5 ms·
This guy seems like kind of a crank, and from what I've read he's wrong as often as he's right. For example, in the first article you linked to he his saying th
by Alex3917 16y ago
This guy seems like kind of a crank, and from what I've read he's wrong as often as he's right. For example, in the first article you linked to he his saying that the idea that acupuncture creates anti-inflammatory proteins is extremely improbable, which is exactly what the parent article proves. And his rant about not believing in the placebo effect is an equally ridiculous strawman, since there are studies that show that if you replace a person's medicine with a placebo they will keep having the same physiological response as they did to the medicine. (See also the converse, Plastic Rose Syndrome.) And, similarly, there are other studies that show that people gain less weight eating liquified food (which tastes bad) as opposed to the same caloric content of non liquified food, and still more studies that show that how much weight people lose from exercise depends more on how long they think they're exercising than how long they're actually exercising.
I'm all for sound science, but this guy seems like he's really just a shill for whatever the trendy assumptions-of-the-day behind western medicine happen to be.
- daeken 16y agoI'm interested in "plastic rose syndrome" but google isn't giving me anything that seems relevant. Happen to have a link to some info?
- ars 16y agoIt seems to be about allergies, so add that to your search. From what I can tell it's the idea that someone allergic to roses would also be allergic to plastic roses, if he thought the roses were real.
- Alex3917 16y agoThis is basically it, that someone who was allergic to roses would also have an allergic reaction if they saw a plastic rose. (The actual incident of a patient having an allergic reaction to a plastic rose was observed by a doctor in the late 19th century, but there are controlled studies showing placebos causing allergic reactions from the modern era.) That is why the anecdotes about allergies being cured with LSD make sense, because if the allergy was psychosomatic to begin with then it would make sense that someone could get over their fear of the substance under the influence of the drug.
- khafra 16y agoSounds like another name for a nocebo.
- tokenadult 16y agofrom what I've read he's wrong as often as he's right [citation needed] I linked to articles by more than one scientifically trained medical doctor, so "he" is not the correct pronoun, unless you are referring to the more-cited author in my reply http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?page_id=223 http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?page_id=223 in his role as executive editor of the Science Based Medicine site. He's not a crank, definitely, and the site has a number of pointed articles by various authors on the use of the "term" shill as an ad-hominem, invalid dismissal of scientific claims. http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?s=shill http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?s=shill
- Alex3917 16y agoMy bad, I thought all the articles on SBM were written by the same person. In any event, I stand by my claim that a lot of the articles on the site are crap. Just look at the article you referenced, which says that calling out pharma industry shills is just a "means of smearing those [...] who have the temerity to ask them to provide scientific studies to back up their assertions." And yet if you look at their article on the efficacy of antidepressants, the author says the meta-study showing that antidepressants are no better than placebos for mild and moderate depression is invalid because it excluded studies where the researchers wouldn't provide their data: http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=3722#more-3722 http://www.sciencebasedmedicine.org/?p=3722#more-3722 Double standard much? The author also criticizes the decision not to include studies that excluded placebo responders. WTF? The whole point of the study was to compare the effectiveness of antidepressants to placebos. How is it that SBM can advocate the use of antidepressants despite the lack of evidence of efficacy and the tons of evidence of dangerous side effects, whereas about medical marijuana they say that, "it’s hard to envision any situation in which prescribing marijuana would be ethical." I've read dozens of articles from that site, and the scientific rigor of their thinking seems to be limited at best.