3 ms·
At the risk of sounding like a jerk, this seems like another example of urban areas subsidizing rural areas' infrastructure because those areas aren't really ec
by TulliusCicero 10y ago
At the risk of sounding like a jerk, this seems like another example of urban areas subsidizing rural areas' infrastructure because those areas aren't really economically viable.
It's a really bizarre situation: you have rural residents who hate 'government handouts' being extremely dependent on just that, and those handouts come from the very 'urban elites' that they despise!
> Two Stones Farm, a small goat farm here, has created an online store to offer more products, including artisanal cheese. “I look at it this way: It’s very much like electricity was at one time,” said Alan White, 54, who owns Two Stones Farm with his wife. “Electricity would have never come to our valley if it was based strictly on population. It’s not a luxury. It’s a necessity that we need to operate.”
Well yeah, that's the free market at work.
Like, I don't have a major problem with the subsidy itself, I just hate the massive ignorance and cognitive dissonance involved from people who worship the market except when it doesn't work out so hot for them, and then are suddenly cool with, even eager for subsidies from their political enemies.
- Spivak 10y agoThis is a very uncharitable interpretation. Is it really so weird that people are more idealistic at a distance? Or that a person's views in the real world are more nuanced than can be boiled down to a few absolute principles. Even the staunchest free market advocates support the idea of government intervening when markets fail, and there is an almost universally held belief that such a failure exists in the telecom industry. And do you not think a person could view a market intervention to expand access to what is becoming a utility and social programs that write checks to 'unproductive members of society' to be different? I'm not saying they're right, but calling them hypocrites based on your world view and your generalization of theirs seems to be picking a fight rather than any kind of respectful discussion.
- TulliusCicero 10y ago> This is a very uncharitable interpretation. Yup. > Is it really so weird that people are more idealistic at a distance? Or that a person's views in the real world are more nuanced than can be boiled down to a few absolute principles. I don't think it's weird, exactly, I'd say it's frustrating/borderline infuriating when people vote for one thing while simultaneously demanding the opposite, when people are against 'handouts' except when said handouts are convenient for their lifestyle. It's massively hypocritical to complain about government handouts while being extremely dependent on them. This isn't some edge case, their lifestyles and communities are fundamentally dependent on the thing they claim to despise. > Even the staunchest free market advocates support the idea of government intervening when markets fail, and there is an almost universally held belief that such a failure exists in the telecom industry. Yeah but we're not talking about using regulation to grant a local monopoly, we're talking about the economic fundamentals of providing services like internet. It's not really a 'market failure' that it's uneconomical to provide internet to people who choose to live in remote areas, any more than it's a 'market failure' there are usually no good ethnic restaurants out there, or that land in Manhattan is astronomically expensive. > And do you not think a person could view a market intervention to expand access to what is becoming a utility and social programs that write checks to 'unproductive members of society' to be different? To be clear, this isn't a 'market intervention' (what does that even mean?). This is a government intervention that relies on private providers for implementation, not entirely unlike building roads. > I'm not saying they're right, but calling them hypocrites based on your world view and your generalization of theirs seems to be picking a fight rather than any kind of respectful discussion. But they are hypocrites, and so far even in conservative circles where I've pointed this out, nobody really has a response that disputes it. And you're right that what I'm saying is not, by itself, terribly productive. But recognizing the internal contradiction of communities that espouse principles that, if actually implemented, would destroy themselves, or even just recognizing the subsidy at work, could lead to interesting policy discussions. I think most Americans are unaware of how urban areas subsidize rural ones. The stereotypical lazy person benefiting from a subsidy in political discourse is a poor person in a city who's mooching off welfare, after all, while rural people are -- when they're not stereotyped as backwards hicks -- stereotyped as gruff, hard-working 'real Americans'. And they may indeed be hard-working, but that doesn't mean their lifestyle isn't getting subsidized.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoHere's a good example of what I'm talking about: > And while widening the broadband infrastructure is an essential step toward bridging the digital divide, simply ensuring access does not address the issue of affordability, especially since the F.C.C. is considering slashing parts of a federal program, known as Lifeline, that is meant to help provide affordable broadband to low-income residents. So here we have a program that benefits poor rural people, being ended by an administration strongly supported by the poor rural people who benefit from that program. How do you resolve something like that? How do you help communities that keep voting in people that want to hurt them? It seems to me like the first step is knowledge. If the people in rural areas who benefit from urban subsidies become more aware of that, maybe their voting patterns will change.
- dragonwriter 10y ago> How do you resolve something like that? How do you help communities that keep voting in people that want to hurt them? The thing is, Trump didn't campaign on hurting them, he campaigned on (ambiguous, unrealistic, and often contradicted in other contexts) plans to help them. To beat that, you need someone campaigning with a strong message directed at the same audience offering a compelling alternative vision of how to address their concerns, including clear criticism of why the first candidates program won't work. A common critique of the Clinton campaign is that it failed to do that with the constituency at issue.
- TulliusCicero 10y agoI think you're right, the only problem is that 'the government is bad and unhelpful' is pretty deeply ingrained at this point, and it feels like a message of 'the government will do X to help' isn't going to be effective as long as the former message remains ingrained.
- bradleyjg 10y ago> there is an almost universally held belief that such a failure exists in the telecom industry There is a widely acknowledged market failure in the telcom market but it doesn't here. Specifically, telcom is a naturally monopoly so we expect there to be one provider and for it to have monopolistic pricing power. Whereas a healthy market has many providers and better pricing (from the consumer's point of view). In this case there are zero providers because there isn't a high enough collective willingness to pay on the part of the would be consumers to cover the costs, much less any profit. That's not a market failure, at least as it is generally defined.
- akgerber 10y agoThe free market isn't the state of nature but rather a social construct of the state. So are rural electrification and telecom programs. And rural residents in New York state aren't universally conservative by any means.