10 ms·
Maybe I'm being naive but how can a company that replaces a whole layer of management and overhead of traditional Taxi companies by an App not reach profitabili
by teekert 10y ago
Maybe I'm being naive but how can a company that replaces a whole layer of management and overhead of traditional Taxi companies by an App not reach profitability? Is maintaining an app that expensive? I can't imagine.
- pyvpx 10y agobecause they subsidize every ride. significantly. traditional taxis are actually profitable with what they charge. uber is not.
- hueving 10y ago>because they subsidize every ride. significantly I don't believe this is true in all markets. IIRC the heavy subsidizing behavior causing severe losses is in new markets like China.
- mandevil 10y agoNope, worse than that. Uber did have its butt kicked in China and surrendered last summer, having it's China operations purchased by Didi (the company that applied the foot to Uber's posterior). But the problem was everywhere: Uber lost 800 million in 3Q 2016 ex-China, 2.2 billion for the year. "Even in the U.S., Uber's home market, the company continues to lose money." They did manage to turn a profit in the US in 1Q2016 but lost 100 million in 2Q and the losses "increased" in 3Q, looking only at the US. Source: https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/uber-s-loss-exceeds-800-million-in-third-quarter-on-1-7-billion-in-net-revenue https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2016-12-20/uber-s-lo...
- danielweber 10y agoThat doesn't show they are losing money by subsidizing rides. From your source: > Net revenue—the amount of money Uber generates after it pays its drivers—was $1.7 billion in the third quarter, That's what it takes to be a real business. If you are a grocery store that buys bread for $1 and sells it for $2, you potentially have a real business even if you only move 20K loaves a month and need 30K to cover all expenses. People keep on alleging that Uber is somehow buying bread for $1 and selling it for less than $1. There was stupidness like this in the first dot-com bubble. You aren't a business if you are doing this. This distinction really matters. Since Uber is making money on each ride, there is a real business here.
- macNchz 10y agoI don't claim to know what's going on behind the scenes, but even years after launching in NYC, both Uber and Lyft have continued to send me notifications with steep discounts, free rides, etc. I've used both apps since they launched here and a major percentage of my rides have been discounted below 'sticker price'.
- JustSomeNobody 10y agoPoor management. If a company is not successful it is because they have a product nobody wants or they have bad management.
- bmelton 10y agoUber may indeed have poor management, but I believe you paint with far too broad a brush in this scenario. MOST companies fail. 75% of venture backed companies fail quickly. Only about 50% of all businesses are capable of lasting 5 years, and only about 35% are able to last 10 years. We have all seen companies that were offering products you wanted, but that closed for one reason or another, and it is not in every case that you can attribute it to bad management.
- Arizhel 10y agoCompanies can fold while offering products that are in-demand. The problem is that you have to have enough demand, and sell at a price that allows you to be profitable at that demand level. So it's quite possible for a company to have a product that's in-demand, such as glittery pink mechanical computer keyboards (there's got to be a few people out there who want them after all), but not be able to sell them at a price high enough to keep the company afloat. So glittery pink mechanical keyboards surely have some demand, but it's not going to be high, and the manufacturing cost of such things is going to be high, so between the low volume and high cost, that means you need to charge boutique prices. If you can't get enough people to buy them, then the company goes under. But this is still attributable to "bad management". Good management would not even try to sell a low-volume product where they cannot price it high enough to make up for the limited demand and volume, and would instead come up with a better business plan in the first place.
- iamatworknow 10y agoYou don't even need to make up your keyboard example -- just look at Pebble.
- 10y ago
- danesparza 10y agoTaxi's don't have an app to maintain. Uber does everything that Taxi's do, but also has an app (and associated server resources and operations) to maintain. Your assessment of "replaces a whole layer of management and overhead" isn't entirely true as far as I know. If anything, they have more overhead.
- kristiandupont 10y agoWould you also argue that AirBnB does everything hotels do, as well as a website?
- ncphillips 10y agoI'm not sure of their business model, but my understanding is that AirBnB doesn't set the price of the rentals or pay the home-owners, they take a cut of whatever price the homeowner decides to charge. As I see it, Uber employs drivers, whereas AirBnB facilitates BnB owners.
