3 ms·
The simplest explanation for why America is successful [...] where you think my argument falls apart factually It doesn't even come together factually, let alo
by pvg 10y ago
The simplest explanation for why America is successful [...] where you think my argument falls apart factually
It doesn't even come together factually, let alone fall apart. The same exact things were said of the Italians, Jews, Poles, Irish and many others that poured into the US. Far worse of immigrants from East Asia. Entirely inexplicably, the country thrived and continues to do so.
- aptwebapps 10y ago"The same exact things were said of the Italians, Jews, Poles, Irish and many others that poured into the US." This bears repeating. Exactly the same arguments were advanced by (otherwise) fairly intelligent people about whichever was the latest group. Those arguments were wrong, and this argument is wrong.
- Exofunctor 10y agoDo you think Italian Catholics are as violent or as memetically aggressive as Muslims from the ME?
- Exofunctor 10y ago> The same exact things were said of the Italians, Jews, Poles, Irish and many others that poured into the US. First off, they were right about all these groups in one way or another. Italians were responsible for a huge and disproportionate fraction of east coast crime for decades, Jews are represented in politics at around an order of magnitude higher than their fraction of the population, polish communities (just like Poland) have huge problems with crime and drug abuse, and Irish communities are still getting over problems with poverty, alcoholism, and church abuses. The complaints levied against these groups were entirely correct, and these groups did culturally subsume large areas, as predicted. I say this as a descendent of 3 of those 4 groups. Second off, you can't really compare hyper-indoctrinated muslims to the Italians. Catholicism is positively benign compared to any of the popular Islamic sects. Just because something vaguely similar happened before doesn't mean it's going to happen exactly the same way again. > Entirely inexplicably, the country thrived and continues to do so. Compared to what? I suspect if the Irish hadn't shitted up the east coast for decades America could be a lot farther ahead. (Again, saying this as someone who is substantially Irish.) Yes, we turned out OK, and the shitty culture that Irish and Polish people brought over with them has mostly been diluted to impotency, but who knows what the damage was, or how it's going to go down with an even shittier and more viral culture. At least the Irish didn't make a habit of stoning people to death.