3 ms·
I think you're living in fantasy world where DRM actually works. Not once has DRM prevented me from watching a netflix show, it's only prevented me from watchin
by flukus 10y ago
I think you're living in fantasy world where DRM actually works. Not once has DRM prevented me from watching a netflix show, it's only prevented me from watching it on netflix.
- bunderbunder 10y agoDRM works to do the only thing it was ever really meant to do, which is give copyright holders warm fuzzies so that they're more willing to put their content up for sale on legal channels that don't require much in the way of technical savvy to use. Which means that it also works for the vast majority of consumers, since that's all they really ever wanted in the first place. The whole bit about preventing people from copying content is just a feel good story that's told to TV executives in order to further DRM's primary purpose.
- Karlozkiller 10y ago> I think you're living in fantasy world where DRM actually works. Not once has DRM prevented me from watching a netflix show, it's only prevented me from watching it on netflix. Yes, yes, and yes. DRM has blocked me from Netflix as a Linux user (not anymore obviously), blocked me from games due to bugs in the DRM in windows and or rootkits, and blocked me because the DRM does not work in Linux while the actual game does. And often you can find DRM free piracy versions. DRM is a pestilence that blocks legitimate use.
- tadblarney 10y agoIt's like saying banning handguns would be pointless because bad guys can get guns. Well: Supply and Demand, if it's harder to get guns, their will be less of them. In Canada, where there is strict rules around handguns - and they are actually enforced (unlike, say Mexico where they're banned but gov. can't enforce it) - there is a lot less 'handgun related crime' and very few handguns floating around. (I'm not making an ideological statement about gun laws here, just using it as an example) Most people don't know how to get around DRM, or consider it 'somewhat immoral' and won't do it. The idea that 'all content should be free' is an interesting popular intellectual phenom. If you've actually ever created something yourself, and had someone steal it under this ideology, then it really 'brings home' how much it's not a very fair concept at all. As much as I hate Disney - if they make some dumb film - it's theirs to sell and control. That film is not public property. People don't want to pay for stuff, and they don't want ads (i.e. ad blockers) - well - the 'long run' economic case is that there is no content. And there is no way around this (i.e. some make the argument that bands should just give away their music and make their money playing live, but this is not realistic for 99.9% of creations) In the 'creative economy' - where even software is a creative function - then stuff can't be free. Firefox is only possible because Google gives them money - from their ads. Can DRM and excessive IP protections hurt everyone - absolutely. But that does't mean they are not necessary. The #1 issue in the creative economy going forward relates to this - how we can effectively, responsibly and fairly manage IP. We have to deal with it, we can't take the naive position that 'all the stuff should be free to me because I don't want to pay for it'.
- dasil003 10y agoWrong, neither I nor anyone in industry believes DRM "works" in that sense. You're misunderstanding the purpose of DRM, see my other comment: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13936576 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13936576
- flukus 10y agoI don't understand your clarification either: > The point of enforcing DRM is not to prevent piracy, but rather to flex their market clout and demonstrate control. I don't see how DRM does this. The amount they've spent compared to the results they've got seems to demonstrate a complete lack of control to me. >As long as they put up moderate barriers to ripping, and as long as they have legal sanction to suppress productized piracy, the steady stream of new must-have content allows them to throw their weight around. What does DRM do to prevent productized piracy? >Licensing streaming without DRM is a slippery slope that decreases the perceived value of their content. So the choose to increase the real value of it instead?
- azinman2 10y agoThere's a difference between deterring (upping the bar) and making it impossible. See CIA guidelines on writing malware in the recent leak.
- flukus 10y agoIt only deters people that were already detered by their own technological inability, the ones that don't know what files are. Everyone else can circumvent it by grabbing a pirate bay version.