3 ms·
I think that scene shows the ridiculousness of the concept; there is NO WAY the computer could have gotten that close to the actual table they were talking abou
by cortesoft 10y ago
I think that scene shows the ridiculousness of the concept; there is NO WAY the computer could have gotten that close to the actual table they were talking about based on those descriptions. It made all sorts of assumptions about the table that just happened to be right in order to move the plot along.
Just imagine trying to describe how to draw that table to a human artist. It would take forever, with a ridiculous amount of iteration.
If you want to program like this, you would have to get VERY good at describing the thing in an unambiguous way, and the skill to do that is going to become the new 'programming' skill.
- derefr 10y ago> Just imagine trying to describe how to draw that table to a human artist. It would take forever, with a ridiculous amount of iteration. Right, that's more what I was picturing: in reality, interacting with this kind of software would be like interacting with a sketch artist. It would be a very exhaustive (and exhausting) process. (Though, it'd essentially be the same effect you get by outsourcing piece-work to a service like Mechanical Turk—just with instantaneous response-time.) > If you want to program like this, you would have to get VERY good at describing the thing in an unambiguous way Today, the intelligence/intuition/common sense of the programmer "allows" the client to avoid ever having to develop the skill of requirements analysis for themselves. Thus, even though it doesn't take any special aptitude to learn this skill, it's currently rare. On the other hand, the naivety and short iteration time of an interactive constraint programming system would, I think, make it likely that anyone who used it would quickly/easily develop the ability to do requirements analysis. Perhaps not without being "lead by the hand" in a person-machine conversation, but certainly with it. (Much like how people who have only ever used CAD software can't necessarily do mechanical drawing by hand.)