3 ms·
Does it make more sense than the previous security procedure that everyone passengers had to take off their shoes and have them scanned? Or the current ban on
by belorn 10y ago
Does it make more sense than the previous security procedure that everyone passengers had to take off their shoes and have them scanned?
Or the current ban on liquids?
Or the even better idea I saw in Brussels airport of two semi-identical security checks; one to get into the airport and then the "regular" second one. I can only wait for the next improved version of three security checkpoints, which will add 50% more secure then the current two.
After 9/11, sensibility went out the window. This new move is quite far from the stupidest I have seen.
- robotresearcher 10y agoMultiple checks are not stupid at all. The screening is not 100% reliable and an independent repeat is a reasonable way to improve detections of weapons, which have been shown to get through sometimes in TSA and third-party experiments.
- belorn 10y agoI recall reading that TSA has never actually stopped a real threat to a airplane. The screening is one of the least cost-effective security mechanism in use, so are we suggestion that doubling it and the costs is a reasonable way to improve detections? A reasonable way to detect threats would be to hire more investigators and bomb dogs patrols. Both has shown to be cost-effective and to produce results, in direct contrast to the TSA screening method.
- robotresearcher 10y agoI'm not a fan of security theatre. But the TSA does not have to catch anyone to be very effective. In fact it its intended deterrence effect was effective it would never catch anyone at all.
- belorn 10y agoSo does the deterrence effect increase by the number of screenings? The physiological effect is not measurable in this case, and if we compare it to the placebo effect which is measurable, there is little proof that eating two fake pills has any benefit over eating one. How big portion of terrorists is likely to completely ignore the fact of one screening but be deterred by the existence of a second one?
- robotresearcher 10y agoRationally, the deterrence should increase monotonically with the chance of being caught. With two serial 90% effective checks, you have a 99% effective system. Such a low chance of success means attackers should try something else instead. Now, with probably not even close to 99% screening, along with cockpit doors and fight-motivated passengers, the deterrence seems powerful enough that we are seeing other kinds of attacks.
- belorn 10y agoWhere did you pull that 90% effectiveness from? People don't believe 90% in a fake pill, and by eating two get to 99% belief. Either you believe the fake pill will work or you don't. The number of pills don't multiply the placebo effect. Why believe that security theater, ie fake security, increase the physiological effect in multiplicate way based on the number of identical copies? If the placebo effect could be multiplied in such a way, every sickness could be cured by just eating more and more sugar. If a fake pill had 1% placebo effect, eating ~500 fake pills would reach 99% effectiveness. That is obviously not how the placebo effect works.
- robotresearcher 10y agoX-ray machine screenings are not placebo. They aren't perfect, but if you put a handgun in your carry on, there's a pretty good chance they'll find it. And yes I know there are failures. But it's not reasonable to say that the current security check is placebo only. Ask yourself: would you put a gun or knife in your carry on to prove the point? The 90% figure I made up as an example. I don't know the real figure. But I don't fancy my chances getting a weapon through security.
- pavel_lishin 10y agoVacuuming the living room rug with a broken vacuum twice isn't going to make it significantly cleaner.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kgwgk 10y agoThe security check to get into the airport makes sense if you want to avoid terrorist attacks at the airport.
- belorn 10y agoBut why not just move the original check then to the edge of the airport, expanding the "safe zone".
- kgwgk 10y agoThe second check to get into a plane is more exhaustive. They let you introduce liquids into the airport!
- waqf 10y agoIstanbul Atatürk has a security check to get into the airport. Guess what, the terrorists simply attacked the people in line at the first security check!
- belorn 10y agoThe third screening should naturally be moved to the train station before the airport. That will solve it.