3 ms·
One of the most brilliant things about HN is the comments in relation to the article not just the article. I had hoped it would include the discussion threads
by ThomPete 16y ago
One of the most brilliant things about HN is the comments in relation to the article not just the article.
I had hoped it would include the discussion threads from that too.
- bearwithclaws 16y agoI agreed. Still working on that. Trying to obtain the permissions from the commenters is harder than I initially thought. That will come in #2, hopefully.
- ThomPete 16y agosweet
- ErrantX 16y agoSuggest a way for us to indicate (maybe something in our profiles) agreement for you to use our comments and I suspect quite a few will support it. In case I didnt say before: you're welcome to use any of mine with attribution (if you want to edit long ones a quick email would be appreciated).
- bearwithclaws 16y agoThanks. If anyone wants to provide permissions to use their comments in HN, just email me at cheng.soon@hackermonthly.com.
- almost 16y agoMaybe PG would agree to put some text to the effect that "by posting this comment you give permission for it also to appear in Hacker Monthly unless you opt-out" on the comments page. I can't imagine many people having a problem with that but tracking down people after the fact is always going to be difficult. I do think it's going to need comments to be worth while. I have just bought a copy of the first issue anyway though :)
- jf 16y agoFrom the Hacker Monthly FAQ: Q. Will you include the comments of Hacker News? A. Of course. Similar to the articles, I will email the original commenters for permission. Oh, if you are a regular commenter in Hacker News, pretty please, put your contact information in your profile (a lot of the members just leave it empty), that would save me a lot of fuss trying to look for your email around the web. [ed: that means you ThomPete]
- mapleoin 16y agoHeh, I actually thought it would include only comments.