6 ms·
So in April 2019, the NHS's budget will increase by £350 million / week. Right?
by pavlov 10y ago
So in April 2019, the NHS's budget will increase by £350 million / week. Right?
- lispm 10y agoNot only that: there will be no more unwanted immigrants, there are no more negative effects of globalization, the tories will care about remote rural areas, the queen gets a new ship, making decisions doesn't require talking to your neighbors, the economy will boom, the empire will be a large free trade zone, ... Though, not everything is rosy: The Germans will still win the football games.
- cjrp 10y agoAnd "Rule Britannia" will blare from every lamp post on a constant loop. Glorious!
- moomin 10y agoDon't forget the blue passports...
- lostboys67 10y agoAnd reverting to proper Imperial units none of those commie SI units back to "Thous" :-)
- chrisseaton 10y agoI think this was the proposal of a campaign group, not of the Givernment. The campaign group aren't in power, even though the referendum went their way. So it isn't reasonable to expect policies they proposed would be be enacted, whether or not you support the policy or the policy made any sense.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoThere was an official leave and an official remain campaign (as well as some unofficial ones). The £350m NHS promise was part of the official leave campaign headed by Boris and Gove. "The pledge was central to the official Vote Leave campaign and was controversially emblazoned on the side of the bus which shuttled Boris Johnson and Michael Gove around the country. "[0][1] [0] http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/06/24/nigel-farage-350-million-pledge-to-fund-the-nhs-was-a-mistake/ http://www.telegraph.co.uk/news/2016/06/24/nigel-farage-350-... [1] https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/brexit-vote-leave-wipes-nhs-350m-claim-and-rest-of-its-website-after-eu-referendum-a7105546.html https://www.independent.co.uk/news/uk/home-news/brexit-vote-...
- chrisseaton 10y agoThey weren't representing HM Government when they made those suggestions. I think the claim didn't make sense either, but it wasn't proposed by any group with the authority to enact it. It wasn't a general election and Vote Leave haven't formed a government or written a Queen's Speech.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoBoris Johnson is a senior member of the government and the reason the promise isn't being fulfilled isn't because the government don't want to do it - it's because it was utter nonsense and never possible as a result of the referendum.
- whyleyc 10y agoThat's a cop out. If they didn't have the means to deliver on their promises they shouldn't have made the claims. They took highly populist positions, completely divorced from reality just to win votes, then shrugged their shoulders post-referendum when asked how they would be implemented.
- chrisseaton 10y agoBut they didn't say 'we will'. It wasn't a promise. They said 'let's' - it was a suggestion of what they thought should be done. You've imagined the promise part, and you'd be foolish to accept it as a promise, because clearly the group did not have that authority.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- cjrp 10y agoI don't see the group lobbying the Government to follow through on that "suggestion". If they believed strongly enough in the "suggestion" to put it on the side of a bus and in their leaflets, surely they should be trying to secure that £350m/week NHS funding as we speak?
- chrisseaton 10y agoYes that's true and that makes sense. That's the right question to ask - not 'why isn't this happening'. It's not happening because nobody with the authority to do it said they would.
- urbanj 10y agoNo. Brexit means Brexit, and the government is committed to fulfilling the will of the people. One of the things the people want is £350 million a weak for the NHS. This is what the people want and this it must be actioned. The will of the people must not be denied by the elites in Westminster. Anyone who doesn't agree with this is basically trying to deny the will of the people, and might even be considered to be a traitor.
- PaulRobinson 10y agoIt was the proposal of the official Leave campaign, headed by Government ministers, one of whom is the current Foreign Secretary.
- chrisseaton 10y agoBut the Leave campaign haven't formed a government so can't submit a budget, and ministers can have personal opinions and proposals that aren't government policy. Attacking the logic of the idea is sensible. Asking why it isn't happening now is ignorance of the whole setup.
- PaulRobinson 10y agoIn that case the Leave campaign should not have suggested it was a reasonable case to put forward if they never could have actually actioned it. You have to remember Leave vs Remain was for the most part government ministers arguing with each other, and the PM lost his job over the result, with the current Foreign Secretary and his colleague in the Leave campaign both planning to run for that office. To say that they are not in Government, just because they have not taken the role of PM, is shaky ground: they will be judged on this at the next election, to some extent. The problem is people still think this number is real. If they knew the true numbers, they would likely vote differently. Hence the back-pressure: now we know the numbers, it might be sensible to re-think this project in its entirety. Alas, common sense can't prevail because to point out that politicians currently serving in HMG's cabinet are lying liars who lie is politically toxic, and saving face is more important than doing the right thing by the country.
- DanBC 10y agoThey lied. It was a clear, unambiguous, blatant, lie. And although they withdrew it the morning of the referendum results, it's fair to keep reminding people that some voted "leave" because of this promise. http://imgur.com/indvx6a http://imgur.com/indvx6a http://imgur.com/AJzU5nd http://imgur.com/AJzU5nd If they were not able to keep this promise they should not have made it. They should have said that this is not something they can offer. Remember when Nolan Principles were a thing?
- agd 10y agoI don't want to get into a debate about who made 'bigger lies' because both campaigns were awful but there were lies on both sides. It's also fair to keep reminding people that some voted 'remain' because of lies about immigration, punishment budgets, costs to each UK household etc.
- k-mcgrady 10y agoWith the Scottish and Irish no longer apart of/a drain on the UK by then there should be plenty of extra capital available for the NHS. /s
- PaulRobinson 10y agoNot only has that been ruled out, but costs to the UK of being outside the EU are currently being estimated at around £60bn/year, so we will in fact have £1.15bn a week less to go around. Meanwhile NHS bosses are already warning they can't hit the target budgets for next year, and we're about to see the currency deflate to a point where imports - including agricultural produce - is going to rise in price dramatically. There is a small chance that the EU might now decide to give more generous terms than they have indicated in the past to the UK, and all will be well. That looks unlikely however.
- mattmanser 10y agoCitation? Is the cost estimated by all the same people who said that a No vote would immediately tank the UK economy, even before the official Brexit? It grew instead. The problem with pronouncements like that is we've repeatedly seen economists and independent bodies be heavily politically biased in favour of the EU and seem to heavily exaggerate consequences and costs. As someone who is disappointed by our exit, I still want to see a reasonable assessment of our chances and frankly a lot of people like the IMF, etc. increasingly look like little more than shills for the EU political elite who are desperately clinging to their federalisation plans and need those bodies to tell other countries in the EU that the consequences of even considering an exit is dire.
- PaulRobinson 10y agoOf course you're right. There is bias. However this bias is informed by pronouncements from the EU themselves declaring they want £50 billion up-front for us leaving, and models that have been updated based on agreements we can see in action elsewhere (Norway, Sweden, WTO tariffs, etc.) So... yes, it might all be wrong. But if you aren't prepared to accept any model because in the past some models were a little off, well, how are we meant to make reasonable decisions about the future.
- mattmanser 10y agoYou're still not saying where you got £60 billion per year from. If you're talking about the OBR figures, they're not a per year figure, but a one off cost. They also include something like £15 billion because of a drop in immigration. The OBR present growth figures include a built in "we're going to keep on ignoring our immigration targets" figure, and by removing that, "lost" that money. So it's basically two parts of government doing opposite things and then talking as if it's a "cost".