7 ms·
> Salaries for professionals are markedly lower, we live in much smaller houses etc. This is an age old debate, and it's very hard to compare one vast continen
by alkonaut 10y ago
> Salaries for professionals are markedly lower, we live in much smaller houses etc.
This is an age old debate, and it's very hard to compare one vast continent to another. Regional differences between US cities and European cities are at least as large or larger than the difference between the avereages of US and European salaries/living standards etc. The difference between central manhattan and rural Apalachia is just like the difference between the fancy parts of Stockholm and rural eastern Europe. There is just no comparison in Salaries, Life expectancy etc.
When it comes to those of us that are "winning", the difference is there, especially for some professions like doctors who can basically make a killing in the US but not in Europe. That is probably to do with that it's an economic risk/investment to get the MD in the US, whereas in Europe it's normally free. When you are a finished doctor you aren't entitled to a fancy car - we just paid your MD so you better get to work and be thankful ;)
To make a fair comparison between me (a software dev) and a comparable person in the US (in a similar metro area of ~1M people) you'd have to make a pretty tricky calculation involving costs of healthcare, childcare, money saved for retirement, pensions etc. On the bottom line I think the US person would make a bit more money, but on the other hand would have a worse work/life balance.
- J-dawg 10y ago> whereas in Europe it's normally free While we're correcting misconceptions, in the UK it's most definitely not free. But I believe it's still a lot cheaper than the US. The universities are capped on the fees they can charge, and your student loan is regulated by the government (you only start paying back when you're earning over a threshold).
- alkonaut 10y agoWhen I look at the UK from Scandinavia, it seems to me that it's basically "50/50 continental Europe and the US". Wage inequality, parental leaves, employment security, higher education etc.are decidedly "non-european" in the UK. So yes when I talk about "Europe" in the context of "Europe vs US" I think the UK needs to be considered separately.
- vidarh 10y agoYes, I'm Norwegian and moved to the UK, and it was a shock to see "US conditions" in Europe, and took a lot to get used to, even though the UK still have a lot of protections and welfare systems the US doesn't. (to the Americans: In many European countries "US conditions" is commonly used in political discourse as a way of scaring voters with the image of chaos and suffering)
- timoth 10y agoShades of grey though; not entirely black and white. In the UK->Norway direction, it's surprising to have to pay to visit a doctor or specialist, not to mention paying painful retail price for medicines, even for children. (Yes, I know there's an annual cap etc., but still seems a bit weird compared to free-at-the-point-of-use and a flat prescription charge in the UK.) No NHS dentistry either. (Yes, I know NHS dentist availability is not what it once was in the UK! And there are subsidies for necessary children's treatment in Norway depending on severity.)
- Accacin 10y agoWage inequality and higher education I agree with, but we do quite well with parental leave don't we (the UK)?
- dagw 10y agobut we do quite well with parental leave don't we Relative to the US, absolutely. Relative to Scandinavia, not really.
- emodendroket 10y agoIt'd be literally impossible to do worse than the US though.
- Accacin 10y agoI mean, we're talking about Europe as whole. The UK has the highest maternity though paternity is much worse but still better than quite a few EU countries.
- scottishfiction 10y agoWhile we're correcting misconceptions... it is most definitely 'free' in Scotland.
- alkonaut 10y agoEven though I'm swedish I did go to Scotish uni (Strathclyde!) for a while. It was probably paid for by magical EU funds though. I do remember registering and my peers talking about student loans but I thought they were like my student loans (which were for rent, food and books) and thought almost all tuitions were paid by govt. grants, not loans. I know at least a part of my friends had grants, not loans, paying their studies at least. What is the political situation now in the UK wrt. free higher education? It seems like one of the biggest social justice/social mobility issues a society can have. Is that not a top issue for Labour?
- scottishfiction 10y agoI also went to Strathclyde :) In Scotland at least, student loans are only used for living expenses, similar to your experience. Tuition fees are paid by the Scottish Government, as education is a devolved power [1]. In England, tuition fees are paid by the student, usually through a student loan, and are capped at £9k/year. [Warning: political] I couldn't answer on Labour's priorities. They're becoming increasingly irrelevant north of the border, and increasingly impotent south of the border. 1. http://www.parliament.scot/visitandlearn/12506.aspx http://www.parliament.scot/visitandlearn/12506.aspx
- J-dawg 10y agoHow could I forget! Thanks for pointing this out. Personally I'm surprised that there isn't a lot more anger from English taxpayers about this. It would be very interesting to see whether an independent Scotland could continue this policy.
