4 ms·
It would be interesting to know why he has not used this excuse. Imagine having encrypted disk format where fast delete happens by writing over the main key i
by nabla9 10y ago
It would be interesting to know why he has not used this excuse.
Imagine having encrypted disk format where fast delete happens by writing over the main key in the volume header with random data and not all zero or some other magic value. You could have lots of deleted disks and memory sticks and go to jail because you can't decrypt them when asked.
- danso 10y agoIt's possible that the suspect wasn't thinking things through when he was hit with the search warrant. It says that he gave them his iPhone 5S password but not his Mac password, or the passwords for the hard drives. They apparently were able to get into the Mac (maybe the password was the same as his iPhone?) but not his hard drives. He is said to have "refused" to give those passwords. I suppose he gave up the ability to maintain a consistent defense when he said "No, I don't have/want to" instead of "I forgot". https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/rawlsopinion.pdf https://arstechnica.com/wp-content/uploads/2017/03/rawlsopin... I'm confused by this statement in the above ruling: The Forensic examination also disclosed that Doe had downloaded thousands of files known by their “hash” values to be child pornography. The files, however, were not on the Mac Pro, but instead had been stored on the encrypted external hard drives. Accordingly, the files themselves could not be accessed. So forensic analysis of the Mac revealed that he downloaded known porn files (identifiable by the database of hashes that law enforcement uses)...but don't you need access to the actual file to be able to calculate its hash? If the files were moved to, or downloaded right to the encrypted drives, how could forensic analysis reveal the files' hash values?
- skoob 10y agoI'm assuming the files were downloaded using Bittorrent or some other file sharing service, and the hashes of the downloaded files were logged on his Mac.
- danso 10y agoAh, that makes perfect sense. Since they could log into his Mac, looking at the Bittorrent metadata would be trivial (apparently he didn't clear history, or at least do so securely), and some clients would indicate not only the downloaded file, but where it was saved to locally.
- nawtacawp 10y agoAs an example of p2p, when a user attempts todownload the song “In the AirTonight,” Gnutella will notlook at filenames, but rather, for other computers sharingthat file based upon its SHA-1 hash value. If,“In the AirTonight” is being shared by multiple users then it is possible for the Gnutella network to obtain parts of the filefrom several users; instead of the user downloading theentire song from one computer, he or she will get a smallpiece from several different users sharing the same file.This allows a computer to simultaneously download different portions of the song, making the entire downloadprocess faster and more reliable.
- smsm42 10y agoOne can know the hash of the file without having it - i.e. if one got the hash as an ID from the file exchange network, and LEOs have the logs suggesting that has was used to download these files - but they don't have the files themselves.
- boogersan 10y agoThe prosecution would say that he frequently accessed the computer (which they could prove with forensic analysis) and argue it unlikely that he forgot his passphrase. The judge would accept that argument. It's scary to me because I've forgotten my encryption passphrases more than once, and I'm highly-educated.
- mickronome 10y agoAfter 18 months I definitely would be unable to comply to unlock the drive if the password was even remotely complicated. Seems like the proper thing to do with a drive you forget the password to is to zero the drive. I know I have encrypted archives of very mundane data in incremental backups which I have no clue as to what the password is, and due to the technology involved it's almost impossible to remove the files without risking to compromise the ability to restore other files. Ooops.