3 ms·
Ah yes, map projections. Time for everyone to complain about why the projection is inaccurate (because all of them are). The problem with Gall-Peters is that i
by jcranmer 10y ago
Ah yes, map projections. Time for everyone to complain about why the projection is inaccurate (because all of them are).
The problem with Gall-Peters is that it gives a misleading impression of equatorial regions--it scrunches up the width and exaggerates the height. Humans are bad at estimating area when the rectangles have different ratios for their sides--notice how Africa appears to be the same size as Asia; in reality, it's only ~⅔ the size.
So, yeah, the Mercator is horrible as a projection. Cartographers have known that for over a hundred years. Yet if you want a better map projection, there are several decent ones that are better than Gall-Peters (which is basically the inverse of the Mercator: exaggerate the equator at expense of the poles). Even if you limit yourself to equal-area, Mollweide and Eckert do better jobs of avoiding shape distortion. Outside of equal-area, well, Robinson and Winkel tripel tend to do very well, striking a decent balance between all of the different kinds of distortions.
As a general rule of thumb, any map projection that insists that it depict a globe as a rectangle seems to do very terribly.