6 ms·
Or just their ass. People can fit amazingly large things in their ass and it would bypass all airport detection. There is no real security with such big loop
by colordrops 10y ago
Or just their ass. People can fit amazingly large things in their ass and it would bypass all airport detection. There is no real security with such big loopholes.
- jacquesm 10y agoBollocks. That's one thing the millimeter scan will pick up just fine.
- jedberg 10y agoMillimeter scans only happen in US airports -- they're banned in ~Europe~ the EU and not really used anywhere else. Also you're very wrong. You can defeat a millimeter scan just by placing the contraband between your palms while your hands are clasped above your head.
- jacquesm 10y ago> Millimeter scans only happen in US airports -- they're banned in Europe and not really used anywhere else. were. https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2014/04/19/bodyscanners-zo-gaat-het-op-schiphol-a1425652 https://www.nrc.nl/nieuws/2014/04/19/bodyscanners-zo-gaat-he...
- jedberg 10y agoYou're right, it's just the EU. I fixed my comment. The point is their technology is terrible and they are easy to defeat, as has been proven many many times. They are security theater and they were only put in place because the guy in charge of what scanners were allowed at US airports happened to have a financial interest in the company that made the millimeter wave scanner.
- kogepathic 10y ago> They are security theater and they were only put in place because the guy in charge of what scanners were allowed at US airports happened to have a financial interest in the company that made the millimeter wave scanner. Yup. I have been to many airports in Africa and SE Asia that have only a metal detector, manned by someone who barely cares enough to stand there, and no one has successfully committed an act of terrorism (a la 9/11) with a plane due to it. Also when I was traveling in Japan, they had machines that could scan the contents of your water bottle so you didn't have to empty it or throw it away while going through security. I'm mildly convinced other countries don't have this because the beverage industry can sell more water/soda you're forced to throw it away when you go through security. I've also stopped arguing about going through the machines. I know they do nothing, but it's not worth the hassle security employees give you to opt out. Just stand there, knowing it's pointless, and move on.
- rangibaby 10y ago> I'm mildly convinced other countries don't have this because the beverage industry can sell more water/soda you're forced to throw it away when you go through security. That makes sense, Japanese airports have distinctly non-airport prices for food and drinks even past security.
- L_226 10y agoAnecdata: Japanese airport staff are also humans, and treat you like a fellow human. Most pleasant immigration experiences I've had were at Narita. My own country (AU) treats me like a criminal on _departure_.
- linkregister 10y agoTo be fair, the threat model of those countries doesn't include terrorist hijackings. You will surely experience a thorough screening in Israel or Frankfurt. Every major U.S. airport I've been to in the past 5 years has had ample bottle filling stations.
- kogepathic 10y ago
- cypherpunks01 10y agoWho's the guy you mention? It's hard to find the right search terms to look it up, and I haven't heard that story before.
- jedberg 10y agoRapiscan, the maker of the device, was a client of Michael Chertoff's consulting company, and he was the head of Homeland Security when the scanners were put in place by his department.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- gervase 10y agoI can say that I was required to use one to get back into the U.S. while transiting through Schiphol back in October 2013. No opt out, just the scanner and "I'm not forcing you to fly today - you can stay here." Pretty rude, too. Since then, I always transit through Heathrow. It's a logistical nightmare with all those buses, but they've never coerced me to go through a scanner. Those biometric checkpoints, on the other hand... [Note: This was with Dutch staff for British Airways; not sure if that's relevant.]
- trevyn 10y agoI experienced this at Schiphol as well, a bit after you. I told them I couldn't because of a medical condition, they gave me a pretty thorough pat-down, and let me on.
- sjf 10y agoI don't know why you say that, while there are not scanners on every security lane at Heathrow they _cannot_ be refused, there is no pat-down alternative like in the US. https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2010/jan/26/new-body-scanners-heathrow https://www.theguardian.com/uk/2010/jan/26/new-body-scanners...
- DarkCow 10y agoI believe this was previously the case, but it is now possible to opt out. I flew from Heathrow (Terminal 2) on Friday, refused the mm-wave scanner and had a pat-down in a private room instead. From Heathrow's security FAQ page (http://www.heathrow.com/more/help-with-this-website/faqs/security-and-baggage http://www.heathrow.com/more/help-with-this-website/faqs/sec...): The only alternative that can be offered to a scanner is a private search which allows for a more extensive hand-search than usual. Passengers will be escorted to a different location in the airport from the main search area (eg a private search room). The private search may involve the loosening and/or removal of clothing. A person undergoing a private search may ask to be accompanied by a witness. This alternative screening method will take significantly more time than passing through a security scanner.
- atomwaffel 10y ago
- sambe 10y agoThey are used all over Europe. Maybe some countries have opted not to use them, but I go through them every time I fly. In some cases there might be an opt-out for passengers, but they are certainly not banned.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- suvelx 10y agoThey're used heavily in Australia too. And I always get picked up by them. I think the person at the monitor wants to look at my weiner.
- lostlogin 10y agoAnd if you care about your radiation dose (some of us do) you will opt for a molestation rather than a zap.
- 09bjb 10y agoI tried researching this a while back and opted for the molestation (at least one qualified for that term). I recently went back to zapping out of cumulative annoyance. Any good resources that review the radiation type and dose?
- greglindahl 10y agoUh, no. Many physicists don't like the now-discontinued X-ray backscatter machines, but the mm wave devices are not ionizing radiation. Some guy explained why non-ionizing radiation isn't a problem in 1905; won the Nobel Prize for it, too.
- jedberg 10y ago> but the mm wave devices are not ionizing radiation The science is still out on whether it's harmful or not. I got TSA pre so I can just avoid it, but before that I always opted out.
- robbiep 10y agoThe science is only still out if you believe that mobile phones are causing cancer as well- ie for those who can't, or refuse, to understand science. For everyone else it's throughly settled
- trevyn 10y agoSorry, what? "The International Agency for Research on Cancer (IARC) is part of the World Health Organization (WHO). Its major goal is to identify causes of cancer. The IARC has classified RF fields as “possibly carcinogenic to humans,” based on limited evidence of a possible increase in risk for brain tumors among cell phone users, and inadequate evidence for other types of cancer." I would not call that "thoroughly settled".
- zkms 10y agoNo. Millimetre wave (and backscatter x-ray) imagery won't penetrate skin and certainly won't reveal the presence of contraband inside a human. There's commercially available penetrating X-ray human body security scanners, but afaict those just have been used in prisons, not in airports (yet!).
- snovv_crash 10y agoThey are also used in diamond mines. In fact, that's what the LODOX (low dosage x-ray) system was first invented for.
- colordrops 10y agoTo find diamonds or to scan workers for smuggled diamonds?
- snovv_crash 10y agoScanning the workers. A full body scan is low enough dosage that it is safe to be scanned every ~3 days (IIRC), so 30% of workers would be randomly selected for a whole body scan each day when they leave the mines. Since then it has been repurposed for extreme cases like unconscious car crash victims in order to determine the extent of injuries. Or so I learned in a medical imaging elective. The technology behind it is really cool! By using temporal separation for the different parts of the image they reduce scattering blur, allowing them to use a much lower dose to get the same image quality.