7 ms·
Impossible Foods says it is close to finishing a large-scale production facility
- libertymcateer 10y agoHeadline is a dramatic overstatement. > In an announcement today, the Bay Area company said it was close to finishing a large-scale production facility in Oakland, California that can produce as much as 1 million lb (454,000 kg) of meatless meat a month. 1. Facility not done. 2. Facility not tested. 3. Capacity not demonstrated. 4. Regulatory approval -- pending? This headline needs editing.
- dang 10y agoOk, edited.
- WalterSear 10y ago> 4. Regulatory approval -- pending? Their product is already on the market, so I don't see how there would be any more red tape other than certifying the new facilities.
- libertymcateer 10y ago> any more red tape other than certifying the new facilities That is a very substantial amount of potential red tape.
- Mikeb85 10y agoFirst 3 points - it's pretty easy to estimate, based on size of the facility, equipment, staff, etc... Point 4 - what regulation? Apart from the regular food production inspections, which are well known, what issue could there be? Headline seems appropriate.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- mamon 10y agoThis was clearly inspired by Buffy the Vampire Slayer episode "Doublemeat Palace" :)
- news_to_me 10y agoI wonder how this kind of burger compares to lab-grown burgers. I would imagine this process is significantly cheaper than lab-grown – in which case, why don't we just replace all burgers with this?
- ars 10y ago> in which case, why don't we just replace all burgers with this? That's the beauty of capitalism. "We" don't have to do anything, if it's cheaper people will buy it and the replacement will happen automatically.
- ChristianBundy 10y agoNot to nitpick, because I agree with your point, but that's the beauty of _economics_, not capitalism. Non-capitalistic economies (e.g. socialism) also optimize for high-yield products that require minimal labor, the difference being who owns the means of production (i.e. factories): the workers, the consumers, private shareholders, the state, etc.
- corporateslave 10y agoThis is false. A capitalist society provides the rewards and drives for people to create innovative products. Socialism restricts those. I'm sorry you think it's the opposite
- acchow 10y agoIf you're looking at it purely in terms of nutrition. But taste? Socialism doesn't measure the actual utility given by goods. Capitalism does by virtue of us spending our money according to what we like.
- dragonwriter 10y agoSocialism measures utility to social decision-makers, and, so, in the case of democratic socialism, weights utility equally across the citizenry, rather by wealth as in capitalism; wealth-weighting not only favors the near-term utility of the wealthy but also entrenches power, since future expectation of power has utility. Of course, non-democratic (either in theory or practice) socialism (or non-socialist central planning) have unequal weighting that has the same kind of issues as wealth-weighting.
- pier25 10y ago> wheat, coconut oil, potatoes, and heme Replacing meat for carbs is not a great idea. Edit: I was wrong. 200cal only have 6g of carbs which is pretty good IMO.
- TheSpiceIsLife 10y agoI suspect by wheat they mean the gluten part.
- wykydtron 10y agothis seems like it conflicts heavily with a large portion of their target demographic... Is the carbs also a double negative?
- pault 10y agoWhat if animal fats are too heavy for your personal digestive system and you aren't obsessed with your BMI?
- tunocina 10y agoYou can't "be obsessed with your BMI". If something makes you fatter, you should not eat it.
- pier25 10y ago> What if animal fats are too heavy for your personal digestive system You could get vegetable fats from avocados, olive oil, etc. Fats are essential to life. > and you aren't obsessed with your BMI? It's a myth that eating fats will increase your BMI. It's eating too many calories that causes that.
- pault 10y ago> You could get vegetable fats from avocados, olive oil, etc. Fats are essential to life. I agree, those and coconut are my preferred sources of fat. > It's a myth that eating fats will increase your BMI. It's eating too many calories that causes that. This is the opposite of my intended meaning. I was referring to GP's blanket statement that replacing meat with carbs is bad. The "BMI obsession" snark is a response to people advocating extreme low carb diets as if they are inherently healthier (rarely are the components of that diet discussed) than a diverse diet of unrefined foods (including the occasional carbohydrate). Keto is great for showing off your six pack. I don't think that means that it is by default healthy.
- Taek 10y agoDoes anyone know how the nutritional content compares? For me, the fact that I can cook a 300g burger that, after trimmings, is 1000+ calories is a big deal. Also the massive amounts of fat and protein, and the low carb profile. All these things make burgers a great meal choice for me (taste matters too obviously). If these fake burgers are cheaper, have similar macros and calorie density, and are better for the environment, I am super interested.
- acchow 10y agoWhy is density important. Is cooking a 500g veggie burger that much more effort? (Its not, especially since you don't need it to be properly cooked)
- scythe 10y agoCan you eat a 500g burger? I can't. In fact I wouldn't even want to eat a 300g burger unless I was very hungry. That's 10.5 oz. 500g is 18 oz.
- heinrichf 10y agoSee http://www.impossiblefoods.com/images/faq/nutrition-facts.png http://www.impossiblefoods.com/images/faq/nutrition-facts.pn... Their competitor Beyond meat has also the following comparison: http://beyondmeat.com/media/img/home/weigh-in.jpg http://beyondmeat.com/media/img/home/weigh-in.jpg
- linkregister 10y agoA 300g Impossible Burger would be (from 85g serving size): 300g / 85g = 3.53 Calories 220 * 3.53 = 777 Fat 13g * 3.53 = 45.9g Protein 19g * 3.53 = 67.1g Carbs 6g * 3.53 = 21.2g
- linkregister 10y ago300g Beef Burger (source: wikipedia) Calories 612 Fat 48g Protein 45g Carbs 0g
- glibgil 10y agoI tried it. It tastes good because of the heme, but it tastes wheaty otherwise. I think most people would like it, but not going for gluten-free recipe seems shortsighted
- Dotnaught 10y agoI've tried the Impossible Burger twice at Cockscomb Restaurant in San Francisco. It's almost identical in taste to a good beef burger, when prepared by a professional chef at least. But at $19, it's not competitive with a $7.75 Super Duper Burger or any cheaper variants one might find at In-N-Out or fast food joints further down the ladder.
