6 ms·
The Coming War: ARM versus x86
- MikeCapone 16y agoI'd love to see ARM compete more directly with x86. Ever since AMD stopped really being able to compete with Intel on tech, x86 has been in need of more healthy competition (even if, to Intel's credit, it hasn't been resting on its laurels). Anything that makes our chips faster, more power-efficient, and cheaper is very welcome. I wonder if combining ARM with GPGPU could help it push into x86 platforms...
- lsc 16y agonow, ever since Intel copied AMD's hyper transport architecture, people have been saying that it's over for AMD. I don't really get it, as the 12 core AMD systems are extremely impressive, for loads that thread well enough to use that many cores. In recent memory, it seems that Intel has been following AMD technologically, albeit at higher clock speeds. First, they copied the amd64 instruction set, and then they copied the hyper transport architecture. Right now, it looks like Intel occupies the high end of the market, but as far as I can tell, their lead is based as much on superior sales ability than on any technological lead. For loads that thread well, they beat the intel chips both in work done per watt consumed, and they absolutely destroy intel chips on cost to acquire, so I'm not sure why people seem to think that AMD is down for the count.
- Groxx 16y agoLess advertisement for AMD gets my vote. Given their purchasing of ATI and as many of the best GPU workers as they could get their hands on, I think they're gearing up for a big blow eventually. But there's definitely more news about Intel's omg-latest-and-greatest, from what I've seen.
- wlievens 16y ago> I wonder if combining ARM with GPGPU could help it push into x86 platforms... OpenCL's the name of the game, but ARM missed that train when it had the chance (and the tech) in-house and got rid of it.
- pavlov 16y agoSounds interesting, can you explain what you're referring to?
- wlievens 16y agoOpenCL is a proposed framework for GPGPU-like computing. I worked at ARM in their Belgian office, and when they announced considering shutting us down, one of the alternative proposals was to redesign the technology we were working on to suit OpenCL. It wouldn't have been trivial but it was certainly possible. ARM never took the proposal under consideration, either because they're not interested in OpenCL or because they have different plans lined up for it.
- r0s 16y agoThe way I understand it, AMD was in bad financial shape after purchasing ATI. Then they did the conservative thing by letting Intel release i7 unchallenged, and investing in their process/research for the next big release they do. MaximumPC had a good article on this back in the day.
- sliverstorm 16y agoThe article attempted to spend it's time pushing ARM, and I'm a big fan of ARM. Yet I couldn't help but come away primarily very impressed by the VIA chip.
- msbarnett 16y agoThe performance was great, but the report makes it clear that it's very Apples to Oranges. > The AMD and VIA systems are inappropriate for power comparisons because they are based on desktop hardware.
- sliverstorm 16y agoI know, but it's still very cool to see a company that isn't even the third most prominent company doing so well. Especially when they make embedded and non-x86 chips, too. When I say 'third', I'm attempting to make an awkward reference how I see politics. There are Democrats and Republicans (AMD and Intel), and that's where most of the struggle happens. Then you have the Green Party, hanging out as a third wheel (who I'd equate to PPC), and then you have the Libertarians. I would equate VIA to the Libertarians. I don't know how they are doing as compared to the Green Party, but said Party sure got a lot more press when I was growing up.
- kenjackson 16y agoI also thought that Atom did very well against ARM. I actually was expecting ARM to do better than what the charts showed. I'd love to see these numbers against Moorestown.
- lsc 16y agoeh, when I can buy a arm netbook with a reasonable keyboard, I will do so. If someone wants to sell a high-density rack of ARM boards,I'll buy those too (and rent them out.) Right now, the available arm boards i've found cost about as much as the atom boards, while the atom supports 4GiB ram, and the arm boards usually come with 256MiB. Obviously, this makes the arm boards I've found commercially infeasible for the sort of hosting I sell. I don't think it's anything inherent to the arm architecture, I think there just isn't anyone currently designing arm boards for people doing what I do.
- kaib 16y ago> If someone wants to sell a high-density rack of ARM boards,I'll buy those too I'd love to see something like this as well. Just CPU, memory and networking (disks can be served from other machines).
- lsc 16y agoI think the first step is to get some arm motherboards with socketed ram (I'm sorry, but 256MiB ram per server... does not cut it, even in my market.) After that, it's a matter of metal working and a power/network backplane. Personally, I'd prefer a local storage option... separate disks either adds a great deal of expense or a great deal of complexity, or performance issues.
- pjscott 16y agoI would also like ARM processors with a 64-bit address space. Sometimes 4 GB of memory just isn't enough. And sometimes you need to mmap some big files. Still, ARM would be great for some server tasks.
- lsc 16y agohah. first get me a board that can handle more than 4GB of ram, then we can start worrying about 64-bit address space.
