4 ms·
"How could anyone be stupid enough to fund Facebook. They'll never make money" - HN. "VC's never fund anything but social media apps and advertising companies"
by nl 10y ago
"How could anyone be stupid enough to fund Facebook. They'll never make money" - HN.
"VC's never fund anything but social media apps and advertising companies" -- HN.
"Yes of course SpaceX is going to make Musk money" -- HN.
"Funding a supersonic plane is a stupid idea" -- HN.
(And yes, also "$41M funding for color.com is stupid" --HN.)
- sschueller 10y agoI would fund a supersonic plane if the company behind it wasn't living in another dimension. There is nothing wrong withe something taking 10 years to build. Under promise over deliver.
- TeMPOraL 10y ago> "VC's never fund anything but social media apps and advertising companies" -- HN. Well, they also occasionally fund stupid shit like uBeam. > "Yes of course SpaceX is going to make Musk money" -- HN. Isn't it? Except that money is wisely reinvested into the Mars transportation project. > "Funding a supersonic plane is a stupid idea" -- HN. Supersonic passenger plane is not a smart idea for various technical and economical reasons. I don't think that's just "HN opinion".
- nl 10y agoSupersonic passenger plane is not a smart idea for various technical and economical reasons. I don't think that's just "HN opinion". AFAIK, the technical and economic reasons boil down to: "Too expensive to build, too expensive to fly, people object to the sonic booms". I don't know if there is a way around the sonic boom problem, but for the first two there's an "easy" fix: make it cheaper. I don't have a clue how to do that, but and I have no particular opinion on Boom, but if someone came up with a way around that "small" problem then everything else falls into place.
- TeMPOraL 10y agoAs far as I can tell, the argument boils down to all that you wrote, relative to what you gain. AFAIK a supersonic passenger plane doesn't shorten your total trip enough, compared to regular passenger planes, to create a new quality class of travel. E.g. taking 5 hours to go to a place (2h flight + airport overhead on both sides) by a plane vs. 12+ hours by bus makes many destinations suddenly accessible to people to visit for a weekend. Except maybe on intercontinental, I don't see a supersonic passenger plane enabling another quality class of travel.
- Retric 10y agoA 16 hour flight dropping to 6 hours is a very noticeable difference, the question is if the economics work out. From an energy perspective ultra high altitude flight at Mach 2+ is surprisingly efferent. Though getting up there and up to speed is pointless for D.C. to NYC or other commuter flights.
- notahacker 10y agoTrouble is when it's 16 hours in a relatively comfortable seat that turns into a bed overnight with a choice of departure times (even including business jets in the price brackets we're currently talking about) versus 6 hours of relative discomfort with only one flight a day, it's less clear-cut a decision. Sure, there'll be some demand for it, but you need full aircraft on a very large number of routes for it to be a viable commercial aircraft programme.
- Retric 10y agoYour assuming seats cost significantly more. That's not nessisarily true as the fuel costs are offset by need 1/2 the aircraft and far less crew time etc. So, if someone is looking at say a twenty percent premium and thinking about trying to sleep in coach that's an easy choice.
- notahacker 10y agoI think it's absurd to assume that supersonic flight will only be a 20% premium over coach class in a conventional aircraft with 3-4x the carrying capacity doing less work against physics and subjecting its more components to less physical stress. If the price point comparison is (more plausibly) between business class in one of several A380/777 flights, chartering a flight and leaving exactly when and where you want if there's a group or coach class in a Boom, I think the choice is rather less straightforward. I'm not saying there's no demand - obviously Concorde filled seats - but I am saying it might not be sufficient to make a viable commercial aircraft programme even without restrictions on where they can fly.
- vatsal 10y agoInvesting in general is hard. Investing in unproven business models or futuristic ideas is harder. Putting money where your mouth is hardest :)