4 ms·
According to the article, taxpayers will be subsidising taxi drivers by at least 80MM GBP: 16MM for the factory, and 64MM in direct subsidies to taxi owners. I
by rahimnathwani 10y ago
According to the article, taxpayers will be subsidising taxi drivers by at least 80MM GBP: 16MM for the factory, and 64MM in direct subsidies to taxi owners.
I don't see why taxpayers should foot the bill for this, when most Londoners cannot afford to ride in London taxis (and use buses, tube or minicabs/Uber instead).
- chillydawg 10y agoWe all benefit from fewer old diesels on the road.
- justincormack 10y agoTrue, and they don't seem politically willing to ban diesels in London, given the government encouraged their purchase in the first place.
- hardlianotion 10y agoI believe that from 2018, all new London taxis will have to be zero emission capable. On the other hand, the "capable" may be weasel wording. It seems that the taxi being discussed is a hybrid with quite a short range (70 miles?). It can be recharged at a point, but can also be recharged via its petrol engine, which may run for lengthy periods if there are no quick charging points available (not many at the moment in London). Seems like a smallish step in the right direction.
- Reason077 10y agoPetrol-electric hybrids are a vast improvement over the ancient, stinking, noisy, toxic NOx and particulate-spewing diesels that plague London's streets today. Plug-in hybrids with a decent electric range are even better.
- m-i-l 10y agoWith progressive taxation, those who can't afford to use London taxis will be paying zero or a negligible contribution towards this. And all those who breathe, irrespective of whether they are taxpayers or use taxis or not, will benefit from cleaner air and fewer pollution-related health issues.
- vidarh 10y agoIt's also an investment in additional jobs, which will cut benefits payments and increase tax receipts, so the net cost to the treasury will be substantially lower. Given current interest rates, it's not impossible that that alone would pay for the subsidies.
- dalbasal 10y agoThis is disingenuous accounting, imo. It assumes these are "additional jobs" not substitute jobs. In reality the people employed would have probably been employed elsewhere if not for this plan.
- pjc50 10y agoThat's the standard subsidy for electric cars in the UK, I think. Similar to the one Tesla benefits from in the US. And while only the very well off use taxis to travel regularly when they could use TfL, you'd be surprised at how many less well off people use them occasionally. Especially the elderly and disabled, due to the accessibility features of London taxis.
- rahimnathwani 10y ago"That's the standard subsidy for electric cars in the UK, I think." Nope. The maximum subsidy for a car is 4,500 per vehicle[0]. The article says they're offering 7,500 per car to taxi drivers. [0] https://www.gov.uk/plug-in-car-van-grants/what-youll-get https://www.gov.uk/plug-in-car-van-grants/what-youll-get
- Reason077 10y agoI don't see why taxpayers should foot the bill for this Everyone benefits from cleaner air.
- aries1980 10y agoIf someone dumps the trash front of your otherwise clean neighbourhood just because he don't want to pay for waste services, would you pay for him to do it less often?
- zhte415 10y agoYou're arguing what is just, from a perspective, but not an absolute. If a factory upstream is polluting and causing a village $200 of damage a year, and if it were possible to pay the factory $100 to reduce this pollution to a $50 impact, should the village not pay? They'll net $50 in benefit. Devil's advocate argument of sorts, but one that focuses on the absolute. Real-life is harder. What if some of the village are employed at the factory? What if the factory produces produces the village needs but costs far more elsewhere? What if the factory employs people from another nearby poor village and your village is a comparatively rich village? Point is: Look for win-wins and an objective framework to work in, not for multiple parties anchoring around their single issue concerns, blinkered from the bigger picture. Talking completely in general. Not verified figures in article either.
- pjc50 10y agoEasy one: the village should pay zero and the factory should sort itself out. Pushing costs onto other people and then asking them to pay to mitigate them is extortion.
- rahimnathwani 10y agoYou're all correct: the benefits of reduced diesel pollution would benefit all Londoners. My comment was partly a negative reaction to yet another subsidy being paid to taxi drivers, who are already subsidised: - Implicitly by having a monopoly on picking up from the street - Implicitly by being able to drive in many bus lanes (there are no carpool lanes in the UK, so an empty taxi gets to use a lane that a family of 4 cannot) - Explicitly through not having to pay the London congestion charge (~90MM GBP per year) even though they cause a disproportionate amount of congestion These are only tangential to this issue, but I'd like to see the costs of London taxis internalized (i.e. paid for by taxi drivers) rather than put onto taxpayers or coming at the expense of other road users
- aries1980 10y agoA London cyclist here. Taxies are paying a fortune for these permissions. For me the only issue is the “right to endanger”: they are allowed to stop in dangerous places, corners, cycle lanes, doing U-turns on a 3x3 road for simple convenience of the passenger. I've had two accidents because of this.
- rahimnathwani 10y ago"Taxies are paying a fortune for these permissions." The congestion charge would cost a regular driver ~4000GBP per year, and she can't drive in a bus lane. How much do London taxis pay in fees per year? About 200GBP, right? What is this 'fortune' you talk about? I spent a few minutes searching online, and can't find any evidence of fees, other than an annual inspection and licence, which are low 3-digit numbers.
- aries1980 10y agoSorry, I was misinformed. I did my research and it seems you are right - actually it is even less, than £200, because some fees are for 3 years.