- 16y ago
- achille 16y agoI don't get it -- I read through the entire review and I was hard pressed to find where ARM shined. The VIA chip was faster in most tests, Intel followed, the aging AMD chip came usually third and ARM last. The Intel Atom used ~3x more power and delivered ~2x the performance. The Arm chip had issues running several tests, had graphics issues and its memory channel was limited. Why again was the author talking so highly of ARM?
- AndrewDucker 16y agoBecause it used less power. And thus, in a phone, it's the superior architecture.
- bad_user 16y agoNot only for phones ... processing power per watt + the cost of acquisition (ARM is cheaper) is also important in a data-center.
- hga 16y agoUntil we can point to a data center that is built with them, that's only theoretical. It may happen soon as multi-core Cortex A9s hit the market.
- gvb 16y agoThe Innovator's Dilemma explains why. The response "I don't get it -- I read through the entire review and I was hard pressed to find where ________ shined" is exactly what entrenched companies said a year or two before they were destroyed by the lower capability (but growing) competitors. In The Innovator's Dilemma, Christensen spends quite a bit of time on the disk drive case study, where over several generational transitions the entrenched bigger-faster-better companies when under because they could not match their lower capability (smaller, but more expensive in the case of hard drives) competitors. When the competitors broke out of their niches and into the mainline with size competitive products, they destroyed the entrenched companies with their cost advantages. ARM owns the low power niche and now it is threatening to catch up with Intel - being "good enough" - in low value moderate performance market. The traditional response of an entrenched company is to retreat to "higher ground," in this case more complex, faster desktops and servers. The problem is, "higher ground" has limited height and the low areas of that high ground keep eroding. Intel is addressing the threat with lower power (and slower) chips - the Atom. It will be very interesting to see if Intel can stave off their dilemma and become competitive with ARM on the low power, moderate performance, extremely low cost front... and that last part extremely low cost is both the key and Intel's Achilles heel. References: * http://www.amazon.com/Innovators-Dilemma-Revolutionary-Business-Essentials/dp/0060521996 http://www.amazon.com/Innovators-Dilemma-Revolutionary-Busin... * http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disruptive_technology http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Disruptive_technology
- kittenparade 16y agoIf anybody in the UK is interested, Sophie Wilson (who designed the original ARM instruction set) will be speaking about her time at Acorn at the Vintage Computer Festival (Bletchley Park) on June 19th/20th http://www.bletchleypark.org.uk/calendar/event_detail.rhtm?cat=special&recID=594620 http://www.bletchleypark.org.uk/calendar/event_detail.rhtm?c...
- c00p3r 16y agoWhat war? ARM already won the next generation of the mobile consumer devices. There are tens of millions of them sold. x86-based smartphones, MIDs or even tablets are nonsense, just because the only goal of x86 is Windows binary compatibility. Anyone needs Windows 7 on their [i]phone? ARM with Android is the new mainstream for the mobile segment, while atom-based low-powered linux "servers" is just a small niche for systems involved in monitoring and other low-intensity tasks.
- hga 16y agoAccording to Wikipedia, 10 billion (thousand million) sold as of January 2008 and it's predicted that 5 billion will be sold in 2011. The current yearly rate broke 1 billion in 2005 or earlier.
- mustpax 16y agoI'm surprised nobody here is talking about the instruction set architecture aspect of this. CISC won the first round of RISC vs. CISC saga. X86 is bloated, legacy mess. It has been riding on the coattails of Intel's success in marketing ("Intel Inside"), silicon wafer production process (a couple generations ahead of AMD), and Microsoft's desktop platform (which only runs on X86). RISC is a better architecture that should have won, and it's finally going to get its time in the sun.
- ergo98 16y ago_Checks Watch_ Is it 1989 again? We've had these horribly boring CISC versus RISC arguments since back in the late 80s/early 90s. Your arguments for why x86 keeps winning are ridiculous. As to RISC versus CISC, in some ways the former is like "native code" and the latter is like "VM byte code" (ala Java byte code, .NET byte code). The former is heavily optimized, but can't adapt well to different hardware/environments, while the latter isn't as fast out of the gate, but it can be heavily optimized. Which is exactly what every modern processor does. X86 to a Xeon is just like Java byte-code, and gets interpreted into something very different in the magical internals of the processor.
- mustpax 16y agoYour analogy to native vs. byte code is apt, but the question is not whether we can JIT-compile byte code to run as fast as native code (we can). The question is, what instruction set allows us to write the best compilers. I would argue that the answer is RISC. Every time Intel adds yet another instruction for doing the same thing, it makes every compiler's job harder. Intel's C compiler is faster than most others because they know their overly convoluted instruction set best. Simpler instruction set means more resources to focus on the few instructions that exist both for the chip manufacturer and the compiler vendors. On a somewhat related note, Java byte code uses a very-Reduced ISC, a simple stack machine.
- bad_user 16y ago> X86 to a Xeon is just like Java byte-code, and gets interpreted into something very different in the magical internals of the processor. Err, no, the interpretation mechanism is actually pretty similar, kind of being shared between microprocessors, with special optimizations here and there but nothing magical ;)