4 ms·
"barely news...." "hard to find anyone that actually cares...." What Wikileaks is changing, and what has had a real effect even here on HN let alone out in th
by jerf 10y ago
"barely news...."
"hard to find anyone that actually cares...."
What Wikileaks is changing, and what has had a real effect even here on HN let alone out in the normal world, is that we didn't quite know that the government was doing all these things. We very very very much expected that they were doing these things, but we were never faced with cold hard evidence. And a great deal of the rest of the populace sort of vaguely expected that the government was collecting stuff, but when faced with concrete evidence of this fact, it became real. Even those who strongly suspected only suspected in very vague terms, but now we have details, which is qualitatively different.
If you want people to care, it seems you need this concrete evidence, not just very well-sourced supposition. I say "it seems" because I am not theorizing about this; I am observing the reality on the ground. It doesn't matter how true it may be theoretically that we shouldn't have needed this information, how we should have theoretically had all the info we needed to care, because I observe that we in fact we didn't have enough information to care, because largely, we didn't. If you want to counter that, please provide me with the observations that I'm wrong and people had enough to care, not just theory. (Though that will require you to contradict your own point that people don't care.)
I suggest to you that you meditate on where you got the idea that Wikileaks is a "threat" for releasing this information, which seems like it ought to help you towards your goal of getting people to care about these things, but which somehow you've talked yourself into trying to downplay and ignore. Who's the source of that idea, and who's pushing it? Are you sure you want to absorb the idea from those sources?
You don't have to "like" Wikileaks to use this information, nor do you have to trust their motives beyond ensuring that the provenance of the files are correct. I do suggest keeping in mind that they may still be filtering the flow (they are certainly modulating it, as they themselves say, so this is no accusation or anything), but you can still do correct logic on the information that is provided (assuming it is accurate). You just shouldn't do any logic based on what is missing. (However, I can't say I'm seeing very many people making that mistake.)
- 3131s 10y agoGP is lamenting the fact that this is "barely news" and the bit about Wikileaks being a threat was sarcasm.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- SomeStupidPoint 10y agoWhy should I care a spy agency has spy tools? (Which is all these leaks show.) I mean, the CIA could always have broken in to my house undetected and set up tiny microphones -- why should I worry now that they use computers as part of that, but not then when it was bugs transmitting radio? The reason people don't care now is why they didn't care then: so what? Do you really believe the CIA gives a shit about what you have to say?
- sanityUnbounded 10y agoThe logistics of breaking into a house undetected to set up tiny microphones suggests a lot of manpower, and to do that to each house in the United States would be near impossible without raising suspicion. The reason to care now is because it likely wasn't happening then. Also, whether the CIA "gives a shit" is irrelevant. It is still happening regardless, and you cannot know for certain what the CIA does and does not "give a shit" about. If you have documents showing what this data is being used for, do the world a service and release them.
- belorn 10y agoThere is this old joke that one should think like ones neighbor: its not me they want, its the neighbor. Joke a side, so long you are not political active, don't run a company, are not a doctor, a lawyer, or a priest, vote for the right political party, have friends with any of the above, or have children or spouse that are friends with any of the above, then it is likely that they don't care what you say. Just make sure you got a high enough citizen score.
- 1001101 10y ago> Do you really believe the CIA gives a shit about what you have to say? As we learned from the Snowden leaks, surveillance is being conducted on a massive scale under the purview of a secret court that rubber stamps whatever comes across its desk, and not in a targeted manner as in your bug argument. I still have a right and desire for privacy, which is not a function of whether or not the CIA, or anyone, cares what I say or do. This level of clairvoyance is too much power for any one person or group to have, and is of what Orwell and others have rightly warned us.