3 ms·
I try not to use pesticides myself on my hobby farm, they do have many downsides. However, I invite people to go visit their local organic farms, where you wil
by cmrdporcupine 10y ago
I try not to use pesticides myself on my hobby farm, they do have many downsides. However, I invite people to go visit their local organic farms, where you will find the following suboptimal approaches to weed control:
- Extensive rototilling / plowing / cultivation, soil disturbance: damages soil structure, increases erosion, releases carbon locked in the soil worsening global warming.
- Propane burners strapped to the back of a tractor, torching the weeds.
- Extensive use of volunteer or cheap manual labour -- look up WWOOF... true-believer volunteer "WWOOFers" make up a significant labour force at organic farms.
Finally, you will find that most organic farms are just growing green vegetables or fruits and some small scale livestock. Which is great, but frankly on a global scale what people eat the most of[but probably shouldn't] is primarily wheat, maize, rice, and casava. You won't find many organic wheat farms.
From my perspective the long term answer is to transition agriculture and foodstuffs away from annual herbaceous crops which require tillage and/or spray-down to perennial crops which over the long term build up soil structure and potentially lock carbon away rather than releasing it. For an example of research in this direction, take a look at The Land Institute's "Kernza" perennial wheat replacement: https://landinstitute.org/our-work/perennial-crops/kernza/ https://landinstitute.org/our-work/perennial-crops/kernza/
Agriculture is probably the biggest contributor to global climate change through the combination of deforestation, intensive hydrocarbon usage, and the damaging of soils. It is imperative we figure out a way to get it right, and the discussions of GMO or pesticides are frankly a distraction from this problem.
- bryanlarsen 10y ago"You won't find many organic wheat farms." I've seen them and they're ugly: - on a good year yields are 50% of neighboring fields - on a bad year (1 in 4) they don't even bother harvesting because the only thing growing there is weeds - huge sand dunes along the fence line because over-tillage has caused massive erosion - algal blooms and fish die-off in the nearby waters because of erosion and manure fertilizer - even the animals aren't better off because frequent tillage destroys their habitat
- erroneousfunk 10y ago> Extensive use of volunteer or cheap manual labour -- look up WWOOF... true-believer volunteer "WWOOFers" make up a significant labour force at organic farms. In addition WWOOFers often violate labor and immigration laws, sometimes just by figuring "this doesn't apply to me." After all, labor laws are for brown people who want to make money and plan on moving to the country -- not for middle class young white people who are doing a fun "work-cation" activity for a noble cause, right!? I have a few friends (from the US) who traveled to various parts of Europe to work on organic farms, in one case an Italian vineyard, and didn't bother applying for any sort of work visa, just did everything as a "tourist." Of course, they were all compensated in the form of room and board, but didn't bother reporting it or considering it as "income" like they're supposed to. I'm sure there are many Europeans coming over and doing the same thing.
- jeromenerf 10y ago> It is imperative we figure out a way to get it right, and the discussions of GMO or pesticides are frankly a distraction from this problem They contribute to our contemporary vision of agriculture, which is intensive, mono specific, high yield, mechanized, subsidized, etc. Short term. GMO and pesticides optimize our current way of growing stuff but won't change it. I don't know about scaling progressively the permaculture ideal to world scale but it feels like a good ideal. I would not be shocked if a sustainable system would require us quadruple our effort (which is pretty much what third world is up to).
- cmrdporcupine 10y agoYes I agree with you. This is my problem with GMO -- not the 'frankengene' pseudo-science crap, but the ecological/economic problems you are mentioning here. But as someone who ran in permaculture circles for a bit, I am highly skeptical of that ideological bucket, too.