor Sergey are strong, commanding personalities like Jobs was w/Apple - they're mega geeks, good at what they do, but at the level of the game they're playing, they need a firmer vision/hand to manage the direction of the company... and remain open at the same time instead of building walled gardens. They're slowly turning into Apple....
- zekevermillion 10y agoSeriously, Google owes me $50 for my obihai router I bought solely for free google integration. This is the problem with building anything on top of Gsuite -- they will screw you over at a random moment and deprecate whatever service you may have been relying on.
- pgrote 10y agoI think it'll still work, right? Google Voice is still supported.
- Danihan 10y agoDon't give them any ideas..
- radiorental 10y agoI think this relates to apps that utilise gtalk. Obihai is integrated with gVoice. Is there something I'm missing?
- zekevermillion 10y agoOK, if they still support XMPP for Gvoice then I am an idiot and I take back my comment. There was a threat awhile back that they would remove XMPP support for Gvoice (and thus I would have to pay for a service to use with my obihai). But that seemed to have gone on the back burner for awhile.
- radiorental 10y agothanks for the clarification.
- accountface 10y ago>owes me >solely for free google integration Dude, you get what you pay for
- lousken 10y agotime to switch to matrix I guess
- jkarneges 10y agoGoogle doesn't support the Matrix protocol either, unfortunately
- vidarh 10y agoBut seeing as we can't trust Google to keep supporting their own stuff from one moment to the next, nor can expect their own services to interoperate with each other, perhaps we shouldn't particularly care which protocols Google supports.
- lousken 10y agoI meant stop using google for communication for good, even if they'd supported it, they could drop the support any time
- rsoto 10y agoI'm sorry, I'm not really into chat protocols, but what does XMPP federation mean? For what I understand I will be able to login via Pidgin into my Gmail account, but not from a custom domain, am I right? Either way, GTalk was such a clean, centered and small IM experiencie +10 years ago, Hangouts is just a mess.
- jkarneges 10y agoFederation is where different service providers can communicate with each other, like how email works. Meaning, you could login to Gmail (whether gmail.com or custom domain) and send messages to users with accounts on non-Gmail IM providers (practically speaking this meant hobbyist, corporate, or university IM server deployments; Google was the only major consumer IM provider to adopt a federated protocol). The shutdown is unfortunate news because the only way IM is going to be as open as email is if two major consumer providers step up and do it. We had 1 and just needed 1 more. Now we have 0.
- gjjrfcbugxbhf 10y agoI believe that at one point a Google chat user could talk with a facebook chat user.
- martin1975 10y agoFederation means not having to reinvent the chat wheel for the umpteenth time.... Who was that quote from - physicists stand on the shoulder of giants... software and IT stand on each other's toes. Sad but true.
- ISL 10y agoApropos? https://developers.google.com/talk/open_communications https://developers.google.com/talk/open_communications
- jkarneges 10y agoIndeed! Much different leadership back then: Service choice is something you have with email and, for the most part, with your regular phone service today. [...] Unfortunately, the same is not true with many popular IM and VOIP networks today. [...] The Google Talk network supports open interoperability with hundreds of other communications service providers through a process known as federation.
- pmilot 10y agoWelcome to The Cloud, where you basically void all rights for long-term support of any product.