4 ms·
2007 is a lot different than 2017 when it comes to online video consumption. For starters, a greater number of people, including the disabled, are consuming onl
by danso 10y ago
2007 is a lot different than 2017 when it comes to online video consumption. For starters, a greater number of people, including the disabled, are consuming online video. This is not entirely different from brick and mortar facilities being hit with lawsuits for not having required wheelchair accessible facilities. Those lawsuits weren't based on new laws, but on the discovery of the inadequate facilities.
- alphapapa 10y agoI think it is entirely different. Physical accessibility is virtually a one-time cost: install the rails, ramps, etc, and you're done. But meeting these standards [1] is surely cost-prohibitive, especially when the only person doing it is an already overburdened professor who's merely uploading videos of his lectures, slides, etc. It would increase the preparation time of every lecture, document, etc. by several times over. 1: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13933826 https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=13933826
- danso 10y agoFor a small business, a $10,000 lawsuit + construction fees is not a trivial cost, and may be cost-prohibitive enough to force the business to close shop. But "something is better than nothing " is not justification alone for not meeting ADA regulations. I don't think anyone believes that meeting ADA regulations is cheap; the fact that Berkeley (and Harvard and MIT [0]) are in this predicament shows that the cost of producing accessible video is non-trivial. But it's the law, and advocacy groups would argue that the burden shouldn't be on the individual professor, but on the institution, or rather, the federal agencies to provide adequate funding to meet the burden imposed by law. If institutions aren't forced to realize the costs, then they aren't incentivized to pressure government budget/policymakers to make ADA funding a priority, which neuters the protections that ADA was created for in the first place. Again, it's costly, but that's the monetary price our civic society pays when it decides to extend protections to those who are disabled. Presumably, the ADA was passed because legislators and constituents thought that the price was worth it. [0] http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2016/2/25/harvard-lawsuit-deaf-proceed/ http://www.thecrimson.com/article/2016/2/25/harvard-lawsuit-...
- mjevans 10y agoI think that something /given away for free/ should have a different standard than something which is sold as a product or service.
- DanBC 10y ago> especially when the only person doing it is an already overburdened professor That over burdened professor was offered help, and s/he had to sign a declaration to say s/he was aware of the help provided by Berkeley, and that the content was accessible. https://news.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/2016-08-30-UC-Berkeley-LOF.pdf https://news.berkeley.edu/wp-content/uploads/2016/09/2016-08... Pages 3 and 4: > UC Berkeley’s faculty creates and publishes courses for the public on UC BerkeleyX. Faculty developing UC BerkeleyX courses can, but are not required to, develop courses in collaboration with the Berkeley Resource Center for Online Education (BRCOE). BRCOE follows best practices in design for accessibility and also has a quality assurance process that includes deploying various accessibility evaluators; remediating layout, page structure, downloadable or styling accessibility barriers; and obtaining transcripts of all audio and video files associated with a course. > Prior to July 1, 2015, UC Berkeley also allowed faculty and instructors to design, develop and publish courses through a self-service model, which did not include support from BRCOE. Beginning July 1, 2015, UC Berkeley advised the Department that all faculty using the selfservice model will be asked to sign off on a list of accessibility resource reviews prior to publishing the course. The sign-off statements include:
- DanBC 10y agoThe age of the law, and of the building, and of the content, makes this example a bit different. i) I build a building and then someone passes a law and I have to modify my building to make it accessible. ii) A law is passed. A decade later I build a building, and I see the law and think it's a good thing and tell my architects and builders to make sure they comply with the law and I offer them support to understand the law, and they sign a document to say "Yep, we complied with that law", and it turns out that they lied and my new building is not compliant with the law and I have to add a ramp anyway. The Berkeley situation is more like ii than i.