4 ms·
A significant percentage of the US beef herd is raised on range lands where they are a critical part of the natural ecosystem (replacing bison in that niche pri
by jandrewrogers 10y ago
A significant percentage of the US beef herd is raised on range lands where they are a critical part of the natural ecosystem (replacing bison in that niche primarily). I have long argued that a moderate reduction in American beef consumption would allow the demand to be satisfied entirely with ecologically necessary cattle herds, which I view as a win-win. Ecosystem stays healthy and people don't have to give up beef entirely.
People tend to focus on feedlot beef but there is also a lot of range beef in the US. Absolutists on both sides tend to ignore the fact that balanced ecologically sound options exist.
- Mikeb85 10y agoWhy not get rid of beef and graze bison? There's wild bison in Canada, as well as ranched bison. Cattle aren't natural to the ecosystem.
- nikdaheratik 10y agoBison are much harder to manage and haven't necessarily been bred for it as far as flavor. I've had a few burgers and they're nice, but somewhere between Venison and Cattle on the gamey scale. On top of that, there aren't really any wild/purebred Bison as they all had some mixing with cattle after the herds were pushed to extinction.
- meetyourmeatj 10y agoOr how about getting rid of farming animals and grow 10x as much plant based food to feed 10x as many people? Of course, that requires one not to be a selfish and self centered piece of shit, which is rare in flesh eaters.
- planteen 10y agoBison are raised in the US too. There are more bison in the US than Canada. As another said, most bison on ranches are cross bred with cattle. I have heard that bison are more aggressive than cattle. http://canadianbison.ca/producer/About_Bison/present_trends.htm http://canadianbison.ca/producer/About_Bison/present_trends.... https://bisoncentral.com/bison-by-the-numbers/ https://bisoncentral.com/bison-by-the-numbers/
- greglindahl 10y agoIsn't almost all range beef "finished" in feedlots? And feedlots are 50% of muscle mass? And the point is that it produces cheaper beef than all-grass? That doesn't bode well for achieving a balanced, ecologically sound option.
- jandrewrogers 10y agoIt depends. Not all range is equal in terms of forage and the flavor of the animal it produces, nor the weight. Some range regions have protein-rich grass that produces nice flavor and weight, other areas need a couple weeks in a feedlot to make the animal (relatively) edible. Similarly, some natural range adds a lot of weight and others are augmented with cereal feeds for the economics to pan out. For others, the economic sweet spot is at a lower weight. One of the critical economic inputs in the mountain west ranges (which tend to have high quality forage) is also water, which is sometimes ignored. There is quite a bit of agricultural economics research on this and the results are surprisingly complex. There are also many areas where the forage is high enough quality that the feedlot finishing is arguably optional even if that is what they do today.
- jessaustin 10y agoSure there are lots of complexities, but the result is that when I visit federal lands in the West, it's obvious that they are all overgrazed. The price that ranchers pay to graze their cattle on public lands should be raised until overgrazing stops. Until then, my tax dollars are subsidizing my competition in the beef industry, while destroying the environment!
- herbst 10y agoSource? I had the believe it is the exact opposite. As in beef shit poisons ground water and air
- HeyLaughingBoy 10y agoWhat do you think the bison did?
- herbst 10y agoI assume they did not overpopulate themself in way to small areas without moving to other places ever.
- meetyourmeatj 10y agoRaising animals to maintain the health of the environment has got to be one of the most asinine and nonsensical things I've seen written on HN. As in, that is a seriously wrong and stupid assumption.