17 ms·
One of the nice things about this is the last section (if you can bear to read that long). Both people comment on the strengths of the opponent's BSD: OpenBSD i
by jcranmer 10y ago
One of the nice things about this is the last section (if you can bear to read that long). Both people comment on the strengths of the opponent's BSD: OpenBSD is complemented on "tackling very important project [sic] which would probably have never happened otherwise" (e.g., OpenSSH), particularly also the fact that OpenBSD cares to see their projects ported to !BSD (e.g., Linux). Meanwhile, FreeBSD is complemented on "its [sic] a real “enterprise” oper-
ating system and I think it is slowly filling the
spot left by Solaris."
At the end of the day, both OpenBSD and FreeBSD are niche systems. They don't have the popularity of Linux, and they probably never will. But that's not a problem. Both of them are major operating systems that do innovate, and hence they're worth paying attention to. That's where the compliment of FreeBSD as becoming Solaris's successor is really telling--Solaris was the operating system that brought us DTrace and ZFS, and it was FreeBSD who I believe had the first container system (jail).
- _delirium 10y agoI can see FreeBSD picking up a good part of the ex-Solaris marketshare in terms of users, but have they really taken over the role in terms of development? As far as I can tell, ZFS in particular has its canonical upstream development in the Illumos repository (Illumos is the successor to OpenSolaris), which FreeBSD pulls from, rather than development having really moved to FreeBSD as the new canonical home. FreeBSD developers are certainly involved in contributing code upstream, but then, so are a number of other developers, including from the major Illumos vendors (OmniTI and Joyent), and even some from ZFSonLinux.
- RantyDave 10y agoSmartOS also has working Linux compatible Zones. Last time I looked, FBSD was a way short of this...
- _delirium 10y agoEven without the Linux-compatible aspect, Illumos Zones are considerably ahead of FreeBSD jails these days imo. Better tooling, resource limiting infrastructure, etc., especially if you want to run multi-tenant with untrusted tenants. Jails did pioneer the concept, though.
- JdeBP 10y agoFocussing on solely ZFS is rather missing jcranmer's point, though, which wasn't about ZFS but was about the level of innovation generally surrounding FreeBSD. As such, where ZFS development lives is not as relevant as where the next such project will arise, and whether it is possible that it will be on FreeBSD.
- digi_owl 10y agoMy impression was that to get the OpenBSD stuff, OpenSSH etc, working on Linux they required quite a bit of out of tree patching.
- notaplumber 10y agoOpenBSD developers maintain the portable versions of OpenBSD software. It's simply easier/cleaner for them to maintain the portable bits (compat code, build system) outside of the projects source tree. "Write code according to OpenBSD standards, fix outliers later."
- gshulegaard 10y ago> and it was FreeBSD who I believe had the first container system (jail). This is an interesting tidbit that I had not considered before! It would appear you are correct, but I would mention that the appearance of "jail" in FreeBSD 4.0 is very close to the appearance of OpenVZ (at least from the cursory look up I did).
- mioelnir 10y agoWhile 4.0-REL was released in March 2000, and the OpenVZ history section starts with the concept phase in November 1999, the commit that upstreamed jails into FreeBSD was made in April 1999 with comment `Run for almost a year by: ...` https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base?view=revision&revision=46155 https://svnweb.freebsd.org/base?view=revision&revision=46155
- jsiepkes 10y agoBryan Cantrill has a nice talk which starts with a bit of history on containers (chroot, FreeBSD jails, Solaris zones, etc.). https://youtu.be/hgN8pCMLI2U https://youtu.be/hgN8pCMLI2U
- pvg 10y agoSince you are [sic]-ing - it's 'complimented', in this case. http://blog.oxforddictionaries.com/2011/04/compliment-or-complement/ http://blog.oxforddictionaries.com/2011/04/compliment-or-com...
- ChuckMcM 10y agoI have a some interest in investing the time and effort into making FreeBSD a solid developer workstation environment. I don't want Solaris, I want SunOS.