5 ms·
It's not as black and white as you make it. If there is a warrant to search my property, I am obligated to assist if required. E.g. open the gun safe. (Hey, sp
by paulddraper 10y ago
It's not as black and white as you make it.
If there is a warrant to search my property, I am obligated to assist if required. E.g. open the gun safe. (Hey, speaking of guns...You know what other antedquated amendment from the Founding Fathers would be really convenient to ignore...)
Now, AFAIK, no one has tested whether that still hold true of a combination safe, where the access substaintivly requires information from the accused.
And a combination safe is very similar to an encrypted drive.
- naasking 10y ago> If there is a warrant to search my property, I am obligated to assist if required. I'm not sure that's true, the police are authorized to break whatever they need to if you don't assist. As for combo safes, this seems like a good overview: http://blogs.denverpost.com/crime/2012/01/05/why-criminals-should-always-use-combination-safes/3343/ http://blogs.denverpost.com/crime/2012/01/05/why-criminals-s...
- paulddraper 10y agoYes, they can proceed without your assistance. Also, they can charge you with obstruction with justice.
- Chris2048 10y agoWhat's the penalty that goes with such a charge?
- paulddraper 10y agoIDK, but you can't keep breaking the law, and have penalties stop. So it won't be one-and-done.
- Chris2048 10y agoYeah, but in this case you have to weigh it against the penalty for being proven guilty. Maybe indefinite detention, and a chance at public attention is better than life in prison as a convicted child molester.
- naasking 10y agoAre you sure about that? I don't think warrants require you to assist the police in their search, you simply can't obstruct them, so they can't charge you with anything.
- paulddraper 10y agoThat you can be forced to produce a known piece of physical evidence is the premise of the very article you quoted, so yes, I am pretty sure.
- trav4225 10y agoNot quite, IMO -- combination safes can be feasibly opened without the combination.
- paulddraper 10y agoEncrypted drives can be opened without the password. Difficulty varies of course, but it can be done (e.g. iPhone).
- Buge 10y agoThat was only because they chose a weak password. With a 100+ bit password, it's impossible.
- CompuHacker 10y agoImprobable.
- michaelmrose 10y agoWhen the average time to unlock is equal or greater to the probably heat death of the universe this distinction ceases to matter.
- cmdrfred 10y agoYou could also get it right on the first guess, so its improbable not impossible.
- paulddraper 10y agoTrue, though 100 bit passwords are extremely uncommon. Even deadhorsebatterystaple claims to be less than 50.
- cesarb 10y ago> Encrypted drives can be opened without the password. No, they can't. The way it's done is by trying many passwords until the right one is found. Once you have the right password, you can use it to decrypt the drive's contents, but then you are "opening it with the password". (IIRC, there were some bad "hardware encryption" HDDs where the password wasn't actually used to encrypt the drive's contents, just verified against something in the drive's NVRAM; these can be bypassed. But that's not the case here.)
- 0xcde4c3db 10y agoIf I'm reading things correctly (IANAL, so it's very possible that I am not), it seems like there's not a lot of consensus. Some rulings say that the court can't compel you to disclose or use a password. Others say that per the Fifth Amendment it can't compel you to reveal "the contents of your mind", but can compel you to produce the protected items without disclosing the password, as those are covered by the Fourth Amendment rather than the Fifth. Yet others say that this is all bullshit and a password is merely a component of a mechanism, legally no more privileged than a physical key used to lock a file cabinet or storage room.
- BearGoesChirp 10y agoWhat happens when I ask for you to produce the password required by this super highly technical algorithm (insert lots of jargon to make the jury's eyes glaze over) called xor which will take the given file and turn it into another file that contains something illegal? Can you prove there isn't a password? Can you prove they didn't forget the password? Should forgetting a password for an encrypted file containing unknown material be cause for a life sentence?
- pvaldes 10y agoI wonder how could one could be safe against the next hypothetical situation. Lets suppose that there is someone motivated enough to distroy you. This people has months to mess with your system and substitute your usual decrypt command with a slightly modified version that 1) decrypts a file as usual when entered the right password and 2) runs a last extra line of code that inserts a child porn image or short video in the file. The timestamp of the decrypted file was changed to now. So you will not suspect that the file has been significatively modified also in the same operation. If the decrypt executable is closed and not easily available to examine... what could you do to prove your innocence? Is possible for the jury (or the lawyer) to re-encrypt the file again exactly as in the first time to detect if the file was changed?
