4 ms·
> If you want to see less pesticide use, do some actual science to prove your point; don't resort to polemical nonsense. I agree with everything you said, exce
by criddell 10y ago
> If you want to see less pesticide use, do some actual science to prove your point; don't resort to polemical nonsense.
I agree with everything you said, except maybe this. Polemical nonsense can be more effective than science if you are trying to alter policy or public opinion. If that weren't true, global warming wouldn't be controversial.
- sametmax 10y agoSomething I wish more scientist minded people would understand. Moving people people has nothing to do with being right. If you care about a topic, education is only a long term investment. You need a short term action has well, and it can't appeal to logic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- tonmoy 10y agoHaven't heard anyone say GW is controversial except in the US
- criddell 10y agoIt's political in Canada too.
- nkoren 10y agoI don't disagree with you as far as the effectiveness of polemic; more the ethics of it. Built on a rational/empirical foundation, a good polemic can engage hit people in both the guts and the brain. That's fine. But absent such a foundation, a polemic is just empty posturing. It might win, but to what end? And if we accept this as a legitimate way of arguing policy, then how what right to we have to object when others use the same tactic against us? I recognise that all over the world -- and especially in America -- the political sphere is increasingly dominated by people engaging in polemical arguments that consider facts to be essentially irrelevant. And yes, this is working for them. But if we stoop to that level, the contagion only spreads, and politics devolves into nothing more than tribal hooting at one another. Which is usually the last step before civil war. So we need to be better than that.
- criddell 10y agoThe ethics are complex. If the use of polemic speech spurs action on climate change, you are potentially avoiding (or mitigating) catastrophes. Sometimes the end justifies the means.