8 ms·
Basic Attention Token
- rdl 10y agoI see no value added by using "blockchain" buzzword for a centralized system like this. It isn't even privacy protecting. This is an obvious use case for 1) some kind of database/book entry system, centralized, if you don't care about anonymity or 2) blinded Chaumian tokens, if you want anonymity (which has security/risk model costs)
- jypepin 10y agoSo publishers will receive BATs instead of $$? Can BATs be sold for money? The website only says "BATs can be used for premium content or services on the Brave platform.".
- Spivak 10y agoIt seems that the under this system advertisers have to buy BATs in order to show ads. Sorta makes sense. Sites get BATs for getting views, users get BATs for viewing ads, and advertisers need BATs connect to users.
- kolemcrae 10y agoAn interesting idea but I find it hard to see this taking off and becomming the norm. They need to sell it to Google or something so they don't have to rely on the browser. Also, rewarding users with "premium content" or let them "donate it to publsihers" doesn't seem too realistic. I like the idea but I see some major hurdles before this takes off.
- mdekkers 10y agoI see some major hurdles before this takes off. The understatement of the century...
- jypepin 10y agoSo users need to use their "Brave" browser? What do they gain from this, apart from earning "BAT"s that seems to only allow access to premium features on that browser? Also, what happens to actual real ads? Are they blocked and replaces by their own ads by the browser?
- sushisource 10y agoYeah. This seems a bit nonsense. The browser "blocks trackers"... while also tracking you. Smells like bullshit to me. As far as I can tell the main selling point is it's using the current buzzword that makes everyone get all hot and bothered: "blockchain"
- news_to_me 10y agoTracking is important for delivering "relevant" ads, which many people would prefer. The real issue is that the different ad networks spew their trackers across the web, without respect for users' privacy or user experience. I don't really think Brave's solution here is fully-baked, but the idea of replacing all those third-party trackers with one that's on-device and (presumably) I can have some degree of control over sounds like a step in the right direction.
- vkou 10y ago> Tracking is important for delivering "relevant" ads, which many people would prefer. I know that advertisers prefer this, but I'm not quite convinced that most users do. The most polarizing example of this is, of course, remarketing.
- news_to_me 10y agoI think it seems plausible. If any users get value out of advertising (and I think they do), then more relevant ones would have more value for them. That said, if advertisers simply respected "do not track", we could see for ourselves how true that is.
- duncancarroll 10y agoWhy should I switch browsers? Don't tell me it's just to help out advertisers.
- m12k 10y ago"Users also get a share of BATs for participating." Not saying it's a good answer, but it's right there on the page.
- sp332 10y agoIt hurts advertisers, but not as much as by blocking them. It's a compromise where you can support the owner of the site you're visiting without having to pay money, and without dealing with invasive ad trackers.
- jamespitts 10y agoPerhaps you might consider switching if that is the only way that you can get control over the information about you that leaks out on many pages that you visit, words on pages that your mouse hovers over, words that you type in, friends you make, and so on. Do you think that it might be impossible to get control over all of that information? It is possible, and it is happening.
- freeone3000 10y agoOr you could run firefox with ublock and privacybadger. Ads and tracking are blocked as well or better than with Brave, and as a bonus, I don't see advertisements.
- mdekkers 10y agoAny idea that starts with "and first, we get the user to switch their browser" has immediately raised their own barrier to entry so ridiculously high, were you to stand on top of it you'd be able to see the curvature of the Earth. What a stupid thing to do. They also list that 600 million devices are actively blocking ads, meaning these people went out of their way to not see ads. Now you want them to switch browser just so that they can see ads - are they on crack? BAT? BATshit crazy...
- libeclipse 10y agoThis. One hundred times this. I block ads, and I certainly wouldn't switch from Firefox to some random unknown browser for the privilege of seeing ads. Having said that however, if there was an option in Firefox to enable this, I may consider it if all other ads were still blocked.
- lou1306 10y agoThey're not ads. They just invite their partners to be our guest and share their tales.
- dazmax 10y agoGuessing the goal is to get something working well enough that Google will put it in Chrome. All of the problems they list hurt Google.
- news_to_me 10y agoI think the idea is that if advertising on the web respected users, they wouldn't feel the need to block ads. This is their attempt to make advertising work in a way that helps everyone. What's the alternative? If every web user blocked all ads, content creators couldn't get any revenue and would stop making content.
- mdekkers 10y agoWhat's the alternative? If every web user blocked all ads, content creators couldn't get any revenue and would stop making content. I understand the problem. I just think that this is a stupid solution. As for content creators getting revenue, how about selling it? Like we used to do?
- whalesalad 10y agoI feel like this is a promo website for season 4 of Silicon Valley.
- wonderwonder 10y agosponsored by Hooli
- liamcardenas 10y agoThis really doesn't make sense. With Bitcoin, I know there are lots of people who will accept them in exchange for real goods and services. With "BAT" Tokens, I don't know why anyone would want them. He mentions that tracking and adblocking are wasteful, but I view them as a beautiful example of how the market implicitly equilibrates itself to provide the "right amount" of advertising. I like Brave, but it seems to me that they are over-engineering a non-problem.
