8 ms·
> A talking lion would still be a lion. But it's not. Lions can't talk, almost by definition. A talking lion is necessarily a creature so different from a regu
by naasking 10y ago
> A talking lion would still be a lion.
But it's not. Lions can't talk, almost by definition. A talking lion is necessarily a creature so different from a regular lion that it can't reliably tell you what being a regular lion is like.
It's like how smartphones aren't really phones, they're computers with telephony capabilities. Calling them phones is ridiculous when you really think about it, but we apply that label for historical reasons based on their evolution from early phones. Still, opening up a smartphone won't really tell you anything about how regular phones work.
- thevardanian 10y agoTalking lions are just lions with trans-species communicating capabilities. Lion communicate with each other instinctively. They at the very least understand each other, whether we understand lions is a different point.
- naasking 10y ago> Talking lions are just lions with trans-species communicating capabilities. In other words, completely different brains than regular lions. So, not lions.
- scott_s 10y agoI agree with your position (and with Dennett's). "Talking" is not like an independent module with a lede you can attach to a lion's brain to get it to talk. It must be integrated with the lion's brain, and that necessarily changes the brain to the point that it's no longer a "lion." This is because even simple statements like "I am hungry" require the ability for sophisticated abstraction. "Talking" is more than mere vocalization, it's also the thought processes behind the vocalization. Once you've changed a brain so that it is capable of those sophisticated abstractions, it's no longer the same.
- thevardanian 10y agoIs a person missing half a brain, in a vegetable state with little hope for recovery not human?