- officelineback 10y agoI believe you're wrong and here's why (maybe the previous poster's way of explaining it wasn't good). 1) Economies of scale. Airbnb has management and overhead but it's spread across thousands of cities. Cab co.s need a full structure for each city in which they operate. 2) Automation. Many of the manual jobs in local cab companies like dispatch and scheduling are automated. You don't call a human when you need a ride, you push a button on an app. So that's also less overhead. They are also very clever in how they treat their drivers, so labor cost is also low, and of course there is no maintenance on cars (drivers change their own oil, buy their own tires, etc). So I believe Uber could probably make money just by replacing cabs, but like others have said, they have to compete with other VC money receiving ventures that are wiling to burn money to come out on top. For now, we the customers are benefiting greatly from the situation.
- vmateixeira 10y agoYou forgot: not paying local taxes and being able to operate illegally in some countries (without public transport insurances and legal permits). Which actually also happens to be the case of Airbnb.
- dasimon 10y agoThe problem is not competition from traditional taxi companies (they do indeed replace taxi companies' management structure) but other ride sharing companies, ie Lyft. Uber has only managed to stay ahead of Lyft by undercutting Lyft's prices, incurring severe losses in the hope that as soon as they have self-driving cars they will be able to become profitable by eliminating one of their main expenses, the drivers themselves, while maintaining lower prices than Lyft. Without self-driving cars, that strategy isn't sustainable, and so eventually Uber will find itself unable to maintain its advantage over Lyft.
- CPLX 10y ago> Uber has only managed to stay ahead of Lyft by undercutting Lyft's prices, incurring severe losses in the hope that as soon as they have self-driving cars they will be able to become profitable by eliminating one of their main expenses I think someone should pause to note that, if true, this is one of the dumbest long term business strategies in the history of high finance. This idea, apparently, is a bet on a technology that not only doesn't exist, but is extremely highly regulated, that the company has literally no demonstrated core competencies in, hasn't been even successfully prototyped, that represents the hardest most complex use case of the technology, and is obviously years away at best, but yet it justifies a policy of losing billions of dollars in the present just to get market share when the costs of switching brands are literally so non-existant that a typical customer often does it several times in a single evening out. Maybe it's my old age and having lived through the first dotcom crash, but it seems to me that even when you feel like the only person who sees that the underlying business logic is nonsensical magical thinking, it's still quite possible you're correct.
- tyingq 10y agoYou aren't alone in that thought. Being privately held the financials are opaque enough that no outsider knows for sure how much of the spend is subsidizing the low prices, versus being used for expansion and R&D. The leaked data from Naked Capitalism is really the only data outsiders have at their disposal: http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver-part-one-understanding-ubers-bleak-operating-economics.html http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver... The use of EBITAR (vs EBITDA) makes it difficult to draw real conclusions, though the fact that they use EBITAR at all is suggestive on its own.
- crispyambulance 10y agoTraditional taxi companies are now increasingly employing 3rd-party apps which function much like Uber's. In many US cities, the "Curb" app will hail you a regular taxi cab and allow you to pay for the whole thing through the app (including tip, even if you just happen to hail the cab without opening the app). Uber's long-game, and the reason they've been funded so handsomely, is the autonomous taxi plan. Its a pity that taxi companies were so slow to adapt to Uber by providing convenient ways to summon and pay for a cab. All that people really want is to get from point A to point B without a hassle.
- pjmlp 10y ago> Its a pity that taxi companies were so slow to adapt to Uber by providing convenient ways to summon and pay for a cab. Have you ever picked a taxi in Nordic countries? Those guys already had Uber like apps and all possible ways of paying for a ride, before Uber was a thing.
- crispyambulance 10y agoNever, but not surprised. How is Uber doing in Nordic countries?
- pjmlp 10y agoNot sure, my last trip there has been around 2012.
- Nekorosu 10y agoTalking about Sweden Uber is just another taxi company here. It's not possible to provide taxi service without having a license. Uber has to comply. Still it's more convenient to use their app because it has better UX than everything else on Swedish market.
- gtirloni 10y agoWhich isn't hard to replicate or improve upon. Is Uber fighting the local government in Sweden to have less regulation too? It seems that's what they are doing here (Brazil).
- emodendroket 10y agoThe overhead is not as large as you're imagining. http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver-part-one-understanding-ubers-bleak-operating-economics.html http://www.nakedcapitalism.com/2016/11/can-uber-ever-deliver... > By contrast, in the hundred years since the first motorized taxi, there has been no evidence of significant scale economies in the urban car service industry. That explains why successful operators never expanded to other cities and why there was no natural tendency towards concentration in individual markets. Drivers, vehicles and fuel account for 85% of urban car service costs. None of these costs decline significantly as companies grow. As the P&L data above demonstrates, Uber has not discovered a magical new way to drive down unit costs.