- ErikHuisman 10y agoThe idea might be: you can sell your bat for bitcoin to advertisers
- alexggordon 10y agoSomething a lot of these comments are currently missing is the fact that the video specifically described that: 1. The brave browser by default blocks ads and tracking software. 2. That advertisements are opt-in only in the brave browser. So while this is a subtle advertisement for the Brave Browser[0], I think this is also a clean separation from the browser in attempt to create a new form of advertising. While obviously those defaults can change, I'd imagine the reason for the clean separation between the BAT and the Brave Browser is because users would be significantly more hesitant to join if the "goal" of the browser was an alternative for of advertising. On that merit I would evaluate the browser separately from this idea. Ignoring the integration with the Brave browser though, one issue for this is that this doesn't solve the fundamental problem of a company that might have a boring product, that wants to advertise and is willing to pay for it. Google will take your money, and show your ads to the relevant market. People click on those ads, and drive engagement to the company. Most companies don't have exciting enough products to be able to drive engagement with simply the "product". Another issue is that if the BAT tokens are generated from users attention and the quality of the ads, and NO user information is stored like is claimed here, then there would engagement would most likely be significantly less than with other advertisers, as the advertising market is then expanded to all people, rather than the demographic the company is trying to hit. This would mean that whatever monetization form Brave comes up with is going to have to be a lot cheaper than what Google is charging, because I can almost guarantee engagement suffer drastically. Finally, as a quick test, I don't even see the browser succeeding on the basis of blocking "all" ad content, as it doesn't even block Facebook ads with the "block all ads" setting checked[1]. I'd imagine because Facebook sends their ads along with the actual page content, which I'd also imagine most other ad companies would figure out a way to do if Brave becomes more successful. [0] https://brave.com/ https://brave.com/ [1] http://imgur.com/kN8l8Ph http://imgur.com/kN8l8Ph
- mdekkers 10y agoFacebook sends their ads along with the actual page content I use Swipe Pro on my android, and it blocks those just fine
- srgseg 10y agoCan there ever be a mechanism that prevents people from reverse engineering the protocol to announce to the network that they're viewing ads, so that they can earn BATs for doing nothing? Their incentive would be to use these BATs to pay for premium content. This would undermine the value of BATs and damage the ecosystem.
- jamespitts 10y agoThe protocol would likely not allow BATs to be earned in browsers not properly implementing the protocol (measuring attention on a web page while protecting privacy, etc). And then instances of Brave and any other browser implementing this protocol could easily be cryptographically confirmed to the ad network.
- teraflop 10y agoHa! In related news, I've figured out a way to totally eliminate automated email spam. It involves replacing SMTP with a new protocol that doesn't allow messages to be delivered unless the sending server cryptographically confirms that a real human pushed the "send" button.
- al2o3cr 10y agoAnd then instances of Brave and any other browser implementing this protocol could easily be cryptographically confirmed to the ad network. Nevermind adtech, if they've invented tamper-proof remote attestation they should just start selling THAT. Otherwise, the botnets will all be running code that says "YEP DEFINITELY LEGIT U CAN TRUST ME" on every request.
- csense 10y agoYou don't really even need to go as far as reverse engineering the protocol to game the system. You can just run as many copies of the browser as you like, each in its own VM, and have scripted mouse/keyboard actions pretending to read content. Reverse engineering the protocol would probably allow a very resource efficient exploit, but it's far from the only point where the protocol can be corrupted by a user with fraudulent intent.
- etjossem 10y agoUser: why don't I just run an open source adblocker that doesn't serve me ads? Publisher: you are extorting me into using your platform by blocking my partners' ads. Advertiser: you are extorting me into using your platform by blocking my ads.
- news_to_me 10y ago> User: yes, but why don't I just run an ad-blocker and wait for the tragedy of the commons to befall content publishers? The problem with this is that it doesn't influence incentives in the right way. If your goal is to replace advertising entirely, there needs to be something to replace it. If your goal is to make advertising better, you need to reward the "good ads" (whatever that means) by selectively showing them. If you just don't care and don't want to see ads, I guess you're in the majority but you're not really helping anything.
- etjossem 10y agoI'm just thinking from the point of view of each of these actors. Users do not care about content publisher finances until their favorite site goes under. What some of them do appear to care about - day by day - is whether they see advertising or not. Those who are motivated to take any action at all are more likely to install an adblocker extension than switch browsers. For everyone involved in the ecosystem, Brandon Eich and Brave are starting out on the wrong foot.
- Analemma_ 10y ago> If you just don't care and don't want to see ads, I guess you're in the majority but you're not really helping anything. It's not my job to help anything. Other people's revenue models are not my problem.
- thr0waway1239 10y agoThis looks like too much effort. Here is a far simpler idea: just hypnotize people via ads so they willingly disable ad blockers, click on every ad they see and ultimately buy so much stuff they go broke.
- Splendor 10y ago> Brave is a fast, open source, privacy-focused browser > The Brave browser knows where users spend their time Well, which one is it?
- AgentME 10y agoThe browser is software running on your own computer. It can know that without sharing that information.
- davidgerard 10y agoWasn't Brave going to use Bitcoin?
- al_chemist 10y agoWell, it's Bitcoin (tm) Blockchain (tm) Etherum (tm) BAT (tm) alt-currency. It makes as much sense as the rest of the idea.
- clock_tower 10y agoI wonder which white-box browser this is built on.
- davidgerard 10y agoBrave, which is based on Blink.