- SCAQTony 10y ago"...LOCKED CONTAINERS - AN OVERVIEW: John P. Besselman Senior Legal Instructor Law enforcement students often ask the question “can I search a locked container?” A better question to ask may be “when can I search a locked container?” The fact that a container is locked may not increase the possessor owner’s expectation of privacy but does limit the law enforcement officer’s access to the secured area. The ability to search a locked container will depend on the justification the law enforcement officer has for intruding into the area. The purpose of this article is to examine the different legal avenues a law enforcement officer can use to search locked containers. ..." https://www.fletc.gov/sites/default/files/imported_files/training/programs/legal-division/downloads-articles-and-faqs/research-by-subject/4th-amendment/lockedcontainers.pdf https://www.fletc.gov/sites/default/files/imported_files/tra...
- nl 10y agoPersonally, I find the Genius analysis of JayZ much more readable: Well, my glove compartment is locked So is the trunk in the back And I know my rights, so you gon' need a warrant for that And the analysis: https://genius.com/17560 https://genius.com/17560
- vilhelm_s 10y agoThere is law review paper[0] about this song. > And I know my rights, so you go’n need a warrant for that . . . If this Essay serves no other purpose, I hope it serves to debunk, for any readers who persist in believing it, the myth that locking your trunk will keep the cops from searching it. Based on the number of my students who arrived at law school believing that if you lock your trunk and glove compartment, the police will need a warrant to search them, I surmise that it’s even more widespread among the lay public. But it’s completely, 100% wrong. Caleb Mason, "JAY-Z’S 99 PROBLEMS, VERSE 2: A CLOSE READING WITH FOURTH AMENDMENT GUIDANCE FOR COPS AND PERPS", http://web.archive.org/web/20130216120816/http://slu.edu/Documents/law/Law%20Journal/Archives/LJ56-2_Mason_Article.pdf http://web.archive.org/web/20130216120816/http://slu.edu/Doc...
- ouid 10y agoit's not similar at all. No one can prove that an encrypted drive is an encrypted drive and not a random number. whereas a safe is plainly a safe.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- repples 10y agoAn encrypted drive will typically contain metadata identifying it as such, so no.
- mickronome 10y agoThere is something, I believe called shadow volumes, which are completely metadata less encrypted containers living in a sea of random numbers. While you could claim that the existence of a program able to acess such a volume would be equivalent to metadata, no actual metadata needs to exist, and the random sea could contain one or ten volumes, which without a password you could never know, only guess or assume. It is could even be possible, even likely, to create encryption schemes where several different encrypted volumes could share the exact same data blocks using something similar to homomorphic encryption. Which raises and obvious question: If the unlocked drive did not contain the data sought, can we hold someone in contempt after they did what we asked from them simply because we didn't find what we were looking for? Because we truly can't know if there is several encrypted volume in the same space without assumptions about information entropy and inaccessible configuration data. Thankfully homomorphic encryption is not really practically viable today, so that particularly nasty can of worms is not imminent to solve, but we might be well served to let out decisions be informed by it, as it breaks most assumptions of what can be known, and what can't.
- harryh 10y agoWhile it's true in a mathematical sense that one may not be able to prove that a sequence of seemingly random bits is an encrypted files that is not true in a legal sense. The law isn't about proving things 100%. The law is about weighing the available evidence and proving things to various standards (preponderance of the evidence, beyond reasonable doubt, etc). For example if if there are server logs showing I downloaded illegal files, and there are people who testify that I talked about downloading illegal files, and there is non pre-installed software on my computer that is used for encryption then probably that sequence of random bits is an encrypted file. Maybe you can't prove it mathematically, but you can prove it legally.
- michaelmrose 10y agoI don't think anyone would ever test this theory its too easy just to force the safe.
- michaelmrose 10y agoCan you explain wherein this obligation is spelled out?
- Chris2048 10y ago> I am obligated to assist What does that mean though? obligation is given meaning by the penalty for not complying.