3 ms·
I agree that it is odd, but it isn't categorically impossible from first principles. For a simple example, consider two plates near each other, one with a posi
by btilly 10y ago
I agree that it is odd, but it isn't categorically impossible from first principles.
For a simple example, consider two plates near each other, one with a positive charge and the other negative close together. That's a capacitor. Now physically pull the plates a bit away. Voila! Every individual piece is in the same state yet you now have more energy stored!
- hwillis 10y agoThe voltage changes in that case. In this case, a voltage difference exists between two materials with the same voltage relative to reference. It is as if you got pure gasoline out of a cars tailpipe.
- tcpekin 10y agoI think they start with Li on one side, and a Cu/C/S cathode on the other, and then plate the lithium on the anode. They measure a difference in chemical potentials between cathode and anode, so there is reason for the Li to move, and as the Li moves, I think I remember the V_cell decreasing. From the paper: > At the cathode, the build-up of plated metallic lithium changes the morphology of the cathode to increase C_C and create a very slow fade of V_cell with time of discharge
- btilly 10y agoYes, but you can make the voltage not change. Take the same capacitor, but make each plate into 2 layers. Pull the outer layers away and attach your electrodes to the inner layers. You can arrange to have more energy, at the same voltage. As the capacitor discharges, bring the outer layers in to keep the voltage across the inner plates constant. Reverse the process as it charges. Please be clear, I'm not claiming that their battery works this way, or even that it works at all. I'm only making the claim that it is actually possible to design a device where what looks impossible here is not necessarily impossible.
- mrfusion 10y agoWait. there's more energy if you pull the capacitor plates apart? What're does it come from? How much more energy are we talking about?
- ScottBurson 10y agoSince the plates attract each other electrostatically -- one is positively charged, the other negative -- it takes energy to pull them apart. The amount depends on various factors: the size of the plates, how close they are together, how much charge is on them.
- mrfusion 10y agoIs there a formula for that? I'm curious now.
- kmill 10y agoCV=Q. Pulling plates apart makes the capacitance C decrease, while the charge Q remains constant. This means V must be increasing. Energy in a capacitor is VQ/2, so the energy increased. (This is somewhat circular reasoning. The point is that the charges on capacitor plates attract each other so it takes work to separate the plates. Integrating the force along the path the plate takes during the separation gives the extra energy stored in the capacitor.) A similar thing is a static generator made using a pie tin. You put a little charge on the pie tin by some means, like rubbing on styrofoam, and then you separate the tin from the styrofoam, which gives more energy to the tin (increases the voltage), which then you can transfer to a Leyden jar. I also discovered in high school that you can use a pair of plastic chairs and two willing participants to generate high voltages when there is low humidity. Person one stands up off the chair, touches person two, then sits down. Person two then stands up off the chair, touches person one, then sits down. Repeat. Eventually, you will generate fairly high voltages that sort of hurt. You can hear the excess static charge on the chair squeal into the atmosphere after standing up.