4 ms·
Man, I really, really like your posts--but come on. Nobody is saying that providing goods and services to poor people is evil. They're saying that there are cap
by eropple 10y ago
Man, I really, really like your posts--but come on. Nobody is saying that providing goods and services to poor people is evil. They're saying that there are capitalistic incentives to keep a poor population captured and that those outweigh the comforting-but-probably-pretty-wrong "just lazy" excuses.
I am perhaps more disappointed in an internet name than I should be, but I am disappointed. You are better than this.
- rayiner 10y agoThe capitalist system writ large would much prefer that these people made $40,000 a year instead of $20,000, because then it could sell those people iPhones and whatnot. I'm being glib, of course, but that's because there is no rational point to be made here. There are almost zero barriers to entry to businesses that provide goods and services to poor people. Buying a trailer park requires extremely little capital investment. Thus, there is no reason to believe that the pricing is predatory. Instead, the article is trading entirely on the ickiness (some) people feel about running a business catering to poor people. I think limited housing options for poor people is a big problem. But it's not a problem created by business owners providing housing to poor people (or ones evicting poor people who cannot pay). It's a problem created by state and municipal governments that make it illegal to build dense housing, housing on small lots, housing that isn't to code, etc.
- eropple 10y ago> The capitalist system writ large would much prefer that these people made $40,000 a year instead of $20,000, because then it could sell those people iPhones and whatnot. Only if the marginal cost of getting there is outpaced by the marginal return. If that wasn't the case, no volume-but-cheaper business could work. When you can have a ton of poor people, they are an exploitable resource for people who aren't selling iPhones (and if you pay attention to the description of eviction as a social problem maybe you'll catch a little more of the "exploitable resource" part). And it's nothing surprising--the historical examples abound of captive, poor populations who are used as revenue generators with no real recourse of their own. I get nothing out of the article that's "trading entirely on the ickiness" of selling goods and services to poor people. But I do get a lot of "poor people have basically no options because of systematic economic incentives to keep them there."
- rayiner 10y ago> But I do get a lot of "poor people have basically no options because of systematic economic incentives to keep them there." Poor people might not have good options, because they have no money, but they have options. If the check cashing place on your block charges too much, you can go to the one down the street. The barrier to entry in these markets is so low that there is no argument that they are "gouging" customers who have no other options.
- eropple 10y ago...Dude. The usurious, bullshit check-cashing places are one of the parts of the system that profits from keeping poor people where they are. The charges at all of them are effectively too much to not be a severe burden on folks who are too down to afford a bank account. You're not covering yourself in glory here with this sort of lack of empathy.
- rayiner 10y agoIf banks could make a profit giving poor people bank accounts, they'd do it. Moreover, there is tremendous competition in the check-cashing market. Walk down a street in Baltimore and you'll hit one every few blocks. If one of those shops could get more of the market by charging lower fees than their competitors, they'd do it. Focusing your ire on check cashing places is the archetypal example of a bullshit solution crafted based on emotions rather than rational analysis. Forcing check-cashing fees below the market price is just going to reduce the number of check cashing places, taking away options from people who need them. Any real solution is going to either require the government writing a check e.g. by subsidizing bank accounts for poor people, or reducing regulation to lower the transaction costs in check depositing and withdrawals.
- tptacek 10y agoAgain (maybe I can say this more succinctly): These are businesses that survive by making lots of irresponsible loans to people who have no business taking out loans, funding them out of the enormous fees and interest payments charged to the subset of their customers who aren't total write-offs.
- rosser 10y agoThe "capitalist system writ large" might prefer it, but entirely too many individual capitalists — that is, the folks with, give or take, all of the capital — probably prefer things more as they are. Which, I believe, was the article's point. EDIT: phrasing.
- rayiner 10y agoExcept the small potatoes capitalists mentioned in the article have zero control or influence over the larger political system.
