5 ms·
There may be attempted manipulation via flagging going on here as well: the story has 450 points over two hours and so should be glued to the top of the HN fron
by kibwen 10y ago
There may be attempted manipulation via flagging going on here as well: the story has 450 points over two hours and so should be glued to the top of the HN front page, yet it's only at seventh (and the comment count, at 288, is nowhere near the flamewar detection threshold).
- pera 10y agoIndeed, some people are flagging this entry, the question is: are they doing it because they are against political articles on HN, or, because they are part of some advocacy group trying to move this news from the top.
- epistasis 10y agoThere's another reason too: defense against cognitive dissonance. If it's one's "own team" that did something bad, and that person is unwilling to give up allegiance to their team, they will often act out in other ways to resolve the conflict. Especially since the partisan aspect of the issue is not headlined, the defenses will be similarly under the surface.
- simula67 10y agoI flagged this story and comments like this is why. If you want to argue the pros and cons of a government policy, do so. Reading accusations of astroturfing etc is not intellectually gratifying.
- __david__ 10y agoSo… you flagged because of those kinds of comments, those comments are there because you flagged it. That's kind of a self fulfilling prophecy.
- DoofusOfDeath 10y agoActually, it strikes me as more of a time-traveler's paradox.
- epistasis 10y agoMy assertions in particular are not about astroturfing, but about politically motivated flagging.
- macawfish 10y agoPart of that could be from peoples' adherance to the HN norm of "no politics allowed".
- hackuser 10y ago> the HN norm of "no politics allowed" That isn't a norm I'm aware of. There is plenty of politics every day on HN; there are some limits, but it's common.
- hawkice 10y agoI think there is a norm of "no purely political stories", and an expectation that it is a story the hacker news audience will care about. Internet privacy rules seem very much in-bounds.
- paulmd 10y agoPersonally I find the norm here of people constantly spouting off about "rules and norms" to be even more annoying. This community has active moderators, moderation is their job, not yours. If you don't like a story or a post, flag it so the moderators can do their jobs and move on. I would rather have a moderator look at a flagged post, determine it's inside/outside rules, and flag/unflag it, than have to read a dozen posts from the peanut gallery with snide rules lectures or debates on whether it's in the rules or not. (not quite a direct response to you in particular, more of a general observation)
- dragonwriter 10y agoThat's not an HN norm (though a temporary experiment in that direction was carried out), though a much weaker form of it is.