- 013a 10y agoThat seems like a strange conclusion considering Uber doesn't even pay for the vehicles and fuel. UberPool is one pointed example of scale economics working. Another would be Uber's brand encouraging more riders and the ability to scale into smaller markets that taxis normally couldn't service.
- emodendroket 10y ago> That seems like a strange conclusion considering Uber doesn't even pay for the vehicles and fuel. Well, they do, indirectly, in that that is part of the money the driver is paid. Yes, one way they've improved the numbers is squeezing their drivers more, but they can't do that forever. They're already encountering a lot of pushback. I question the claim that Uber is serving a bunch of small markets that traditional livery services do not. Do you have an example?
- cat199 10y agoNot OP, but I can say from personal observation/experience that while not 'small', Uber has increased taxi use in the general sense in Texas cities that are so car-centric and-or sprawl-like that traditional taxi services were never really popular (Houston, Austin, Dallas, etc) - having more drivers available in an ad-hoc manner has made the dispatch time much more reasonable (minutes vs a hit-or-miss scheduling ordeal of ~1h) and so using taxis (e.g. Uber) as a viable means of transportation, especially for things like social events, is much more common than it was before. I suspect the same is likely in similar places where 'everyone has a car' and the geography is very spread out.
- samfisher83 10y agoThey are subsidizing the rides. They are charging you less than what they pay the driver. That is why they are losing money.
- danielweber 10y agoThat's not what private leaks show. For example, in the first half of 2015, they got $3.6 Billion from customers and paid $3 Billion to drivers.
- deleted 10y ago[deleted]
- kylehotchkiss 10y agoImagine Uber built by a team of 10 people making $75,000k each in the midwest. That would not be the worst profit share / stock payout.
- paulcole 10y agoThis classic HN-trope simply isn't possible in this case. The app, while perhaps technically impressive, is the least of Uber's problems: 1. Recruiting drivers and passengers 2. Legal issues 3. Marketing and branding 4. Support
- logicallee 10y agoNot even a dating app would be profitable if you just spent VC money on paying for (subsidizing) users' dates ;) It would be very popular though. Hey - brb!
- cauterized 10y agoBy keeping their prices below costs in order to undercut the competition.
- fs111 10y ago> Maybe I'm being naive but how can a company that replaces a whole layer of management and overhead of traditional Taxi companies by an App not reach profitability? They employ more than 2000 Engineers, many of them in the Bay Area. Those cost easily more than any manager in a Taxi corporation..
- Arizhel 10y agoYep. Amazing how you need 2 thousand engineers just to make an app (which is already made) and run some servers (which are probably hosted on AWS anyway).
- iamatworknow 10y agoI wonder if they were just overzealous in hiring and don't actually need all those employees, but now can't let them go because of the impression that would give to the industry/equity holders. Large staff cuts usually do not instill confidence in investors, even if that staff literally isn't required.
- sosborn 10y ago> just to make an app (which is already made) and run some servers I assume they want to do more than let the product stagnate, not to mention the resources they are putting into driverless vehicles.
- Arizhel 10y agoYou don't need thousands of engineers to keep a mobile app up-to-date, and the driverless vehicle thing is a boondoggle as there's already other companies doing that work, which are much better at it (Google, GM, etc.), and don't need tons of VC for such a risky endeavor.
- sosborn 10y ago> there's already other companies doing that work In your opinion, is work not worth doing if those mammoth companies are pursuing it? Also, you say it is a risky endeavor. Would you argue that the driverless vehicle is not an inevitability? I would certainly argue that betting on Uber to come out on top is risky, but that doesn't mean there isn't money to be made.
- anilshanbhag 10y agoI disagree with the other comments. I think it's because the rides are currently cheaper than they need to be. From the airport to my place, it costs 50$ via normal taxi. Via uber pool I pay $10-12. Most of the times it's only me in the car. There you have it.
- ExactoKnight 10y agoUber has massive costs as it scales, but unlike Amazon that has fixed costs, Uber's problem is that it has massive VARIABLE COSTS in three areas: driver recruitment, local advertising and local regulation. The work Uber needs to do to onboard a driver in Alberta, Canada is completely different from Ontario, Canada (e.g. drivers needing a commercial class 4 vs consumer class 5 license). As a result, they are facing unique regulations that is making it difficult to automate the work that is being done in each local market.