3 ms·
Even if they did do a better job of reviewing patents in certain countries, people would just shop around until they found the most lenient international patent
by Someone1234 10y ago
Even if they did do a better job of reviewing patents in certain countries, people would just shop around until they found the most lenient international patent office and file there.
The US Patent office in particular decided many years ago that they simply weren't qualified to review all patents and just left it to the courts to deal with the fallout.
Realistically a patent examiner cannot be qualified in all areas; so they'd need to gather industry experts which would make patent filing pretty expensive (plus a lot of experts disagree, so where do you set the standard?).
- Animats 10y agoA patent examiner cannot be qualified in all areas Which is why the USPTO has a large number of specialist patent units.
- ScottBurson 10y ago> The US Patent office in particular decided many years ago that they simply weren't qualified to review all patents and just left it to the courts to deal with the fallout. Right... but then, in the courts, an issued patent has a presumption of validity! This is arguably the biggest problem. I believe that before a patent can be used in litigation, the patentee should have to show its validity in more depth than the PTO requires, including objective evidence of nonobviousness [0]. [0] https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_v._John_Deere_Co.#The_Patent_Act_of_1952 https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Graham_v._John_Deere_Co.#The_P...