4 ms·
Quite aside from anything else, can someone explain whether or not the same logic would apply to (for example) asking someone to open a safe vs. the code to ope
by olliej 10y ago
Quite aside from anything else, can someone explain whether or not the same logic would apply to (for example) asking someone to open a safe vs. the code to open the safe. It seems like this ruling would say that failing to open the safe is functionally the same?
As a gratuitously distorted example, lets say i had cooked accounting books in a spreadsheet on my computer, and they were encrypted by a random password that /i/ do not know, but have on a memory stick in a safe. It seems that logically that would be equivalent, but i also am very much not a lawyer so am perfectly willing to accept i am missing nuance of the law.
Outside of the law i don't like the forgone conclusion stuff - for example, revolution period you could say hanging out with revolutionaries regularly could reasonably conclude your documents include a calendar for revolutionary meetings so you should be required to provide that information and/or information required to receive that. Obviously that's some contorted logic but i don't think it's that far removed from this.
I would argue that a hash match should be sufficient, and i would be convinced that (absent other information and details) this was evidence that he's a pedo, but i can see how a lawyer could create reasonable doubt where in reality there is none (specifically referring to hashes here, nothing else).
Of course i can't serve on a jury (and apparently knowing what you're talking about may be disqualifying? :-/)
- rayiner 10y ago> Quite aside from anything else, can someone explain whether or not the same logic would apply to (for example) asking someone to open a safe vs. the code to open the safe. It seems like this ruling would say that failing to open the safe is functionally the same? Basically, judges don't agree on which way this scenario comes out. > Outside of the law i don't like the forgone conclusion stuff - for example, revolution period you could say hanging out with revolutionaries regularly could reasonably conclude your documents include a calendar for revolutionary meetings so you should be required to provide that information and/or information required to receive that. The "foregone conclusion" stuff is narrower than Ars makes it out to be. The gist of the 5th amendment is that the government can make a defendant do things but not transfer information.[1] Sometimes, an action can implicitly transfer information. The foregone conclusion rule just says that if the government already has the information, then the action does not additionally transfer information. In your hypothetical, the foregone conclusion rule would not apply because even if the government "could reasonably conclude" that you have a calendar, producing it would still confirm that conjecture (and thus transfer information). But if the government knows you have the calendar, however, because your sister testified that you keep a calendar of revolutionary meetings, then producing it becomes a pure action. [1] I'd actually argue that the gist of the 5th amendment is even narrower than that: the government literally can't put you on the stand to testify against yourself, or enter into evidence a coerced confession. That's it.
- blubb-fish 10y agoa safe will simply be cracked if there is a warrant. easy as that.
- kelnos 10y agoKind of missing the point: let's say it's a safe that is incredibly difficult to crack, and there's a 90% chance of making a mistake that will trigger a failsafe that will destroy the contents of the safe. In that scenario, the authorities would be unlikely to attempt to crack it.
- bluesign 10y agoHow this works if there is other evidence in the HDD, for example piracy, list of stolen goods, location of bodies he buried. How 'foregone conclusion' can be applied?
- olliej 10y agoThanks for the answer! :D
- RangerScience 10y agoIf I understand the parent post, it's basically protecting you against the "leading questions" of investigation...? You opening the safe cannot be used as evidence against you; that would cause your action to be "testimonial", and protected. The contents of the safe are evidence, and not testimonial. If I'm understanding this correctly; it would be like saying "open the safe with the illegal weapons in it", and pointing at the safe. If you open it, does that mean you're admitting the weapons are illegal?
- rayiner 10y ago> If I'm understanding this correctly; it would be like saying "open the safe with the illegal weapons in it", and pointing at the safe. If you open it, does that mean you're admitting the weapons are illegal? Kind of, yes. The non-contrived situation where this comes up is with subpoenas. A subpoena will request specific documents or specific kinds of documents. Responding to the subpoena requires making judgments about what documents are responsive to the request, and there is an implicit assertion that documents produced fall within the scope of the subpoena request. So the government cannot, for example, make you "produce all accounting records containing false numbers." Producing documents in response to that comes with the implicit admission that the accounting records are false. The government can eliminate that problem simply by asking for all accounting records.