4 ms·
Electron apps are most certainly not functionally indistinguishable from native apps. They are always much larger and always seem to consume orders of magnitude
by swiley 10y ago
Electron apps are most certainly not functionally indistinguishable from native apps. They are always much larger and always seem to consume orders of magnitude more resources (memory, CPU.) If despotify still worked I would absolutely use that instead of the slow, buggy webview based official client.
People want native apps because they don't want the cooling/memory/power consumption from the web, as well as their delay tolerance and consistent UI. Electron can only provide the second (and sometimes the third.)
- a85 10y agoThat's a valid concern and I believe all developers who are working on the platform will address this. If memory/power consumption on laptops was so draining just because something was in HTML/CSS/JS, I believe people would have stopped using browsers or probably just stuck to 1-tab per browser.
- Ajedi32 10y agoPerformance is a property of an application as a whole, not just the framework it's built on. While you can certainly argue that apps which use webviews are slower on average than their native counterparts; Electron-based apps aren't necessarily always going to be slow; and native apps aren't necessarily always going to be fast. Therefore, since a user cannot conclude that an app is "not native" merely by observing its performance, Electron apps cannot be said to be functionally distinguishable from native apps merely because they're slower, on average, than other applications.
- debaserab2 10y agoPeople conclude things based on their experience using them. There are a lot of bloated feeling electron apps out there that are popular right now, which leads to people concluding (not incorrectly) that electron apps tend to be slower than native ones based on their experience.
- a85 10y agoAgreed. However, perceptions change as technology improves and overall the arc of software tools has been towards higher level abstractions unless absolutely required to go deeper.