3 ms·
What if all but about a dozen with a great reputations (MIT and others, as he said) and about a dozen hidden gems have the problems Zed describes? Or do you hav
by benatkin 16y ago
What if all but about a dozen with a great reputations (MIT and others, as he said) and about a dozen hidden gems have the problems Zed describes? Or do you have a solid argument against it?
Also, the dozen hidden gems don't do the people asking Zed for help any good, because they're hidden. They're great for the people that happen to be going to them, but if an outsider thinks one might be a hidden gem, it's not a great risk.
My computer science education at a small state university exhibited all the problems Zed describes, and more. For all classes, except those taught by two or three of the instructors, there was very little culture. We were taught what was a subset of what was in the books, designed to help mediocre students pass. Learning extra was not encouraged. How the knowledge came about, or is used practically, is glossed over. Half of my classes were Computer Science, but what I remember is mostly from non-CS courses. And on top of it, a lot of teachers gave me pointless exercises and confusing tests and some had grading that wasn't at all straightforward. Less dedicated students who knew how to game the system did much better than me, grade-wise.
- hga 16y agoAnd you know, it doesn't take much to teach context and (domain specific) culture while the professor is teaching the basic course. Look at these quotes from my favorite chemistry professor: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_S._Kemp#Quotes http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Daniel_S._Kemp#Quotes Ummm, well, OK, except for the first one they aren't so great, but let me relate this tremendously useful and memorable anecdote he told us in first term organic chemistry: There was a company manufacturing a molecule and at some point their yield randomly started going to hell, an impurity wasn't getting removed. They just about went crazy trying to figure out what changed until they set up 24x7 cameras, reviewed the footage and found out that a night watchman was relieving himself into the vat. But here's the neat part: it was only when he did that that they got pure product and the cause of their new problem was his semi-retirement and not working as many nights as he had been. Their real problem, of course, what that they didn't truly understand their process, they didn't realize they needed to e.g. include some urea or whatever to complex with the impurity and help it get washed out.