4 ms·
When you work with troubled youth, an accusation of child pornography is almost as bad as it can possibly be. Since the police didn't give him an explanation fo
by macintux 10y ago
When you work with troubled youth, an accusation of child pornography is almost as bad as it can possibly be. Since the police didn't give him an explanation for the mistake up front, I'm sure he lived under a cloud of suspicion after that, hence the concern about being alone with young women.
For 3 weeks everyone around you assumes you're guilty. How do you prove the absence of pornography in your life when the police have all your equipment?
Yes, it could have been much worse. No, I'm not shocked that it was devastating.
(Update: forgot to add, I imagine there's a very real fear during those three weeks that you'll be permanently separated from your children.)
- Udik 10y agoOk, but the police cleared him of the charges. Then he hired a solicitor and thanks to him the mistake was made clear, and he got a totally justified, and very handsome, compensation. One would think that this should be enough to put at rest any possible suspicion. Three weeks are not such a long ordeal, especially when you know from the start it's all a mistake.
- Jabanga 10y agoWhat happened to him was terrible, but I tend to agree that he received adequate compensation. My armchair judge verdict: calls for further compensation should be strongly discouraged, but the lesson this story teaches of how devastating a sex crime charge, particularly a child sex crime charge, is, should be spread far and wide, and anyone who goes through ordeal similar to Nigel's should be similarly exonerated in a very public way.
- mjevans 10y agoI agree with no further direct monetary compensation... but I can see how this would literally 'break' him. He is no longer the calm, re-assuring, blissfully ignorant individual he once was. He should probably be re-evaluated for current aptitude and skills, receive refining education towards a promising related career field and live a reborn life. I don't know, does the UK actually do the right thing (unlike the US)?
- Jabanga 10y agoHe may subconsciously sabotage his own rehabilitation because doing so could net him even more compensation. I strongly believe that now that he's received compensation and full public exoneration, he should be expected to return to supporting himself. There are a lot of people who are in much more difficult circumstances than him. We cannot provide unlimited aid to every person who's been wronged or suffered trauma. It has to be proportionate and within society's ability ability to support.
- nikanj 10y agoIf you pay any attention to the news, there's been numerous cases where innocent people spent years or even decades in jails before they were found not guilty.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- emodendroket 10y agoI guess this is related to the thread where a bunch of HN users said they stopped reading news altogether.
- greghatch 10y ago> One would think that this should be enough to put at rest any possible suspicion. But, it wasn't. People were still suspicious - and in his working with kids it doesn't make sense to "take a risk" on an allegedly exonerated pedophile. What should happen and what did happen as a result of his three weeks of suspicion was starkly different. Certainly we don't need to blame anything or anyone in particular to understand how awful something like false charges can be regardless of how awful they ought to be. > Three weeks are not such a long ordeal, especially when you know from the start it's all a mistake. He didn't know it was three weeks at the time, he didn't know if he would be able to exonerate himself or if he was being framed or whatever - it's not like he's just sleeping it off when law enforcement already got one thing wrong enough to falsely arrest.
- DanBC 10y ago> People were still suspicious - and in his working with kids it doesn't make sense to "take a risk" on an allegedly exonerated pedophile. England has a "Disclosure and Barring Service". People who work with children and vulnerable people will apply for a DBS. It will return information about arrests and convictions. Some people need an enhanced DBS, and that will sometimes return police intel. https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-barring-service https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-b... https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-barring-service/about https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/disclosure-and-b... This is likely to affect his employment for some jobs until it got fixed.
- zkms 10y ago> Ok, but the police cleared him of the charges. To be clear -- the police exonerating him took three years ("5 April 2014 he received a letter from Hertfordshire constabulary"), which is rather a long ordeal, especially because he had no idea why he was targeted until then. The "three weeks" just refers to how long it took for the police's forensics people to search his laptop and find nothing. After those three weeks the police was like "oh we can't find proof of those illegal images on your laptop, welp, gotta let you go", not "we typoed an IP address and kicked down the wrong door, you are completely innocent and utterly unconnected to this".
- edblarney 10y agoI'm very sympathetic to this guy. I understand how hard it might be to be accused of something. That said - I don't feel this is a case for outrage. Surely, most of his colleagues will be well informed of the mistake. He received basically $100 000 in compensation. That's a lot of money. Given the clarity of his exhoneration - i.e. this was not something that 'went to court' or there wasn't some kind of 'Michael Jackson style payoff' to keep someone quiet - and that it was an obvious police error - I think that any circumstances around is guilt should be relatively clear. He is not a public figure - his personal reputation that 'matters' is limited to his colleagues, friends, family and the people he helps at work. That's a manageable thing from a PR perspective. His $100 000 in 'compensation' can surely be enough to pay for some lifestyle helpers. The notion that it was too much for him to go back to work, I think is a stretch. There should be no lingering doubt. This is a sad story, I feel for him, but it's not one of the scary stories we here about that need serious redressing and law changes etc.. As far as his pursual of the police action - it's clear that this boiled down to a single digit in an IP address. That's it. Innocuous error = consequence. There is no 'evil secret police' or 'malign intent'. The fact the he feels he needs to pursue this is really only going to keep him in problem zone. What kind of closure can he expect? That police will change their operating procedures to make sure they 'write down stuff correctly'? Surely there's tons of data that's passed around in an investigation and this is liable to happen. I guess this is newsworthy, but I think context is required here.
- timv 10y ago> For 3 weeks everyone around you assumes you're guilty It sounds like it was worse than that. After 3 weeks they gave him back his laptop because they found no evidence on it, and stopped pursuing charges. But the police never explained why they suspected him, nor did they uncover their own mistake regarding the IP address. So, at the end of the 3 weeks he went from being actively under investigation for child pornography to no longer under active investigation for child pornography. That's a small step forward - now not-quite-everyone around you assumes you're guilty. It took years before his solicitor uncovered the error and there was enough information available to demonstrate that he should never have been a suspect and it was all due to a police screw-up.
- mjevans 10y agoProbably way worse. I imagine it hit the news, and even if they didn't name him, //EVERYONE// that KNEW him then KNEW it was him. Then, he shows up, as you say, no longer being actively investigated for X, but still not cleared of X. Public Perception (most probably): 'Likely guilty, but they couldn't nail the bastard.' Compounded by the other details everywhere else in the thread.
- UpDownLeftRight 10y agoAnd even if cleared, everyone still thinks he's guilty. Ask a random person on the Left about the Duke lacrosse players. Even though they were exonerated... not just found not guilty... and the prosecutor was put in jail, and the accuser is now in jail, most progressives still think something happened, and their lives are ruined.