- busted 10y agoDoubt if impossible burger was at in-n-out it would cost $19. For people's comparison, the normal hamburger at Cockscomb is $15 (+$20 if you want to add foie gras ;)
- pan69 10y agoI might be more fair to compare their $19 Impossible Burger with their $15 Hamburger rather than an In-N-Out burger. I haven't tasted an Impossible Burger (yet) but I'd be more than happy to pay the extra $4 if its "almost identical in taste to a good beef burger". http://cockscombsf.com/menu/lunch-menu/ http://cockscombsf.com/menu/lunch-menu/
- LeanderK 10y agoThis is something i am really (REALLY!) excited about. I am a Vegetarian because of the environmental impact, but the desire for the taste is still there (been a few years). All the substitutes i have tried (until now) were bad and left me disappointed and i still have to fight the urge to order a good old schnitzel at a restaurant. EDIT: if somebody asks why i am being so strict...i will stop being strict when we start living sustainable on a global scale. I don't see that happen in my lifetime. Until then being a strict vegetarian has a good impact on the people around me. I don't try to persuade anybody, i will even grill your meat, i am just a vegetarian for myself and the planet.
- itake 10y agoWhat makes you think that this is more environmentally friendly than beef?
- LeanderK 10y agowell, intuition. Beef is extremely unfriendly for the environment. Also on their website it says: >Because we use 0% cows, the Impossible Burger uses a fraction of the Earth’s natural resources. Compared to cows, the Impossible Burger uses 95% less land, 74% less water, and creates 87% less greenhouse gas emissions. And it’s 100% free of hormones, antibiotics, and artificial ingredients.
- Mikeb85 10y agoRaising cattle on a mass scale uses more inputs. Mainly because they're fed grain, and caloric value of the inputs is higher than the output (ie. wasted resources), plus the environmental impacts of the cattle themselves. It's not exactly controversial.
- subpixel 10y agoI've scaled back my meat consumption radically in the last six years or so and in my experience, taste is just a factor of habit. Change your habits and you can change what you perceive to be delicious. Anecdotally, eating meat infrequently has resulted in me finding chicken and turkey generally flavorless and gross when I'm in a position where I must eat them. And while the smell of a burger cooking somewhere is still nice, the smell of bacon being cooked in our building has gone from sublime to rank. When I do eat meat that I find tasty (burger, steak, kebabs) I've slowly come to appreciate that less is best, and more can turn my stomach. A thin patty ala Shake Shack is vastly preferable to an $18, 3-inch tall burger at a hip restaurant. I haven't yet come around to vegan cheese. But based on other changes I can't rule that out.
- linkregister 10y agohttps://www.impossiblefoods.com/faq/ https://www.impossiblefoods.com/faq/ Nutrition Facts Serving Size (85g) Servings Per Container about 85 ------------- Amount Per Serving Calories 220 Calories from Fat 120 Calories from Saturated Fat 100 ------------- % Daily Value* Total Fat 13g 20% Saturated Fat 11g 55% Trans Fat 0g Cholesterol 0mg 0% Sodium 380mg 16% Potassium 250mg 7% Total Carbohydrate 6g 2% Dietary Fiber < 1g 4% Sugars 1g Protein 19g ------------- Vitamin A 0% - Vitamin C 25% Calcium 2% - Iron 10% Thiamin 1260% - Riboflavin 15% Niacin 20% - Vitamin B6 10% Zinc 15% - Vitamin B12 50%
- entee 10y agoOne note: the saturated fat component is most likely from the coconut oil. The nutritional impact of coconut oil as a saturated fat is complicated. 55% daily value may not be as terrible as it looks on first glance. http://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/coconut-oil http://www.health.harvard.edu/staying-healthy/coconut-oil
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- LeanderK 10y agoFor special requirements (allergies, diets) reengineering the patty would be way easier than reengineering a cow, i would expect. This is their first product.
- linkregister 10y agoAllergies, yes. Zero carbs, probably impossible. That's okay though. No product can satisfy everyone!
- 10y ago
- jkarneges 10y agoI haven't tried Impossible Foods yet, but I have been dabbling with Beyond Meat (both companies backed by Bill Gates apparently). In case anyone is curious about this product category, here are my thoughts on Beyond Meat: Beyond Meat has a normal burger replacement. Other than the factory-formed shape (easy to fix I'd think), the texture and taste approach the real thing. It probably wouldn't pass a blind test and it's expensive, but if they got the cost down and In-n-out started cooking with it I could see myself preferring it. They also have a healthier burger (Beast). This one's not trying to be as convincing and isn't going to convert any carnivores. I don't really recommend it unless you must eat something healthy in patty form. Then there's the Beefy Crumble. This is a ground beef substitute that isn't in patty form. It's on the healthy side and isn't going to fool anyone either, but I use it all the time as it's nice to have another protein in the rotation (all the Beyond stuff uses pea protein). Easy to throw into burritos or pasta. Looking forward to the future of this space.
- thoreauway 10y agoI've had the hamburger before in NY (~$9 w/ fries) and it's pretty delicious. Probably would have thought it was real beef if I hadn't already known. I'm extremely bullish on IF.