- ryandamm 10y agoYeah, your reading is very different from mine, also. You're assuming things about the liquidity of the market, regulatory environment, and external situations that simply aren't true. Toy models can be useful, but don't take them for reality. The point of this article is to tear down simplistic assumptions like yours. I guess it failed. Any time you say "this can't be true, because otherwise..." you had better take a hard look at your mental model and 1) make sure it's saying what you think it is, and 2) is backed up by evidence, not just an idealized version of the world. I think politics and economics are most bedeviled by these simple models, which tends to elicit this knee-jerk kind of response.
- rayiner 10y agoThe article does absolutely nothing to "tear down simplistic assumptions." For example, with respect to the trailer park. The article says nothing about the guys return on investment, which you would need to know in order to determine whether he was earning some sort of abnormally high return by having a captive audience. The article also talks about the unfortunate situation faced by people who are evicted, but says nothing about the kinds of returns earned by those landlords. And studies have looked into this issue and confirmed the view I expressed above. For example, studies have found that competition in the payday loan market is intense. Interest rates are high because the default risk is high, not because people don't have choices between lenders that compete on interest rates.
- lutorm 10y agoI'm not sure what point you are making. Even if competition in the payday loan market is so fierce that there's zero margin, it still remains that the rates will be high enough to help trap people in poverty, and having people need to take out payday loans is the solution the capitalist system has devised for this situation. To pretend that this is not a failure of the capitalist system seems very narrow-minded.
- rayiner 10y agoThe folks attacking payday lending (i.e. mainstream American liberals) aren't suggesting replacing those options with minimum basic income or a comprehensive welfare state. They're simply ignorant, and think that poor people will be helped if the government sets lower rates by fiat. In reality, it will simply remove another option from people who have very few.
- pillowkusis 10y ago>The capitalist system writ large would much prefer that these people made $40,000 a year instead of $20,000 The captialist system finds local maximums, not global ones. This is a classic coordination problem. As a business, your path to profit maximization from poor people is to keep them impoverished (make the poor part with the most money possible). Of course, if every business adopted models that were less predatory, overall wealth would increase, poor people make 40k a year, more stuff is sold, and everyone profits more, poor and businesses alike. But as a single business, if you adopt less predatory business practices, you are not maximizing profit, AND you are opening yourself to be out-competed by a business that does. The regular customer-satisfaction competition does still apply, of course. But the power of the consumer is significantly blunted if the consumer has limited choice, which is what happens to the poor when they have limited options caused by low economic security. Perhaps, the poor have so few options, businesses are allowed to create predatory cycles of poverty.
- zkms 10y ago> But it's not a problem created by business owners providing housing to poor people (or ones evicting poor people who cannot pay). It's a problem created by state and municipal governments that make it illegal to build dense housing, housing on small lots, housing that isn't to code, etc. I concur -- awful zoning laws are a root cause of the undersupply and overpricing of housing for poor people. Criminalising the sheer act of dwelling (or renting to people who dwell) in any sprinklered building is utter depravity, especially given how many people are homeless or live in warehouses that are deadly firetraps. However, currently-existing residential landlords/property-owners have extremely strong reasons to preserve the currently-existing legal regimes that limit housing supply. After all, if it suddenly becomes legal to {build,live in, rent out} dense housing / housing on small lots, there'll be people who indeed will do so, which will increase supply and lower prices. That's the profitable element in the current state of affairs -- all the current landlords who can charge higher than they would be able to if the government wasn't making lots of potential competition illegal.
- saint_fiasco 10y agoAny stupid theory can outweigh the comforting lie of "just lazy", but that doesn't mean we have to reduce our skepticism. The people who rent trailers to poor people would probably make much more money building nice houses and renting to richer people. It could be that one of the reasons poor people have so few affordable options is that people don't profit from serving them. The article does nothing to argue against that possibility. It doesn't even acknowledge any alternative theory that could explain the same data, except the "just lazy" strawman.