2 ms·
My argument isn't about apache 2 vs bsd. It is about the terrible legal issues relicensing other people's code without explict permission will create. The ti
by hedora 10y ago
My argument isn't about apache 2 vs bsd. It is about the terrible legal issues relicensing other people's code without explict permission will create.
The timeframes created by relicensing create particularly nasty problems. Here is an ordering of events where the developer and user act in good faith, but the troll wins:
First, a dev at Yahoo contributes under the OpenSSL license.
Years later, Yahoo sells to trolls (this is bad, but no one involved in OpenSSL did it).
Even later, openssl decides to relicense as apache 2.0. Maybe the dev clicks yes on the relicense form (big mistake, since the patent is not held by the dev or yahoo anymore), maybe the dev clicks no, or maybe they don't reply. Let's go with "no reply" or "clicks yes".
In those cases, openssl will not rewrite the code, and users will see that yahoo contributed to (now) apache 2 licensed OpenSSL and assume the patent protection apache 2 implies actually exists.
Some decide to use the code, instead of some other actually unencumbered alternative.
Later, the users get sued by the troll for violating the yahoo patent by running "apache 2" software yahoo wrote while yahoo held the patent. (When the troll bought the patent rights, the code was still openssl licensed, so the apache 2 relicensing definitely does not apply)
Even without the patent sale, openssl will be misrepresenting grants of patent licenses unless they rewrite all the "no" and "no response" code, including all the derivatives of code. The repo is at least two decades old, so a "no" response from the early days is probably impossible to recover from.
Anyway, the letter says they will treat "no response" as "yes", which clearly not going to hold up in court in most legal jurisdictions.
Claiming apache 2 licensing at the end of this flawed process is simultaneously false advertising and hostile to users.
It also hurts non-apache 2 downstream projects, or anyone paying enough attention to run away screaming.
Contrast this to what would happen if they simply removed the advertising clauses, making it GPL compatible: They'd need permission from many fewer people, wouldn't break downstream, and wouldn't make false statements about patent licensing.