3 ms·
I really hope some new species of Portia spider gets named P. icarus or P. rorscharch or something. Probably 90% of the people I meet who know of Portia learned
by taneq 10y ago
I really hope some new species of Portia spider gets named P. icarus or P. rorscharch or something. Probably 90% of the people I meet who know of Portia learned about it from reading Echopraxia (or from talking to people who'd read the book.)
- gpderetta 10y agoEchopraxia is nowhere as good as Blindsight, but it was worth reading just to discover about Portia spiders!
- taneq 10y agoDifferent books for different audiences. Echopraxia tries to be more accessible by having a baseline human as the main character and a vehicle for a bit more explanation, but in doing so it loses a bit of the hard edge that Blindsight had. I'm re-reading it now (we're just about back to Earth) and I think it's actually holding up pretty well.
- gpderetta 10y agoDefinitely. Blindsight was straight high-stakes first-contact horror, with a deep philosophical questions about consciousness. Echopraxia switched to action/adventure which didn't work as well for me. Also the philosophical themes (post-scientific discovery, god is a virus) weren't as interesting or believable.