13 ms·
Remember Zip Disks? These Election Departments Do
- tomclancy 10y agoHow they have not suffered the "click of death" is a miracle.
- mirimir 10y agoDamn, you beat me :) I was an early adopter :(
- LeoPanthera 10y agoZip 250 (and above) drives do not have that problem. The Zip 750 drive can read Zip 100 disks, but not write to them. If you work in IT, a huge percentage of your knowledge (much like the above) becomes redundant with every year that passes. I think this is true more for IT than any other industry. I feel old.
- mikestew 10y agobought its voting equipment in 2002 Who the hell was buying new systems in 2002 that relied on Zip disks? Have them taken out back and shot. If they're dead, dig them up, kill them again. By 2002, most of us had figured out the unreliability of Zip disks, and the industry had pretty much moved on by then. Except the people selling voting systems, apparently. (For the youngsters, I'd guess that the use of Zip disks took a pretty good nose dive around the end of the 90s. By 2002, the only users left should have been those with an existing investment in Iomega's removable disk system.)
- M_Grey 10y agoCan confirm, was a youngster in my teens at high school during that time. I actually remember a friend getting a Zip disk drive, and immediately regretting it when someone else showed off their new CD burner. Heady days...
- dfox 10y agoIn fact, the disks themselves are surprisingly reliable, the totally unreliable part of the system are the drives, with the quite unfortunate fact that broken drive can create disk that breaks other drives.
- curun1r 10y agoHe also could be confusing Zip disks with the Jazz disks, which were only slightly better than writing your data to /dev/null.
- dredmorbius 10y agoWriting to /dev/null had the advantage of being far faster, and far more predictable.
- eridius 10y agoYou could say that about literally any storage mechanism. Writing to /dev/null will always be faster and more predictable, no matter what the alternative is.
- aidenn0 10y agobut Jazz disks didn't have any better data retention than writing to /dev/null, whereas most alternatives do.
- dredmorbius 10y agoBingo. Cheaper, too.
- micro-ram 10y agoGRC still has a utility for click of death. https://www.grc.com/tip/clickdeath.htm https://www.grc.com/tip/clickdeath.htm
- angry_octet 10y ago
- eli 10y agoThe Help America Vote Act of 2002 basically required states to buy electronic voting machines in a relatively short time frame and gave them federal dollars to help. It was a response to the "hanging chads" of the 2000 election. There was not previously a huge market for voting machines and the three or four existing vendors sucked. The law had strict requirements about making the machines available to people with disabilities, but not so much to say about security or reliability or robustness of the platform.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- hkmurakami 10y agoI think I was using mine around '98, on my second PC, which had about 10gb of storage. I think it was quickly obsoleted by CD-Rs and CD-RWs, though during its short lifespan on my desk, I feel like I enjoyed using it (then again I was a young teenager, so I definitely didn't push the technology into revealing its faults at all)
- Thlom 10y agoWhy not paper ballots? The trust is greater (you can't hack a piece of paper), it's idiot proof, can be counted electronically and hand counted in the case of dispute or even as part of procedure. And much easier to expand to more polling stations as you don't need any voting machines on site. Just paper and a secure box to put it in.
- cbanek 10y agoOf course you can hack a piece of paper. You can add more pieces, add misleading pieces, fake pieces, etc. And even with a secure box, there's always the risk of conspiracy to remove votes. Do I think this kind of thing happens? No. But encryption could be used to make the trust of voting even better, if done correctly. This would allow secrecy of votes, the ability to verify the validity of a vote without seeing who they voted for, and the ability to bundle the votes together and hash them, for example. Paper scales great, until you need to collect and retain it.
- Klathmon 10y agoBut those "paper hacks" take man-power, physical resources, time, and a lot of people. To do any of those across a state you are looking at at LEAST a few hundred people. Nation wide? Thousands. In a perfect world. With electronic voting, all it takes is one person at some point in the chain, or at best a handful of people.
- cbanek 10y agoWhy not have everyone in the chain sign? The point is you'd have to have a secure chain from the voter all the way to registration. I don't see how the number of people in the validation chain would change. The only real problem is a technological problem, like a bug or improper use of encryption. Especially if you're only trying to validate the results, and not trying to have secrecy. Each person signs / records the hash of the votes they're validating is. Combine those hashes together and sign that to validate at higher levels, or use something more fancy. It would be obvious if something got changed due to malice or fraud. What would this one person do exactly to sabotage the system?
- kome 10y agoPen and paper is a cost effective solution to all this technological crap...
- walrus01 10y agoCanadian federal elections are 100% pen and paper stuffed in cardboard ballot boxes.
- pacaro 10y agoI think that the fundamental problem is not the one technology. Election systems have this odd requirement (compared to most stuff we build) they are used both very intensively and very infrequently. These 15 year old systems have probably been used less than 30 times. From a procurement perspective it seems wasteful to need to replace something after so little use, but so many of the computer systems that we use have anticipated lifespans of only a handful of years. I suspect that an electromechanical system that records votes onto a medium that can be easily interfaced with technology du jour (and audited by humans when necessary) would have an expensive but long lived set of components that deal with the large numbers of voting actions, and then the ticker tape (e.g.) output can be read with a device that plugs into an off the shelf computer
- sowbug 10y agoZip disks were so awesome at introduction. Huge, rewriteable, removable, portable, and cheap (both hardware and media). And this was in an era where 28.8k modems were considered fast, so local storage mattered. But the day I burned my first CD-R a few years later in the mid-1990s, I felt like a god among mortals. Zip disks were mostly obsolete after that.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kalleboo 10y agoFor the same price, I had the choice of buying an external SCSI harddisk, a Zip drive, or a Syquest drive. (Syquest soon went bust so at least I dodged a bullet there) I went for the Zip drive and used it as basically an external harddisk. For the computer I had at the time (a 68K Mac), it was actually perfectly performant as a harddisk replacement - I had one disk of games, one disk of Office, etc.
- angry_octet 10y agoNo way, you had to master CDs, you needed a dedicated 700MB SCSI disk to write it too, then it took forever to burn (1x burners people, 1x). And you might have made a coaster. In contrast, ZIP disks were fast, scratch proof, reusable.
- pirocks 10y agoWhy is this marked as flagged? Is it advertising?
- ebbv 10y agoIt's an extremely low quality article with no real content or educational purpose and a clickbait-y title.
- frozenport 10y agoWe need an unflag button
- mikestew 10y agoThere used to be a "vouch" button. It either went away, or my privileges to do so disappeared.
- superioritycplx 10y agoBut that would make cheating much harder for Soros.
- dang 10y agoWould you please stop posting politically inflammatory comments to HN? That's not what this site is for. We detached this comment from https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13945582 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13945582 and marked it off-topic.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]