- scottishfiction 10y agoI hope they are angry; at their own leaders for failing to provide the same, and not based in some misguided theory on Scottish subsidies, which is a far more complex issue than many tabloids would have their readers believe. Stats here paint are more nuanced picture: http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/are-the-scots-really-sucking-up-a-massive-subsidy-9723797.html http://www.independent.co.uk/news/business/comment/are-the-s...
- conanbatt 10y agoA software engineer in a startup in berlin earns maybe a median salary of 60k euros ayear at a 40% tax rate. Thats less of what interns make in the us at a 30% tax rate. An experienced engineer at google or facebook make 200k with a sizable signup bonus. As far as I know, theres no comparison between what a soft dev makes in the us and what he makes in europe. This is from someone that lives in south america, and is considering moving to either europe, NZ or America, and hands down america pays so much more than anything else. Not to mention that people criticizing work-life balance of engineers in the us havent visited google offices.
- probably_wrong 10y agoIf you end up choosing the US, and go to an at will state, keep in mind that your employer can fire you for wearing the wrong color of socks, even if they never told you which color is the right one (no, really). I think it boils down to whether you want to take care of yourself, or if you let the state do it for you. I would definitely take the 60K if it includes awesome public transport, unemployment money, affordable healthcare, a month of holidays, and having free time in the evenings for hobbies. Your priorities, of course, may be different.
- tbrownaw 10y agoIf you end up choosing the US, and go to an at will state, keep in mind that your employer can fire you for wearing the wrong color of socks, even if they never told you which color is the right one (no, really). Getting new hires up to speed is expensive enough that they'd be pretty stupid to actually do this. Sure a few do, but it isn't common. Also, a couple minutes with google turns up this: https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=AVD_DUR https://stats.oecd.org/Index.aspx?DataSetCode=AVD_DUR . If it says what I think it says, getting a new job really is easier in the US (like it should be, because as any economist will tell you this is what has to happen when a bad hire is less of a disaster for the employer). I think it boils down to whether you want to take care of yourself, or if you let the state do it for you. In part, yes. But also, there are two approaches to reducing downtime. You can increase MTBF (make things more reliable, make it harder to get fired); or you can reduce MTTR (make things easier to fix, make it easier to get hired somewhere new). Europe goes with the first approach, the US goes with the second (which I very much prefer, because it doesn't gum things up). Separately, there's also making downtime less of a problem (failover systems, all the various other social safety net things). The US is generally known to kinda suck at this.
- iicc 10y ago>...doctors who can basically make a killing in the US but not in Europe. Arguably that's due to constrained Supply - http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2013/03/the_high_price.html http://econlog.econlib.org/archives/2013/03/the_high_price.h...
- conanbatt 10y agoThis is related to one of the least favoured policy changes Milton Friedman wanted to make: remove medical licenses. There are plenty of tasks doctors are commanded with that do not require mastery level of expertise, and that enormously raises the cost of medicine. You dont need to study 10 years to read an EKG, someone could learn all the EKG patterns in a much shorter time. A funny story about this in argentina: anesthesiologists earn more money than surgeons. Surgeons are not unionized, but anesthesiologists are.
- 0322317_anes 10y agoI have never heard that anesthesiologists make anywhere close to what specialized surgeons make. Where are you getting this information from?
- conanbatt 10y agoSurgeons and anesthesiologists in Argentina. Is a famous trade quirk here. I think surgeons cannot unionize by law, but anesthesiologists can, but im not sure about that.
- emodendroket 10y agoIn the US increasingly NPs and PAs are being used instead of regular doctors for primary care.
- rubber_duck 10y ago>is just like the difference between the fancy parts of Stockholm and rural eastern Europe It's really not - in the EU the difference between median net income in say Norway 41 483€ or Denmark 28 364€ and Romania 2 315€ and Bulgaria 3 332€ - that is over 10x differences between poorest and richest countries. US doesn't have that level of disparity between states even if you count Puerto Rico. http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/gdp-and-beyond/quality-of-life/median-income http://ec.europa.eu/eurostat/web/gdp-and-beyond/quality-of-l...
- vilmosi 10y agoThat may be true but you should really compare purchasing power rather than raw disposable income (I still think what you say is true, but not as exaggerated)
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- lilbobbytables 10y agoI'd imagine, without putting much thought into it, that when you compare salaries, and then account for how much more is paid in taxes in (most) European countries, then at least parts of the comparison can get voided - like retirement savings or something of that nature. If you're working as a professional in the US it's pretty rare that your health insurance isn't at least mostly paid for by your employer, if not completely paid for by them. But like you said, that's why it's a tricky calculation. All of which varies if you're single or married with children. I'd imagine that for the young and healthy people without children, it isn't hard to sock away more in the US.