4 ms·
Shadow of the Colossus has always, to me, felt like that sort of game. It's one of the few I've seen/played that felt like something other than just an escape i
by Jtsummers 10y ago
Shadow of the Colossus has always, to me, felt like that sort of game. It's one of the few I've seen/played that felt like something other than just an escape into fantasy. The consequences of the actions, the tragedy of the circumstances and outcomes, lend itself to introspection and contemplation for the player/audience.
- rrauenza 10y agoI believe my wife (as did many others) responded to Ebert's blog entry years ago with that exact example. He mentions Shadow of the Colossus it in a response: http://www.rogerebert.com/rogers-journal/okay-kids-play-on-my-lawn http://www.rogerebert.com/rogers-journal/okay-kids-play-on-m... It's funny, Ebert said that games aren't art because they give you choices... and in a way, Shadow of the Colossus gives you none.
- Jtsummers 10y ago> It's funny, Ebert said that games aren't art because they give you choices... and in a way, Shadow of the Colossus gives you none. I think his outsider perspective made it difficult for him to appreciate that these things, examples of what he wanted, already existed. Myst is another (sort of) example, where the number of choices are actually more limited than it immediately appeared. I'm not really certain that they'd actually be great art, but they're demonstrations that the medium is capable of it. Which he later admits, though I think his timeline for when it will happen (if it hasn't happened yet) was way off.
- vacri 10y ago> Ebert said that games aren't art because they give you choices That has to be the dumbest requirement for 'art' I've ever heard. Especially coming from a professional critic, who earns his paycheck by interpreting art for others (ie: making choices about what it means). Or, on a simpler level, there can be no such thing as interactive art with that definition.
- rrauenza 10y agoI don't agree with Ebert, but it is subtler than that. You get to choose how to interpret the art, but it is still presented as the 'auteur' intended. In a movie context, you don't get to pick and choose what scenes you see in what order. The author of the movie has complete artistic control of every moment on the 2D screen. Ideally. A photograph/painting is static. I think if we had true 3D (holographic?) movies he'd argue those aren't art as well because you could walk to any position in the scene to see the action from a viewpoint you pick, whereas his concept of art is that the director / editor picked very specific angles for you to view the scene to evoke a specific feeling. He'd probably argue the Lytro photographs aren't art, either, since you the viewer get to pick the focal plane. That, I think, is where he gets caught up in choice -- and that's where I mean that his concept of choice is very one dimensional. I think he felt you making choices in the game takes away from the author's control, and that lack of control made it not art. In a sense, he expects the artist to be active and the consumer to be passive, except for experiencing the art. ...I could be wrong, but that's the impression I got from his writing. (...and I think he was wrong.)
- aaron-lebo 10y agoYou've watched Reign Over Me one too many times. Just kidding. But there really are no consequences. You get smashed by one colossus and respawn. Pure escapism. It is a beautiful game, though. It's thought highly of maybe because the writers didn't do too much. Too many devs think you want to spend six hours watching their bad writing.
- Jtsummers 10y agoI had no idea what that movie was until I googled it. I mean the ultimate consequence, of destroying creatures that (seemingly) harbor no ill-will to anyone not attacking them for the sake of someone who's dead, in a desperate attempt to bring them back to life. The consequence of the main character not truly achieving their goal, and, even if they had, what of them would remain for the person they loved?
- astrange 10y agoNieR deletes all your save files at the end of one story branch. I don't think we need an arms race of games trying to have "real consequences" like that though.
- jszymborski 10y agoI think that this is the all-but-expressed motivation behind Lev Grossman's "The Magicians" series. The VC pitch would be "First half is Skins set at Hogwarts, Second half is Trainspotting, except the rave scene is Narnia"
- Jtsummers 10y agoI generally avoid reading contemporary (< 10 years old) novels, especially series, for fear they'll turn out to be part of the 90% of everything that's crap. How is this one? Because that premise sounds interesting enough to me to want to read, especially since I'm about to spend a week recuperating from surgery and don't care to spend it online.
- lbotos 10y agoIt's decent but I'd firmly put it in the category of "pop-lit" vs "modern lit". It's very present day and I don't think the writing was anything spectacular but it is a fun "quick" read for sure. I'd say give the first a shot, and if you aren't interested, you won't miss much skipping the rest.
- egypturnash 10y agoIf you loved Narnia as a kid, and just couldn't go back when you tried to re-read it as an adult because of all the Christian allegory you missed the first time, it's pretty damn good. It also helps to have had a dream, attained it, and had it fall apart in front of you. I had both of those experiences and I devoured the Magicians books with glee.
- rockostrich 10y agoIt's enjoyable. I have some problems with the decisions of characters and the world building, but overall I think they can be mostly overlooked. I hate to say it's a more mature Harry Potter, but it really feels that way.
- selimthegrim 10y agoI read it almost as a parable of people who didn't make it into <insert selective thing of their dreams here> and what they choose to do with the rest of their lives
- CoolGuySteve 10y agoYes, there are a few others too. Dark Souls and its emphasis on patience/reward makes you a more conscientious person. The Walking Dead series makes you contemplate the consequences of quick moral choices more than most games I've played. Will Wright has commented on The Sims' relationship with materialism: > People frequently comment on the materialistic bent of "The Sims," but if anybody has played it in that direction as far as they can, they realize that every object you buy is a potential time bomb. They all can break or have some failure state. And so if you start pulling up your house and buy all the stuff, pretty soon you find that you're spending all your time fixing this stuff and they become a giant time sink instead of time savers--which I think has something to say about materialism. And another Will Wright quote that sums up the whole situation: > "Games are not the right medium to tell stories," said Wright in a CNN interview, adding that they're "more about story possibilities." > "Television is a very different thing from video games. It's kind of hard for me to compare."